Mafia 92: Night of the living Mafia... the play

Vote count day 3:
Ice (2): Dawg, DD
DD (5): Wiz, Pappy, Labby, Ice, Kash
Kash (3): Noods, Dday, Rich

No votes: Cnote, Tank

So, if we started the game with 5 scum, we're down to two. Looking at this list, it's hard to know what to make of it. Can't clear anyone on DD, though I doubt 2 teammates would have been on her. Kash's late move onto DD to prevent scum from making it a tie looks honorable now, but they could have decided it was likely DD was going anyway so may as well have Kash put the nail in the coffin and look good. That being said, I still think Ice is scummier than Kash. Some of Noods' recent comments have made me wonder, especially when combining it with the fact that DD kept bring up that Noods could be scum. Maybe DD was trying some reverse psychology to make Noods golden.
 
Me too. I'm not liking the list of people on DD right now though. I'm hoping we can learn from what JM is about to do...and not in a bad way either.

Ice (2): Dawg, DD
DD (5): Wiz, Pappy, Labby, Ice, Kash
Kash (3): Noods, Dday, Rich

In light of Dawg's comment, I thought I would post the vote count and look at those on DD.

Wizard-Salt of the earth, the kind of guy you would introduce to your mother. Spent 2 game days fighting tooth and nail to get DD lynched.

JP- also spent 2 game days going after DD. IMO to strongly for it to be distancing. Not clearing him but do lean him innocent.

Labby- has been more active this weekend. Hasn't posted anything that jumps out and grabs me. I have agreed with her a couple of times and that worries me. Currently on the fence neutral.

Ice- I have stated what I thought about Ice. Initially it was just a feeling that I couldn't put my finger on. His attempted orchestration of the voting today raises him high on my list.

Kashta- The nail in the coffin for DD. IMO it was her switch to DD that prevented the scum from manipulating the lynch without sticking out like a sore thumb. Leaning her innocent.
 
Lol Wiz, it worries me too that we seem to be agreeing. You did fight hard against DD, much harder than mere distancing, so I'm leaning you townie for now. Plus, you were the first vote on her.
 
So, if we started the game with 5 scum, we're down to two. Looking at this list, it's hard to know what to make of it. Can't clear anyone on DD, though I doubt 2 teammates would have been on her. Kash's late move onto DD to prevent scum from making it a tie looks honorable now, but they could have decided it was likely DD was going anyway so may as well have Kash put the nail in the coffin and look good. That being said, I still think Ice is scummier than Kash. Some of Noods' recent comments have made me wonder, especially when combining it with the fact that DD kept bring up that Noods could be scum. Maybe DD was trying some reverse psychology to make Noods golden.

Until Kashta moved the scum could have prevented DD from being lynched without it being obvious. It is easy enough to explain 1 late vote switch. I don't think they would have written her off at that point.

Some of Noods posts today have caused me to wonder. I know she sealed Razz's fate D1 but, it was also after a lot of pushing from Mad that she did so.
 
Glad we got a mafia and glad to see one UD finally.

Great work Dr

No idea why JM hit Rich, My guess would be since he is hard to read it was worth a shot but I haven't seen anything from Rich to warrant it.

Still see it as a slip so...

I vote to lynch Kash

I think they realized they weren't getting me lynched and Kash is more important to the team and DD had dug herself a deep hole.
 
I have to get this engine done. I will try to check in before going to bed.(If going to bed is an option tonight) Either way I will vote before work tomorrow and don't know if I will get back before night fall.
 
Glad we got a mafia and glad to see one UD finally.

Great work Dr

No idea why JM hit Rich, My guess would be since he is hard to read it was worth a shot but I haven't seen anything from Rich to warrant it.

Still see it as a slip so...

I vote to lynch Kash

I think they realized they weren't getting me lynched and Kash is more important to the team and DD had dug herself a deep hole.

So who do you think "they" are? Who do you think are the remaining scum?
 
Ice
Dawg
[AC] Doomsday998
Noods
Kash
Jpappy
Wiz
Lab_Rat

Looking at this list, I am pretty lost. I wanted to color code them, but I am not even sure how I would do that. Could the day 1 exchange between Ice and Doom have been distancing? Doom was much more active day 1 and now has kinda disappeared. I can't put my finger on exactly why Dawg is striking me as scummy, except him declaring we should assume all the UDs were innocent. Had Tank been innocent and not scum, I'd be more interested in his declaration (since he would have known for sure they were all innocent) but since that was not the case, I can also see why he would make that assumption based on only townies being zombies once lynched (and applying that to a UD).

Early in the game, I found myself agreeing with Noods. Right before nightfall and shortly thereafter she's started to rub me in a scummy way. DD's focus on her, knowing Noods wasn't in any danger, also makes me wonder.

Kash I can't decide on. Wiz and Pappy I'm leaning townie.
 
AquariaCentral.com