The syrum not being used. Suppose you give me your thoughts on why you think it wasn't used.
Bold Statment !?!?!? I'm posting what I'm thinking. Is your real problem that you are on the list?
Who's to say that the gingers are waiting to use the syrum on a townie PR? Why waste the syrum on Day 1 when there is not a very big chance of hitting a PR when they could wait and have a better guess later on? They also have investigations so they could be waiting for those results before using it.
I feel that saying everyone up for a test last night was innocent is a bold statement. I have no problem at all being on your list. IMO it's a weak case and with so many people on the list, I would actually have a problem not being on the list.
True, but then why not use the syrum. I can see them saving it to go after another PR, but not if they had any chance of losing a player on a late vote switch.
Lets just call it a top 5 for now.
Your right Jpap. I made that post after quickly looking at nightfall, and being very surprised that the cartoon syrum wasn't used. After looking over nightfall this morning I'm thinking everyone up was innocent. That makes this the list
Razzlefish
Dangerdoll
Allaboutfish
Jpappy
Lady G
Rich 311k
Wizzard
From that list I'm going to remove Allaboutfish, and Rich. AAF I'll still give more time, and Rich because If I'm right there would be no reason to risk a late vote move like he did.
I am not getting a good understanding on the reasons for not including AAF and Rich in your list.
From that list I'm going to remove Allaboutfish, and Rich. AAF I'll still give more time, and Rich because If I'm right there would be no reason to risk a late vote move like he did.
My post should of said..why giving AAF and Rich a pass, I know what you said in your post, but really?[/QUOTE]
I have this same question.... it's not making the best sense to me. I would think they held onto the serum until after day 1. I would think day 1 is way too early to use the serum and good thing too..... because if they were as confused about the serum as we are, they sure are getting a good explanation of it now.
I'm not sure how much more I can explain but at this point in time they have all their mafia members so there is no need to gain another. Need being the key word. If we are able to lynch/ genetically test one of the gingers, then I can see where targeting a townie is more productive. Then they could replace the one they lost. Make sense so far? As far as not using their hit, well I guess that would be a personal decision between the mafia members. Yes, they could do the same with a hit. Also, keep in mind if they turn someone, that person is going to have to rework their game play (provided they weren't already looking at the wrong people). That shift would be fairly obvious to the town and would be something everyone would be on the lookout for if we knew the syrum was used. Follow? So then everyone is suspecting that person and we vote to test them. Well that one mafia member that they gained is now lost so they are back to the number they had before, right? So I guess it would have to fit the situation, kill an innocent or turn an innocent but have them die by testing. Almost the same thing right?
I have no idea if that makes any more sense than before but trust me, it all makes sense in my head! :nilly:
wait, I might have missed something but why would mafia not have a need to gain another? They could ALWAYS use another. I am trying to make sense of your logic but it's late....
If Pir doesn't turn up scum obviously it doesn't help to clear them.
Ok, one other thing I don't understand is why Pir would be automatically thought of as mafia....
It's a long explanation but it still doesn't make sense to me. Do the math, maybe you'll see why it doesn't make sense.
You get 2 dead but the other way you have 2 townies gone and you get an additional team member possibly.
What do you mean we won't get anywhere. In fact I think it's an interesting discussion. I wonder if Razz is taking the stance he is so when the scum team uses it, if they use it on a regular townie he can say "look, I would have gone for a PR if I were scum so I can't be scum". I wonder if LG thought the serum might kill her if she used it last night.
So you voted for me A. because it was safe and B. because I was really looking hard at Kash and Plant. Would you rather me sit back and not analyze peoples' posts? Should I not point out anomalies that stick out to me?
ok, I will try to explain again.... no, I voted for you because when I was reading, all that seemed odd was your behavior change in my thoughts. you say you are analyzing posts now so you admit that you are playing close attention to the game... you missed a joke, but couldnt understand how with all you are doing with other posts, you know, your analyzing. You also came out of the gate pushing on aaf, something i did last game..... he seemed like an easy target at the time, being the noob.... last game, I was mafia. For the little I had a chance to read, work got in the way of keeping up on the thread. I was still at work and 8:35 or so rolls around and I needed to vote or UD. I made a personal goal for myself to not UD in any further games. I agree that UD does nothing for the town nor the game. While still at work, I had time to come on, vote with all I had to go on and hope for a better day today. I was not able to make any formed opinion on anyone else with how little I had read and didn't just want to jump on a train without having a reason to do it in the first place. I didn't know who you were looking at, I didn't know anyone that anyone was looking at. Now I am not understanding why you tried to fluff up my first reason I gave you which was the short version of this post. You completely made up your own reasons of either 1 or 2 that had to be my reasons. Are you forgetting that I wasn't able to make any fair assessments otherwise?
And please Labby, analyze away. It's the spirit of this game. I wouldn't want you to hold back, but please take into consideration or at least read my posts before deciding for yourself why I must have voted for you.
