Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play

[jpappy789]

UGH!! I was thinking we still had the investigator, I forgot all about Chill being the Investigator.....

funny thing is, the reason I changed my vote to Kash was because I thought G was possibly the investigator.... good thing I had that brain fart, huh

DD, what about G made you think she was the investigator over anyone else when you thought that role was still in play?

ok, if I am not mistaken, Chill had an investigation night one. Then night 1, he voted Kash and then changed his vote to Pir. Could this have been his way to let us know both were scummy?

I don't understand what this post was supposed to mean. Yes, Chill had an invest N1 but his vote were before that happened so what do the two have to do with anything?

 

[RazzleFish]

AAF, the way you are wording your posts makes it hard for me to follow. I think what might make it easier for everyone is if you went through each player one by one and gave some thoughts about them. Myself, LG and Jpapy did this not too long ago and IMO it makes things much easier to understand (for us) and helps get your point across.

Jpap, I think you're being a little hard on him. Yes he needs to contribute rather than just say it's quiet but remember this is really the first game he actually got to play so don't expect his theories to be so solid. He at least tried, right? Questions are good but he's new.

 

[jpappy789]

i might would if i heard more evidence and pir has been on my list almost at the start of the game. he just acts scummy IMO.

Fair enough although it would be nice if you got a bit more specific that just he "acts scummy."

So why do you think that Kash voted Pir?

AAF, the way you are wording your posts makes it hard for me to follow. I think what might make it easier for everyone is if you went through each player one by one and gave some thoughts about them. Myself, LG and Jpapy did this not too long ago and IMO it makes things much easier to understand (for us) and helps get your point across.

Jpap, I think you're being a little hard on him. Yes he needs to contribute rather than just say it's quiet but remember this is really the first game he actually got to play so don't expect his theories to be so solid. He at least tried, right? Questions are good but he's new.

I get what you are saying but it is do or die time still as a wrong lynch can pretty much do in the town at this point.

 

[allaboutfish]

jpap-i havent thought it was mafia anywhere in the game.
razz-same.
pir-have thought he was scum from the beginning but since someone said that that was there regular game play (i think it might of been DD but cant remember) im not to sure.
rich-i really think hes mafia.
DD-hasnt really posted enough for me to make an analysis.
lady g-i thought she was a ginger but i dont think so now.
AAF-i know who i am.

 

[allaboutfish]

Fair enough although it would be nice if you got a bit more specific that just he "acts scummy."

So why do you think that Kash voted Pir?



I get what you are saying but it is do or die time still as a wrong lynch can pretty much do in the town at this point.

it wouldnt really matter who she picked. she was gone either way. her voting him would make him not seem like scum.

 

[allaboutfish]

jpap-i havent thought it was mafia anywhere in the game.
razz-same.
pir-have thought he was scum from the beginning but since someone said that that was there regular game play (i think it might of been DD but cant remember) im not to sure.
rich-i really think hes mafia.
DD-hasnt really posted enough for me to make an analysis.
lady g-i thought she was a ginger but i dont think so now.
AAF-i know who i am.

it=he sorry jpap

 

[jpappy789]

Thanks for at least responding.

 

[RazzleFish]

jpap-i havent thought it was mafia anywhere in the game.
razz-same.
pir-have thought he was scum from the beginning but since someone said that that was there regular game play (i think it might of been DD but cant remember) im not to sure.
rich-i really think hes mafia.
DD-hasnt really posted enough for me to make an analysis.
lady g-i thought she was a ginger but i dont think so now.
AAF-i know who i am.

Ok better. Now I know you said DD hasn't posted too much, but Pappy pointed out some specific things. What do you think about any of those posts? What makes you think LG isn't scum anymore?

it=he sorry jpap

:lol:

 

[allaboutfish]

i dont think a townie would have missed that chil was the investigator. its a pretty big deal to know who waas hit and or tested and what their roles were. i

 

[allaboutfish]

Doll, just a question here. You say you forgot Chill wast the investigator, and thought maybe I was...ok fine. My problem with this is you voted opposite me...if you thought I was the investigator and switched you vote because of that wouldn't you vote with me? Don't get me wrong I am very glad Kash is gone, but your vote to her made no difference what so ever and no switching to Pir at that point would of made no difference in the outcome, but still if you thought I was the investigator, I don't understand why you would of voted opposite me?

i agree with this. the investigator might know who was scum and who wasnt so why would DD vote for kash instead of pir like lady g did.