I probably won't be on much today I have to process my thoughts (and earn my paycheck). It would be nice to here from some of the other players as well.
Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)
- Thread starter Kashta
- Start date
ok, I have 3 more pages to catch up with but I just wanted to place thoughts out because it's getting late and I haven't much time before I go to bed. For the record, I have read up to post 1320.
The problem I am having with MC investigating me is for one, he would have found me innocent. Knowing this, I think he may have left subtle hints but that vote out of the cage like that would have dispelled a mafias opinion of him being Detective. If I was mafia, it sure would have made me think he was wishy washy and playing without much thought, just rushing out a vote. The mafia knew he wasn't one of them and to see that vote must've had them like oh brother, MC is gonna be an easy lynch for sure and there's not way he has a role because I am not on their team either. The thing is UN was voting, then trying to take a vote back by being sloppy, saying he unvotes who he voted for and made his next vote.... which by the way seemed suspicious. You folks that claim MC would have chose someone other than UN should think about that. MC doesn't know UN's play, all he knows is that he is a regular after his time (MC's) and everyone knew him so he must know the game. I cannot substantiate for myself that MC was only going to investigate Vets that he knew. That would be foolish to use that kind of gameplay with such an important role. The fact is, UN seemed to panic and I believe MC caught on to it and checked him out.
Originally Posted by Dangerdoll
I believe it was because he wanted to appear obviously NOT the detective... but just wishy washy... he was being careful so as not to be suspected as detective which in the end screwed himself because he not only convinced the mafia of not being the detective, he also convinced those who voted that he was not a townie either.
I am not saying no mafia voted him, I am saying that since using the thought that he didn't know who the mafia was by voting me out of the gate, they were less opt to taking him out with a hit.
The problem with your thought here DD is shown in the post below. Yes UN did look suspicious with his vote switch. With last night's vote. He did not switch votes D1. The only invest result MC had was from D1.
DD's post now has me questioning where my vote lies. Do I think MC investigated DD? I don't know and won't get into that.There is no way anyone can pretend to know who the invest was.
For now, I retract my vote on LG.
It could be difficult, but I will get back on prior to night fall and vote.
Leaving soon for work. I'll be running nightfall from the office tonight so I may not be able to post vote counts very often before it... depending on how things are at work. Players are welcome to post updates themselves if you don't see one from me just to keep everyone informed. Thanks!
Day 3 - Vote Count
1 DD - UN (1127) LG (1142) Dawg (1195)
3 UN - Zaffy (1147) DD (1167) Rich (1438
3 LG - Jpappy (1255) User (1282) Lab (1364) Wizard (1365)
No vote: JB, AAF, Ninja, Mad, Rbishop, Dawg, Bally, Chill, Wizard.
Nightfall at 9pm Eastern/6pm Pacific.
PMs as needed.
Day 3 - Vote Count
1 DD - UN (1127) LG (1142) Dawg (1195)
3 UN - Zaffy (1147) DD (1167) Rich (1438
3 LG - Jpappy (1255) User (1282) Lab (1364) Wizard (1365)
No vote: JB, AAF, Ninja, Mad, Rbishop, Dawg, Bally, Chill, Wizard.
Nightfall at 9pm Eastern/6pm Pacific.
PMs as needed.
ok, I have 3 more pages to catch up with but I just wanted to place thoughts out because it's getting late and I haven't much time before I go to bed. For the record, I have read up to post 1320.
The problem I am having with MC investigating me is for one, he would have found me innocent. Knowing this, I think he may have left subtle hints but that vote out of the cage like that would have dispelled a mafias opinion of him being Detective. If I was mafia, it sure would have made me think he was wishy washy and playing without much thought, just rushing out a vote. The mafia knew he wasn't one of them and to see that vote must've had them like oh brother, MC is gonna be an easy lynch for sure and there's not way he has a role because I am not on their team either. The thing is UN was voting, then trying to take a vote back by being sloppy, saying he unvotes who he voted for and made his next vote.... which by the way seemed suspicious. You folks that claim MC would have chose someone other than UN should think about that. MC doesn't know UN's play, all he knows is that he is a regular after his time (MC's) and everyone knew him so he must know the game. I cannot substantiate for myself that MC was only going to investigate Vets that he knew. That would be foolish to use that kind of gameplay with such an important role. The fact is, UN seemed to panic and I believe MC caught on to it and checked him out.
Originally Posted by Dangerdoll
I believe it was because he wanted to appear obviously NOT the detective... but just wishy washy... he was being careful so as not to be suspected as detective which in the end screwed himself because he not only convinced the mafia of not being the detective, he also convinced those who voted that he was not a townie either.
I am not saying no mafia voted him, I am saying that since using the thought that he didn't know who the mafia was by voting me out of the gate, they were less opt to taking him out with a hit.
DD, UN's vote hopping was N2 and his only invest was N1. He had to catch on to something well before that...
I'm trying to get a read on your opinion here...so do you think he investigated UN?
i still cant get past MC's last post if he had invested DD and she came up up scum, I do not see how he would not have posted that. He should have realized a guess against another play would just sow more confusion. I am quite happy with my vote.
Doll, aside from what Pap and Wiz pointed out, even I?F he had got innocent with a invest on night one...it wouldn't mean diddly, since the boss shows as innocent night one...so your thought that if he invested you he would of got innocent doesn't stand as a reason for him to vote you so the mafia would think he was not the detective.ok, I have 3 more pages to catch up with but I just wanted to place thoughts out because it's getting late and I haven't much time before I go to bed. For the record, I have read up to post 1320.
The problem I am having with MC investigating me is for one, he would have found me innocent. Knowing this, I think he may have left subtle hints but that vote out of the cage like that would have dispelled a mafias opinion of him being Detective. If I was mafia, it sure would have made me think he was wishy washy and playing without much thought, just rushing out a vote. The mafia knew he wasn't one of them and to see that vote must've had them like oh brother, MC is gonna be an easy lynch for sure and there's not way he has a role because I am not on their team either. The thing is UN was voting, then trying to take a vote back by being sloppy, saying he unvotes who he voted for and made his next vote.... which by the way seemed suspicious. You folks that claim MC would have chose someone other than UN should think about that. MC doesn't know UN's play, all he knows is that he is a regular after his time (MC's) and everyone knew him so he must know the game. I cannot substantiate for myself that MC was only going to investigate Vets that he knew. That would be foolish to use that kind of gameplay with such an important role. The fact is, UN seemed to panic and I believe MC caught on to it and checked him out.
Originally Posted by Dangerdoll
I believe it was because he wanted to appear obviously NOT the detective... but just wishy washy... he was being careful so as not to be suspected as detective which in the end screwed himself because he not only convinced the mafia of not being the detective, he also convinced those who voted that he was not a townie either.
I am not saying no mafia voted him, I am saying that since using the thought that he didn't know who the mafia was by voting me out of the gate, they were less opt to taking him out with a hit.
Ok Pap...as long as you really think you know what you are doing and not just being stubborn because you don't want to admit you could be wrong.
[YT]jAlQ1cR6X9Q[/YT]
