Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

Madcrawdad said:
It never crossed my mind. Have you played with Paul before? Did such a move on his part seem out of character to you?

Nope. My guess is Pappy on the invest.

Seriously? Detective has a scum read, and backs off just because somebody pushes him on it. Paul didn't just back off on the vote, he also backed off on calling DD scum period.

If you've got other reasons than just trying to guess Paul's investigation.
Click to expand...
Yes, of course I have played with MC before, as I stated before he seemed to get himself in trouble quite a bit when innocent. Which was originally why I didn't jump in and vote him..I wanted to see where he was going with it before deciding on what I thought about him. As the day went on, the thought of him being detective did cross my mind and is the reason I in the end did not want to vote him. When night fell happened and he was indeed the Detective...yes, I could see why he would of voted Doll right off the bat if he had investigated her and found scum. Thinking he would be able to build a case on her as the day went on. Of course I don't know that, that is for sure what happened, but it does make since to me.

Does the fact you believe the invest was on Pap, sway you one way or the other on Paps innocence/guilt?

Yes, I can see the detective coming off their vote if it was going no where at the moment, and having someone hound you so much everyone is looking at you, not being able to come out and say what you found. I'm not so sold on the fact he seriously thought Doll was innocent, I can see that easily as a way to try and "save" himself from the lynch and the hit.
 
Madcrawdad said:
I like this post.



So you were running interference for the detective? Why would the mafia care if you thought that MC was the detective? Seriously. You didn't have to call MC scum, you could have just said nothing and nobody would have thought that you were thinking Paul was detective.

For now, I vote to lynch LG. Could change as I read further.
Click to expand...
I'm done trying to explain my thoughts at that time...I went about it wrong and I can't change that now.

Madcrawdad said:
Yup. If you think you've spotted the detective, you certainly don't bring up the fact that they leaned another player innocent out of the blue...especially if trying to keep the detective hidden.
Click to expand...
Excuse me for being stupid, I had my thought in my head and at the time it made since...I didn't think he had investigated Pap and I still do not think that. I don't think with the invest showing the boss as innocent night one, he would of brought up a "innocent" if he had found one.
 
I'm currently plugging through at #1339, and something bothersome it that there's still nothing new from Bally. The busted computer excuse isn't cutting it, either. She has phone access, and she said in the signup that she has time to play. As she has the ability to check in and keep us up to date on the "broken computer" status, it's interesting that she's not saying anything at all. Almost as if she's hoping out of sight, out of mind.
 
Lab_Rat said:
I wasn't looking for innocents Mad. MCs vote so quickly on DD really stuck out to me so that is immediately what I went to check out (timing wise). I didn't read through all his posts though, therefore I missed the part about Pappy. In my mind I already had Pappy leaning innocent anyway.
Click to expand...
Really, not even through day 2 and you already lean Pap innocent? Why is that Labby, so you had Wiz innocent and you had Pap as innocent correct?
 
Madcrawdad said:
I'm currently plugging through at #1339, and something bothersome it that there's still nothing new from Bally. The busted computer excuse isn't cutting it, either. She has phone access, and she said in the signup that she has time to play. As she has the ability to check in and keep us up to date on the "broken computer" status, it's interesting that she's not saying anything at all. Almost as if she's hoping out of sight, out of mind.
Click to expand...
She also was posting on Facebook last night...

Lady G said:
Really, not even through day 2 and you already lean Pap innocent? Why is that Labby, so you had Wiz innocent and you had Pap as innocent correct?
Click to expand...
You gotta start somewhere. Had them leaning innocent, as in slightly out of neutral. Never said I was 100% sure either was innocent. I've found myself agreeing a lot with Pappy and I can understand where Wiz was coming from. Looking back on it even more, since both FF and Spencer did in fact show innocent, I don't think Wiz would have made such a racket about not voting them if he was scum.
 
Lady G said:
Does the fact you believe the invest was on Pap, sway you one way or the other on Paps innocence/guilt?
Click to expand...

No, as a N1 innocent read is useless this game.


Lady G said:
Yes, I can see the detective coming off their vote if it was going no where at the moment, and having someone hound you so much everyone is looking at you, not being able to come out and say what you found. I'm not so sold on the fact he seriously thought Doll was innocent, I can see that easily as a way to try and "save" himself from the lynch and the hit.
Click to expand...

It's one thing for the detective to pull his vote off scum, another for him to completely retract any suspicion of someone he's gotten a confirmed scum read on.
 
Lady G said:
Yes, of course I have played with MC before, as I stated before he seemed to get himself in trouble quite a bit when innocent. Which was originally why I didn't jump in and vote him..I wanted to see where he was going with it before deciding on what I thought about him. As the day went on, the thought of him being detective did cross my mind and is the reason I in the end did not want to vote him. When night fell happened and he was indeed the Detective...yes, I could see why he would of voted Doll right off the bat if he had investigated her and found scum. Thinking he would be able to build a case on her as the day went on. Of course I don't know that, that is for sure what happened, but it does make since to me.

Does the fact you believe the invest was on Pap, sway you one way or the other on Paps innocence/guilt?

Yes, I can see the detective coming off their vote if it was going no where at the moment, and having someone hound you so much everyone is looking at you, not being able to come out and say what you found. I'm not so sold on the fact he seriously thought Doll was innocent, I can see that easily as a way to try and "save" himself from the lynch and the hit.
Click to expand...

So if you are not sold on DD being the invest then why is your vote still there? You seemed pretty sure when you originally placed your vote. Just curious if there are other reasons...
 
Ballyhoo said:
Ok my computer took a carp on me...it's being fixed now should have it back in the morning. I can't multiquote on my iPhone and had to do all of today's reading on it.

I vote to lynch Chill
I don't like how he was ready to post his vote retraction on D1 and the quickly post with another last minute vote. I don't see why a 3 man tie on D1 with 2 ppl who had clearly deserved the votes they recieved was so important.
Click to expand...

This was Monday evening. Still not fixed, Bally?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom