I'd love to hear some input from Zaffy, too. After last game, I don't feel like I can let him slide this time...
Mafia 96 Who Are You? Game Thread
- Thread starter the wizard
- Start date
Sorry, I've been out most of the day and unfortunately I don't have much time right now I will be able to be on a little later. I've only skimmed through at this point so I can't add much right now. Right now, my concerns lie with those who voted/unvoted LFB...AAF seemingly not knowing who he voted when he retracted, MC voting Rich after night was called. After getting caught up more, I will update my thoughts.
Too sleepy to sort out all the other quotes I pulled. Let me sum up my comments here.... there are corresponding quotes above that go with them.
1. About AAF voting a UD.... (most of the quotes relate to this one.)
From what I see, AAF may have made himself the next most likely lynch for pulling that indefensible vote switch from FF to Spence. I can't figure out why he wanted to or felt he needed to switch at all. FF wasn't obvious scum or innocent at this stage and no one questioned AAF's vote where it was had he merely left it alone. As for Spence's imminent UD, it wouldn't surprise me if AAF wasn't paying attention to the standings enough to actually realize Spence had not voted and, thus, was going to die anyway. Unfortunately, that makes me wonder why AAF is playing more than it does which side he's on.
2. Mostlycichlids... while I must admit I like your style, always have. Would you mind giving us a real answer to Pappy's question? (Third quote from the top.)
3. Dagamoth... in the quote I pulled from you where you say "it sucks the innocents are down....," wouldn't it have been more natural for you to say "it sucks that WE are down...." if you were an innocent yourself?
4. Ice... you are so right about that idea if Wizard had put FF and LBF together on the same team with me. lmao!!! Would not have been a smart move... if he wanted to sleep without keeping one eye open all night.
I had originally typed that out when I was posting but then I remembered every time someone, anyone, claims they are innocent either directly by saying I am innocent or by saying something as "we are down" it always makes them look scummy. It does nothing positive for the town if I were to give scum the opportunity to use the "scum always say they're innocent" card and provide a distraction for the town to keep the town focused away from the scum.
So... in order to give the town something to go off on the next night fall I would like everyone to list out their top 3 scum suspects.
For me right now:
Ice
LR
Kashta (zaffy may be swapped for kash, i dunno kinda have mixed feelings on both)
For the most part this is just gut feeling after reading. There hasn't been much to go on more than gut since no one, until possibly today, has been communicating. Hopefully having people list out suspects will give us some semi-hard info to go off when the next vote happens.
For me right now:
Ice
LR
Kashta (zaffy may be swapped for kash, i dunno kinda have mixed feelings on both)
For the most part this is just gut feeling after reading. There hasn't been much to go on more than gut since no one, until possibly today, has been communicating. Hopefully having people list out suspects will give us some semi-hard info to go off when the next vote happens.
tsk, tsk... bleeding for information the obvious way right out in the open. could you trust my list if i gave it to you?
reasoning? simple! i'm a skeptical person. i don't give my trust away easy. those on my "list" just so happen to have even less of my trust. my likelies if you wish.
nope. no way. sorry. i'm the new guy. i'm the one that can use anything i can get. no way i'm just spitting out a bunch of names. uh uh... :shakehead:
Just one more before going to bed. Also have an appointment after work tomorrow so it'll be real late again before I get back on.
lmao!! Jpap's title, "I'm the Doctor."
^^ I guess it's not a role claim if the role's not in this game. Too funny, Papp!!!
With that in mind, pencil me in as the journalist then..... or rather, journalist-turned-demon. That was one I really enjoyed.
I was intending to reference Dr. Who, but I guess a fake RC works just as well LOL
Having a majority of scum doesn't make it any easier to find them. I could just as easily pull a name out of a hat and have a greater than 50% chance of picking scum but that doesn't mean trying to find a "legit" reason to vote for scum is just as easy. A lack of actual game play sure doesn't help.
Why are you concerned with the votes on LBF? I voted to get rid of that eye sore avatar and the crap posting. You voted Chill because he voted JB...should I be worried about your vote as well? The only difference is that LBF turned up innocent, which absolutely no one could have known 100% on D1.
Which is better, self preservation or helping the town? I guess it would depend which side you are on...
In all seriousness withholding info isn't going to do any good. In reality it makes you look scummy and not pro-town, whatever your reasons may be.
The point of lists is to get a gauge of where the town stands and possibly point out and contradictions or weak reasons a player may have, which in turn can lead to scum. It's one of the best resources we have in these games which is why they are used often. Look to any past games and you will always see them used and see others trying to rip them to shreds.
Oops...I was going to respond to Dag saying that at this point I have no idea who my list would even be. People who have caught my eye so far are AAF, Ice, Dun, and now LG but I would hesitate to call it a "suspect list"...
You must have some kind of gut feeling after reading everything that has been said so far. That is like saying after conversing with a group of people at a camp fire over night you have no impressions of any of them. Certainly isn't helpful for the town to stay silent.
