Mafia #98: The Grinch Returns -- The Play

allaboutfish said:
no bc you dont want people loooking at the list, when it can help us figure out whos evil, you just dont want people to lynch a teammate, you've also been playing wayy different than usual, looks more coached to me.
Click to expand...

Can't argue with the different game play. I am playing different. And I intend to continue behaving different.
 
Fishfriend1 said:
I'm not sure how much credence we should put into AAF's list. First off, we don't even know if it's a true RC. Then, of the people there, we already have ideas for who's evil/innocent, and if we just go via elimination, well... we would lose before we got lucky. Personally I think we should continue the game using our own heads more then any naughty/nice list.


Assuming his RC is true, Kashta, Bally, or Rich is definitely evil. The biggest issue is that they are all good players. Bally screwed up a bit, with the nightfall incident and her confusion there. Personally I don't think that is enough to be evil. Kashta overdefended her votes. Rich hasn't done anything scummy yet (IMO). So, who do we want to say is evil? I think Kashta, of these people, is the best choice. I've never been able to read her, period, similar to Rich. So, well, she's the one, of this list, who is the most scummy. But I'm not yet sure I believe AAF's RC.
Click to expand...
I will agree to a point, we should not base solely on a list that very well could be false. There is the possibility he is evil and this entire list is fake, to deny that is possible would just be stupid. On the other hand I am more apt to believe it is a true list. Having said that, obviously I feel Kash is the evil of them. I do agree Bally has said some "off" things, but as I have stated what she has done is pretty typical of her IMO...that of course is MY opinion and I'm not saying I am right and anyone voting Bally is evil because they do not see things the way I do. Rich, I am going on a limb to say is innocent again something I could very easily be wrong on, but most times when he has been evil, there was at least a post or two that made me question him...this round I have not had that so I have absolutely nothing to make me think he is evil.

Fishfriend1 said:
Yes, he voted 2H because of the unlynchable thing, but he was perfectly fine with 2H or Dun, and I was wondering why he picked 2H. He said 'Gut feeling" that 2H was scummier then dun.
Click to expand...
Ok, I did see what he made that statement FF, but I don't know why you didn't add the part of his vote that said his reason...when you posted it, you made it look as if he only said it was a "gut feeling". That is something that made you questionable in my mind, by leaving that part out...you changed his vote/post entirely.
 
LG: Ah, yes, I can see that. Sorry, I thought it was obvious what I was trying to say :/
 
the wizard said:
What makes you lean Kashta more scummy than Bally? I can never read Kashta when she is scum. You did vote Bally last night.

The reason I ask is you, Bally, and Kashta are on AAF's naughty or nice list. If it can only have one scum (still waiting for AAF to clarify the wording in response to JP) then it definitely gives us two confirmed innocents if we get scum tonight.

If you are innocent, then what changes your mind on Bally?

If you are the scum on the list, I can see you trying to lynch Kashta first as when she has time to play these games she can cause a lot of discomfort for the scum team.
Click to expand...
Just one question here Wizard, You say "I can never read Kash when evil"...can you read her when she is innocent?
 
Fishfriend1 said:
LG: Ah, yes, I can see that. Sorry, I thought it was obvious what I was trying to say :/
Click to expand...
LOL, nothing is ever "obvious" in these games :thm:
 
Current vote count:
Bally (1) - Wiz
Kash (2) - LG, Rich

No votes: everyone else

Mobile site doesn't give me post numbers.

Nightfall in about 7 hours. PMs as needed.
 
Labby, I have a question about next nightfall....after tonight will we be going to a 24 hour nightfall or a extended night, I know with 4 kids there is NO WAY I will make it for a nightfall Sat or Sun?
 
Another options if they would, we could possibly "lock" the game until Monday after tomorrow?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom