Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[dirtydawg10]

So let's just say for the sake of argument that Ice is innocent and the current interpretation of the paper is correct. LR, AAF and Dun voted for Ice last night. Don't you think if Ice is innocent that scum would vote for him?

Kash...why the singleton vote on DD? I get that you think she is scum but if you know your vote won't matter why not move it to where it might make a difference? Similar question to JB. Ice explained why he was gone at nightfall.

 

[Lab_Rat]

So let's just say for the sake of argument that Ice is innocent and the current interpretation of the paper is correct. LR, AAF and Dun voted for Ice last night. Don't you think if Ice is innocent that scum would vote for him?

I think that scum would vote for anyone who wasn't scum. So yes, scum would vote for him. Scum would also vote for FF, or place a random vote on someone non-scum. I'm not sure what you're getting at with this question Dawg.

 

[Zaffy]

Great game,loved the final 4 minutes. Pat game was over as soon as it started.....

I'm kind of surprised JB and Dawg didn't get the reference. I'm actually interested in what their 1st thoughts were when they read the headline.





Not sure what you mean here Dun... You agree with Labs post enough to vote me but you don't agree with it. She voted me because she thought scum would make a move to protect FF, but you say any move would be suspicious as I said. So if you agree with me then why did you vote with her?

This bothers me too. He doesn't seem to have anything to say it looks like he's just trying to vote.

At the time he voted Kash and Ice both had 2 votes. His vote put Ice in the lead. The weakness of his reasoning and timing make me wonder if he was protecting Kash. There were 5 more votes outstanding at the time, I could see a scum team wanting a little insurance.

 

[allaboutfish]

So let's just say for the sake of argument that Ice is innocent and the current interpretation of the paper is correct. LR, AAF and Dun voted for Ice last night. Don't you think if Ice is innocent that scum would vote for him?

Kash...why the singleton vote on DD? I get that you think she is scum but if you know your vote won't matter why not move it to where it might make a difference? Similar question to JB. Ice explained why he was gone at nightfall.

FF was innocent too with your reasoning, the people that voted him are scum.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I think that scum would vote for anyone who wasn't scum. So yes, scum would vote for him. Scum would also vote for FF, or place a random vote on someone non-scum. I'm not sure what you're getting at with this question Dawg.

I'm getting at, that I think at least one of you that voted for Ice is scum. I also think that FF = Rocket Scientist = Oxymoron. I also like the fact that Kash pointed out that the Blogger couldn't affect the outcome of the news headline and that she didn't place a vote on me even after I pushed for it. I need to get some sleep and review this thread tomorrow.

 

[dirtydawg10]

FF was innocent too with your reasoning, the people that voted him are scum.

My reasoning is that scum would try to get Ice out by the lynch if at all possible if he was innocent. He is a strong player and scum would jump at the chance. FF not so much.

 

[Zaffy]

FF was innocent too with your reasoning, the people that voted him are scum.

There were 6 votes on Ice and FF, how many scum are in this game? Is it likely that at least one was on either of them?

 

[jbradt]

C'mon you can do it...vote for me. If DD ends up getting more votes you can always retract Isn't that what scum would do anyway?

This post really stuck out to me. Dawg, it really seems to me that you are goading Kash to do something that you then go on to explain "scum would do". That seems a bit odd to me.

well with the low posting would they really need to hide?

Not "need" per se. But the low posting makes it much easier for them to do it.

So let's just say for the sake of argument that Ice is innocent and the current interpretation of the paper is correct. LR, AAF and Dun voted for Ice last night. Don't you think if Ice is innocent that scum would vote for him?

Kash...why the singleton vote on DD? I get that you think she is scum but if you know your vote won't matter why not move it to where it might make a difference? Similar question to JB. Ice explained why he was gone at nightfall.

So, for the record, which inncent person would you have preferred I vote for? Ice or FF? Assuming the premise you gave (Ice is innocent), you would be questioning why I moved to take out either a) a townie PR or b) a player who is a huge asset to the town as a known innocent. I wasn't feeling it with either of them, so I went with my gut instinct. I'd rather place a lone vote than one that helps lynch someone I'm not ready to vote for.

 

[allaboutfish]

My reasoning is that scum would try to get Ice out by the lynch if at all possible if he was innocent. He is a strong player and scum would jump at the chance. FF not so much.

i agree, but he cant be the only innocent that was voted for so....

There were 6 votes on Ice and FF, how many scum are in this game? Is it likely that at least one was on either of them?

yes it is likely i was just making a point.

 

[IceH2O]

Wiz I wanted to answer your question...

Exactly what "mess" did I put my "team" into. My comments were about you voting so quickly over FF's slip when I have seen you require more than that to convince you he was scum. You yourself admitted partly it was due to another thread. You then state that I am defending FF?

I don't see the defense of FF in my posts. You sir are either misguided or scum. Knowing that you won't be back prior to night fall creates a pickle for me as I would like to hear explanation and with out such I can't bring myself to vote for you as I would never OMGUS vote anyone.

The fact that you drew your vote off of FF so easily after stating how convinced you were makes me wonder if maybe you two are team mates and we already know that you don't have an issue with throwing team mates under the bus.

I see the point I guess with FF but I am having a hard time because Dawg and Ice are so quick to vote. FF is notorious for not making sense and seeming to make major slip ups and a lot of times is innocent. I feel like this early in the game, you guys are taking advantage of it... I am willing to vote for FF if more people see it but it just bothers me to see votes coming out of the gate like that.

I mean, if it were anyone else, I might be as gung ho as you guys too..... but this is FF....

Well, we are off to the same sucky start we usually have. Two innocents down and not a lot to go on. I do admit that FF's post sends off bells and whistles. I am however leary to vote so quick after night fall. I too must ask why so sure Dawg? Same question to Ice as well.

I am not opposed to voting FF but with the limited time I have had to play lately, I am not as thorough or accurate as I once was.

DD, I must say that this almost seems as though you are defending FF.

Would you care to comment or explain in greater detail?

Wiz, tell me how DDs post is defending FF but yours isn't...