Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[dirtydawg10]

This post really stuck out to me. Dawg, it really seems to me that you are goading Kash to do something that you then go on to explain "scum would do". That seems a bit odd to me.

Not "need" per se. But the low posting makes it much easier for them to do it.

So, for the record, which inncent person would you have preferred I vote for? Ice or FF? Assuming the premise you gave (Ice is innocent), you would be questioning why I moved to take out either a) a townie PR or b) a player who is a huge asset to the town as a known innocent. I wasn't feeling it with either of them, so I went with my gut instinct. I'd rather place a lone vote than one that helps lynch someone I'm not ready to vote for.

Yes, I was goading Kash.

Thanks for the explanation JB...you could have voted for FF, Ice, Kash, Wiz or DD and not had a singleton vote. I am always leery of singleton votes...more so on D2. If you are innocent how would you have known that both Ice and FF were innocent before nightfall?

 

[Zaffy]

i agree, but he cant be the only innocent that was voted for so....


yes it is likely i was just making a point.

Do you think the scum piled on to either FF or Ice, or do you think they spread out?

 

[IceH2O]

AAF...lets try something different...instead of you following others and parroting their thoughts why don't you take this opportunity to make a suspect list and give reasons why you think they might be scum...put it in the order of how you'd vote them. Maybe even go as far as voting them,you could always retract..There is no greater satisfaction in this game then being the one that led the charge on a scummy player.

 

[Zaffy]

I think that scum would vote for anyone who wasn't scum. So yes, scum would vote for him. Scum would also vote for FF, or place a random vote on someone non-scum. I'm not sure what you're getting at with this question Dawg.

You seem to be saying that Scum would vote for non-scum. Why wouldn't they throw a random vote on one of their own? You've played here before right?

 

[allaboutfish]

Do you think the scum piled on to either FF or Ice, or do you think they spread out?

i dont know, but wouldnt it be stupid to vote for the same person?

 

[Lab_Rat]

You seem to be saying that Scum would vote for non-scum. Why wouldn't they throw a random vote on one of their own? You've played here before right?

Did I say that they wouldn't throw a random vote on one of their own? Please show me where I said that.

 

[Zaffy]

Did I say that they wouldn't throw a random vote on one of their own? Please show me where I said that.

It's not that you said it, but rather that what you said seemed to specifically exclude it. Did you slip up?

 

[Dangerdoll]

See the difference, DD? JB at least addressed the question in some way. You used my asking the same thing of you to spin me in a scummy light.

My vote stays where it is.

ummm... what?

I have a follow-up question to ask, Dawg.

Tell us who the "low posters" were that you were considering at that particular time. It would take an awful lot of back-tracking for me to figure out the lowest posters now and factor in the posts that have been made in between then and now. And since you apparently contemplated between us, you should be able to answer this quite easily.

Bally, for example. I'm sure she would have been one of the lowest posters too. Yet, you preferred me being sent to the looney bin over her for some reason. Who else was with me on your list of low posters when you voted? I'm curious to see who else you chose me over for your vote besides those you mentioned in your post (Zaffy and FF).

Kash, if you are at the GCC forum menu, you could click on the number under "replies" (I have circled it in red). I am not clear if this is just a mod tool or not but I think we talked about this in earlier games, about 90 games or so.

I am finding it difficult to find anything to comment on after the results we had tonight.

Looking through the thread the most obvious thing is the lack of posting.

In an effort to start conversation, even though Kashta has seemed to drop it, I would like to know why DD didn't actually answer Kashta's question about how her post was off.

sorry, I must have missed that. If she was talking about her first post, clearly it was off. It wasn't 3 paragraphs long and even though there was no real content going on yet, it didn't fit right where it was. While others were posting their gifts and things like that, her post was nothing of the sort.

 

[Lab_Rat]

It's not that you said it, but rather that what you said seemed to specifically exclude it. Did you slip up?

Nothing to slip up about. In fact, I'd said before this past nightfall that if FF and Ice were both scum I could see Ice voting FF off. Why are you trying to twist my words?

 

[allaboutfish]

AAF...lets try something different...instead of you following others and parroting their thoughts why don't you take this opportunity to make a suspect list and give reasons why you think they might be scum...put it in the order of how you'd vote them. Maybe even go as far as voting them,you could always retract..There is no greater satisfaction in this game then being the one that led the charge on a scummy player.

i dont have much of a scum list yet but i guess here it is.
dirtydawg- i dont like how he decided that just bc someone voted an innocent that theyre scum. there could be someone on ice, but just bc we're almost sure that he's innocent doesnt mean that you knew that before nightfall. i also dont like the FF vote right after nightfall.
ice- thought you were scum but after tonight, your most likely innocent.
dun- seems pretty pro town to me.