Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[Kashta]

Yes, I did read your post. I read all the posts in these games. And I can see where you're coming from and what you did, but I can also see how it could have been a scum move. I also find it odd that after Kash got some support against you, she voted for you then kinda disappeared. That also really bugs me.

Sorry about that. I wasn't planning to disappear... I just reviewed the thread mostly after the posting dwindled out. Came back to add my thoughts about Wizard/Zaffy when I got done with that.

As it stands now, I've pretty much been over everything I can find that we have to go on. Until more input comes in from the ones not posting or nightfall comes and goes so we'll have more information about somebody at least, I don't really know what else to offer.

 

[noodles62]

This doesn't make sense, Noods. If you truly believe one is scum and the other is innocent you should at least vote one or the other. Reveal one role gives you insight on the other, plain and simple. Now, if you believed we're both innocents butting heads, THAT's a reason to not vote either of us. But according to this post that isn't what you believe is true.

This posts suggests Noods may know which one of us is scum but instead of putting her name on a vote against me... she dodged it so no one would come back to her to explain herself for that vote later on. It also gives an excuse to NOT vote her teammate. And it contributes to the level of general confusion over this for the town.

Scummy strategy there, Noods.

That makes no sense at all Kash. So are you saying that Dawg and I are team mates? I am saying that based on the interaction between the two of you, I believe that one of you is scum. If I knew which one, I would vote as such. The way I see it, we have already lost 5 innocents including one PR. I am not willing to risk a guess on which of you is scum and possibly help take out another innocent. I would prefer to wait until I am more certain.

 

[Lab_Rat]

That makes no sense at all Kash. So are you saying that Dawg and I are team mates? I am saying that based on the interaction between the two of you, I believe that one of you is scum. If I knew which one, I would vote as such. The way I see it, we have already lost 5 innocents including one PR. I am not willing to risk a guess on which of you is scum and possibly help take out another innocent. I would prefer to wait until I am more certain.

So then you are sure Zaffy is scum? Or is that a guess?

 

[noodles62]

So then you are sure Zaffy is scum? Or is that a guess?

I feel more certain about Zaffy than tossing a coin up over Kash/Dawg.

 

[Kashta]

So who are your top 4 most likely scum at this point Kash?

I don't know, Lab. Yesterday I had 3 solid suspects (Dawg/Zaffy/Wizard) with a toss up for the 4th. Now, I have 2 solid ones (Dawg/Zaffy) with Wizard in with the others TBD.

What Noods just posted brings her up on the scummy meter. At least if she stays with us and doesn't leave again, we might get more to go on from her.

We really need some participation from DD.

I went through Dun's posts and there's a lot in those I couldn't even figure out what he was talking about. My overall impression though? That he probably really is cantankerous enough to vote LG out of spitefulness because of the last game without regard for anyone's role in this game. For most anyone else though, I'd interpret that as a lame excuse or scumtell. With him, I can't tell if he's lying or telling us the truth.

 

[Kashta]

That makes no sense at all Kash. So are you saying that Dawg and I are team mates? I am saying that based on the interaction between the two of you, I believe that one of you is scum. If I knew which one, I would vote as such. The way I see it, we have already lost 5 innocents including one PR. I am not willing to risk a guess on which of you is scum and possibly help take out another innocent. I would prefer to wait until I am more certain.

I'm not saying you and Dawg are teammates. I am trying to determine IF you and Dawg are teammates. Big difference between the two.

Besides, that same risk exists for everyone in the game, Noods. The only way the town learns anything is when everyone takes a stand. Right or wrong. It isn't your single vote which determines whether me or Dawg dies. Or even if either one of us is up for lynching. But you making a choice AND others making their choice would help us pinpoint where possible alliances exist between scum. Especially with so much time remaining between now and nightfall.

It's not like you can't switch a vote or it's out of character for you as a mafia player to retract and revote more than once.

As you left this instead, all you did was add to the general feeling of indecision the town has already. I believe the scum favors that.

 

[Kashta]

I forgot to make a stop on the way home from work. Will be back in about an hour... two at the most.

 

[noodles62]

ok Kash, I'll bite. I don't like singleton votes anyway. I retract my vote for Zaffy and vote to send Kash to the looney bin. That makes a three way tie and the movement to save someone should be very telling.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Since we have an extension until nightfall, I'm going to run some errands and thing more about my vote. In my head, I see two different scum teams. One has Kash on it, the other has Dawg. Noods would be on Dawg's team. Dun and AAF would be on Kash's team. DD could be on either, she's not taken a stance on way or the other.

 

[noodles62]

Speaking of DD, I hope her "little" pup is ok, but I would really like to hear from her. The last few games I have played with her, she has participated little and sometimes UD'd, regardless of her alignment. We cannot afford another UD and I would like to hear what she has to say.