Mafia Game 3

I'm going to go by KotD's ruling on the mayor thing, if he wants me to take over, I'm not going to go messing around with what he says...

As far as taking out 3 people, if the townies vote off 1 person, the mayor & detective get 1, and the vigilant took his hit... Well, I guess that's possible. You probably won't see it too often, but yeah, I guess it IS possible.
 
Dwarf Puffers said:
I'm going to go by KotD's ruling on the mayor thing, if he wants me to take over, I'm not going to go messing around with what he says...

As far as taking out 3 people, if the townies vote off 1 person, the mayor & detective get 1, and the vigilant took his hit... Well, I guess that's possible. You probably won't see it too often, but yeah, I guess it IS possible.
Click to expand...

so how do you read it DP, in terms of how many hits the mayor has? Possibly one a night, or one in the game?
 
I'd say one a night, as long as the detective and mayor are both still together. Other than that, the mayor can investigate. The mayor and the detective can either both investigate a night or kill 1 person.

This rule makes sense, seeing as the mayor, the leader of the townies, knows who a mafia is, so it is assumed the leader of the townies, knowing who a mafia is, will have that person eliminated.
 
According to the wiki it looks like the Mayor gets 2 votes. So say its 6 votes Ogre and 5 votes Sorvan and the Mayor hasn't chosen he gets 2 votes on whichever is Mafia.

But since its the middle of the game already I think we should only let the Mayor investigate possible Mafia. He gives his choice to the detective and the detective then gives 2 players to DP as inquiries.
 
KingOfTheDeep said:
the mayor can work with the detective in finding out who the mafia are, the mayor will need to find out who the detective is before they can work with eachother, the mayor can PM me with suspicions just as the detective can, but he cannot eliminate a mafia without the detectives help, if the mayor and detective know who eachother are, and the mayor has a suspicion he can share that with the detective, the detective can investigate that person, then come to me with a name, if he is right..he will be told so and that person will be eliminated....sorry if thats confusing

if you guys dont like the idea of a mayor or vigilante, you can vote to have those roles scratched from the game
Click to expand...

As the mayor, I investigated Coler the first time. He is the detective. I was also unsure of the Mayor role and asked for some clarification on it. Day 1 the above was posted. I think the Mayor & Detective roles have given the town too much power over the mafia.

I think OgreMvK should concede. We should get some firmer rules. We are all new at this and most of us do not know what we are doing. I think changing narrators mid game does not help. I am guessing that it is a lot of hard work. I would love to do it, but my wife already thinks I am at the web site too much. I would consider trying to run it, but would rather someone else jumped up.

We can still play this night out, but I am the Mayor of ACville and DangerDoll will be brought to justice tonight.
 
Last edited:
How would the Mayor get to vote twice without everyone knowing who the mayor is?
 
Dwarf Puffers said:
I'd say one a night, as long as the detective and mayor are both still together. Other than that, the mayor can investigate. The mayor and the detective can either both investigate a night or kill 1 person.

This rule makes sense, seeing as the mayor, the leader of the townies, knows who a mafia is, so it is assumed the leader of the townies, knowing who a mafia is, will have that person eliminated.
Click to expand...

/game off

Here's how I read it....in the beginning, the mayor can PM the mod once a night looking for the detective. The mod will say 'yes' or 'no', not revealing if a 'no' is town or mafia.....once the detective is found, the mayor CANNOT investigate any longer....any suspicions must be relayed to the detective for confirmation.....therefore, if the detective is whacked, the mayor effectively becomes a regular townie with no special powers.

As far as the detective/mayor investigating OR whacking on a given night.....it would make sense to me that the detective could investigate on the same night as the mayor makes a hit.

Hopefully this makes sense...anyone else reading it this way?

/game on
 
johnlarson66 said:
How would the Mayor get to vote twice without everyone knowing who the mayor is?
Click to expand...

lol I don't know. Maybe his vote is supposed to be in secret?
 
johnlarson66 said:
How would the Mayor get to vote twice without everyone knowing who the mayor is?
Click to expand...

Note that this is the mayor as posted on Wiki (2 votes) .....King of the Deep never mentioned this in the description of 'his' mayor. At any rate I assume that the mod would simply count the mayor's vote twice.
 
Madcrawdad said:
/game off

Here's how I read it....in the beginning, the mayor can PM the mod once a night looking for the detective. The mod will say 'yes' or 'no', not revealing if a 'no' is town or mafia.....once the detective is found, the mayor CANNOT investigate any longer....any suspicions must be relayed to the detective for confirmation.....therefore, if the detective is whacked, the mayor effectively becomes a regular townie with no special powers.

As far as the detective/mayor investigating OR whacking on a given night.....it would make sense to me that the detective could investigate on the same night as the mayor makes a hit.

Hopefully this makes sense...anyone else reading it this way?

/game on
Click to expand...

That's what I would think

/game on.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom