I agree, Ogre would be a good choice if he's willing, and I hope we continue. Townies only have 4 shots at the mafia left (assuming nobody else bails).
Mafia Game 3
- Thread starter KingOfTheDeep
- Start date
I agree, Ogre would be a good choice if he's willing, and I hope we continue. Townies only have 4 shots at the mafia left (assuming nobody else bails).
The last Mafia has PMed me and said everyone make a vote and if it's wrong the Mafia win (?)
I'll be able to mod until monday, prolly morning where you are. So, if the votes come in quickly, I can mod another round or 2.
I'll be able to mod until monday, prolly morning where you are. So, if the votes come in quickly, I can mod another round or 2.
yesterday I gave the above explanation of how Caveman could be mafia. Since giving the thread a quick look-thru, I've found a little additional info showing Caveman letting himself be led on the vote, a possible mafia strategy.
Below is a quote from NJ back on Day 1 where NJ accuses me of having cynical and downer posts......
Caveman jumps on it....
A little later in the day I go after Caveman pretty hard, and toss my vote his way, and a couple of folks follow. NJ then changes her vote for me.
Later in the evening JRR and FL toss in their votes for Ice
10 mins later CC follows JRR & FL.....
There are a couple of other examples where CC looks to be pretty willing to follow others on the vote.
I'm willing to vote to lynch CaptainCaveman at this point, even though I've got a stronger feeling about someone else. Coler and JohnLarson, though, were 4 for 4 in picking mafia and I can't ignore that....
if we're going with the showdown, I might need to rethink my willingness to vote for CC...I have a stronger feeling on someone else.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
I'm willing to mod for DP. If you'll send me whatever file you have with the current votes (hey, i'm dead, I haven't been keeping as good a track)
I'm willing to continue on.
I can't say I have any one person I'm big on.
I'll have to look back at past people I've suspected,should have kept notes lol.
I know FL22 was high on my list
So for now I vote to lynch Fishlady22
When is night going to start. Going to a family picnic around 2 and probably won't be home till after 9. I want to be able to read posts and make a final decision if at all possible.
I can't say I have any one person I'm big on.
I'll have to look back at past people I've suspected,should have kept notes lol.
I know FL22 was high on my list
So for now I vote to lynch Fishlady22
When is night going to start. Going to a family picnic around 2 and probably won't be home till after 9. I want to be able to read posts and make a final decision if at all possible.
A Case for Lynching '13'
As I said in an earlier post, I had a stronger feeling about someone else being mafia. That feeling would be about '13'. I said that I'd be willing to vote to lynch CCM for Coler/JL, but if going with the one-vote showdown, this would be my guy.
Early on Day 1, Ice tosses his vote at '13' for a pretty random reason. He says it doesn't mean much. It's early in the game and looks to be a way to get things going in the game.
Much later in the day, '13' sees the seemingly random vote Ice has cast for him, and retaliates. Keep in mind Ice has already changed his vote from '13' to someone else at this point.
Day 2 dawns (after DP is lynched the evening before) and '13' let's everyone know that he's got suspicions about Ice, and is sticking with his vote another day.
Still Day 2 and '13' let's everyone know he's still voting for Ice and will do so tomorrow if necessary
He's still voting for Ice, now says for no real reason...even if Ice may be an innocent
Still sticking with Ice
Still sticking with Ice like a pit bull
Still hanging onto Ice. Says he NEVER thought Ice was mafia, though. Not the most pro-town strategy, is it? Innocents are lynching each other and this guy's hanging on to Ice for a reason like this!?
Here Plantling points a weak finger at '13' and he points a weak one back a little later, maybe trying to distance themselves from each other?
'13' is still sticking w/ Ice, but would sure LIKE to vote for someone else...2 reasons here maybe.....persuade Madcrawdad to vote for NJ (as Ogre also tried), and to distance himself from Ogre?...notice that Ogre is named last.
Day 3 and the game has busted wide open. Coler/JL have outed Ogre, DD, and Sovran. '13' suggests that everyone vote for the same person....keep in mind that the Sovran lynch train is already chugging down the tracks with folks jumping on left and right.
Ooooh, '13' must REALLY dislike Ogre. Everyone else is going Sovran, but he votes Ogre. No biggie, though....still one of the 3 mafia identified (Ogre, DD, Sovran).
Next JRR, calls '13' out on not following his own 'everybody vote for 1 person'
'13' says, 'Sorry, your right.....I vote for Madcrawdad.' WHAT?! Note that I'm not protesting that I'm innocent here, but does a vote for anybody other than Ogre, DD, or Sovran make any sense at all here....Also pay attention that at this point, the mafia is scrambling and EVERY member of the dead mafia is whispering 'Madcrawdad, Madcrawdad, Madcrawdad......"
DP posts a vote count clearly showing Sovran way out front in votes, but forgets to put '13's' vote on for me. '13' reminds him "Make sure to get my vote for Madcrawdad."
Later when it's clear that he's out flapping in the breeze on the Madcrawdad vote he falls in line.....
Ogre, DD and Sovran fall, and the next day everyone is going for Plantling. At some point I cast suspicion on him, and he falls in line with the plantling vote, OR DOES HE?
Following JL's lead, I think I made a pretty strong case for lynching Plantling. She responds with some weak arguments 'It's Madcrawdad....It's FishLady.' Whatever. She can protest all she wants....but who is the ONLY guy who subtly tries to question everyone's votes for Plantling? Let's see.
Here I see '13' is stirring the pot on the plantling lynching and call him on it...
Nope...he's sticking w/ Plantling because he trusts me on this now......Keep in mind he was sure voting for me yesterday. What changed?
Then here's a post of his top mafia picks...It is what it is, but JOHN LARSON? The guy has clearly proven he's mayor at this point.....if you don't trust John Larson why are you tossing Captain Caveman in your top 2, as JL is the one who strongly pointed the finger at CC.
Still sticking with Plantling.....but EVERYONE may switch their vote from Planling to him.
Finally, more whispering "Madcrawdad....woooooohhh."
I think all of this info tells an interesting tale, don't you? If this guy's not mafia, he's sure the oddest acting townie I've ever seen....
Still not going to vote, though. Want to hear what other folks think.
As I said in an earlier post, I had a stronger feeling about someone else being mafia. That feeling would be about '13'. I said that I'd be willing to vote to lynch CCM for Coler/JL, but if going with the one-vote showdown, this would be my guy.
Early on Day 1, Ice tosses his vote at '13' for a pretty random reason. He says it doesn't mean much. It's early in the game and looks to be a way to get things going in the game.
Much later in the day, '13' sees the seemingly random vote Ice has cast for him, and retaliates. Keep in mind Ice has already changed his vote from '13' to someone else at this point.
Day 2 dawns (after DP is lynched the evening before) and '13' let's everyone know that he's got suspicions about Ice, and is sticking with his vote another day.
Still Day 2 and '13' let's everyone know he's still voting for Ice and will do so tomorrow if necessary
yeah so what i have only voted for one person and that is IceH20 yesterday and again today. i'm not going to change my vote for any reason. As far as my post's seaming hollow...well maybe i'm just not posting a big fake line of crap ? just like a mafia member would. Its only been 2 days so im sticking with my vote for awhile. heck i'll even vote for IcEH20 again tomorrow if he isn't voted out tonight.
Hollow as it may be
He's still voting for Ice, now says for no real reason...even if Ice may be an innocent
Still sticking with Ice
Still sticking with Ice like a pit bull
Still hanging onto Ice. Says he NEVER thought Ice was mafia, though. Not the most pro-town strategy, is it? Innocents are lynching each other and this guy's hanging on to Ice for a reason like this!?
Here Plantling points a weak finger at '13' and he points a weak one back a little later, maybe trying to distance themselves from each other?
'13' is still sticking w/ Ice, but would sure LIKE to vote for someone else...2 reasons here maybe.....persuade Madcrawdad to vote for NJ (as Ogre also tried), and to distance himself from Ogre?...notice that Ogre is named last.
Day 3 and the game has busted wide open. Coler/JL have outed Ogre, DD, and Sovran. '13' suggests that everyone vote for the same person....keep in mind that the Sovran lynch train is already chugging down the tracks with folks jumping on left and right.
Ooooh, '13' must REALLY dislike Ogre. Everyone else is going Sovran, but he votes Ogre. No biggie, though....still one of the 3 mafia identified (Ogre, DD, Sovran).
Next JRR, calls '13' out on not following his own 'everybody vote for 1 person'
'13' says, 'Sorry, your right.....I vote for Madcrawdad.' WHAT?! Note that I'm not protesting that I'm innocent here, but does a vote for anybody other than Ogre, DD, or Sovran make any sense at all here....Also pay attention that at this point, the mafia is scrambling and EVERY member of the dead mafia is whispering 'Madcrawdad, Madcrawdad, Madcrawdad......"
DP posts a vote count clearly showing Sovran way out front in votes, but forgets to put '13's' vote on for me. '13' reminds him "Make sure to get my vote for Madcrawdad."
Later when it's clear that he's out flapping in the breeze on the Madcrawdad vote he falls in line.....
Ogre, DD and Sovran fall, and the next day everyone is going for Plantling. At some point I cast suspicion on him, and he falls in line with the plantling vote, OR DOES HE?
Following JL's lead, I think I made a pretty strong case for lynching Plantling. She responds with some weak arguments 'It's Madcrawdad....It's FishLady.' Whatever. She can protest all she wants....but who is the ONLY guy who subtly tries to question everyone's votes for Plantling? Let's see.
Here I see '13' is stirring the pot on the plantling lynching and call him on it...
Nope...he's sticking w/ Plantling because he trusts me on this now......Keep in mind he was sure voting for me yesterday. What changed?
Then here's a post of his top mafia picks...It is what it is, but JOHN LARSON? The guy has clearly proven he's mayor at this point.....if you don't trust John Larson why are you tossing Captain Caveman in your top 2, as JL is the one who strongly pointed the finger at CC.
Still sticking with Plantling.....but EVERYONE may switch their vote from Planling to him.
Finally, more whispering "Madcrawdad....woooooohhh."
if Madcrawdad's Mafia were screwed
I think all of this info tells an interesting tale, don't you? If this guy's not mafia, he's sure the oddest acting townie I've ever seen....
Still not going to vote, though. Want to hear what other folks think.
That is a pretty good case against 13. Imagine the luck of pointing them out as the 1st lynching. Guess we should have gone with that idea and rolled them out 1st.
FL22, there is no real explanation for my vote except for that I have always thought you were, 13 was also in the mix because as pointed out above they were always on my tail.
I'm inclined to follow Mad for a couple of days. If we end up lynching 2 innocents following his lead then I say the 3rd day we take him to the guillotine.
But I would also like to see who else gets thrown under the bus and what they have to say to protect themselves. I'll post a final vote before I leave for the day but for now FL22 sticks.
FL22, there is no real explanation for my vote except for that I have always thought you were, 13 was also in the mix because as pointed out above they were always on my tail.
I'm inclined to follow Mad for a couple of days. If we end up lynching 2 innocents following his lead then I say the 3rd day we take him to the guillotine.
But I would also like to see who else gets thrown under the bus and what they have to say to protect themselves. I'll post a final vote before I leave for the day but for now FL22 sticks.
