Mafia Game #4 The Play

bkw1982 said:
I dont think CL is mafia i also don't think he is mayor...it's obvious he is tryin to save himself. My top two stll remain Zsandman and Charlie, if you need me to go into detail go read my previous post, if you need more detail just ask.
Click to expand...

Yeah...well.....I guess it was kinda a stupid sying that I am the mayor. But here are the two reasons I did it for:

(1) I thought maybe people wouldn't pick off the mayor.....but since I'm just a innocent people don't care as much if they lynch me.

(2) If the Mafia were dumb, they would have went right ahead with lynching me and thinking that I'm that mayor....which would be better then them lynching the real mayor (hope that made sense lol).

Very well said about mee-mee Mad.....I like your way of looking at things with the Mafia game.

CL
 
I am back home and playing again.

The detective and 3 innocents on day/night one ????

Its all uphill for the town from here on in; I'm going to be completely honest and say that I have no clue who to vote for, although I can see the point of voting Corylover.

JL - you voted jpappy; is there a good reason for that ?
 
Hooked Newbie said:
And 1 of the 2 I suspect are named.... I'd like to see more from Max. Frankly, it looks like he's chosen his spots to post which seems shady to me. Post your thoughts and convince me that I'm wrong.
Click to expand...

Ok,first off, for those of you that do not know me, I am FEMALE, lol, my name is Julie,Secondly, I posted in an earlier post that I wouldn't be on much fri, or sat., I am a officer for The local F.O.E, I had to paint an assemble an entire float, to be ready by sat morn at 10:00am, I also have 5 dogs, two small children, 7 fish tanks, and run a small photography business out of my home, I re-home dogs, and had a special case brought to me yes. eve., AND I mod for a bully breed board, I am trying to pack to move, lmao, I am busy! I am not choosing when I post, I am simply posting when I can.

Madcrawdad said:
As promised, here are a couple of folks currently tweaking on my mafia radar...

JudgeMax
For reasons listed by Ogre yesterday

Here Ogre claims to be setting a trap. Thanks for tossing me in for bait, old boy.


Immediately JudgeMax bites with this one saying that it would make sense if Julie were given a special mafia role.as stated before, i had my own suspicions, I didn't ask anyone else to vote for them, I was just stating that IMO they seemed to be acting funny..I have not tried to sway any votes either, I was simply stating what I was thinking...

Julie counters with this regarding random assignment of roles. Make sense to me.


Then Judge points out that even with random assigments, her original statement still makes sense. NOT TO ME. Unless of course, rbishop is cheating.
I am not saying rbishop is cheating, i would never call someone a cheat, I was saying, strategically, If It weren't random, it would be the perfect play.

Ever seen this before? Folks whispering other people's names and 'mafia' at the same time. JudgeMax is one to watch.

I have stated that I am not mafia, I can say it again, but what would that really do?..make me look just as guilty, I can also assure you, for those that might be wondering, I am also not the mayor, or any other special role, I am simply smart, and did what all of you are doing, following hunches, I did not jump on any lynch trains, I went with what I stated from the get go, I still believe NJ is acting suspicious, I am entitled to think that, its the name of the game , elimination, you figure out who is who , bu the process of elimination.

That said, Ice was the detective, he could have investigated me, if he really wanted, I am sure he could have lynched me, or led a lynch train on me, With a vote from him and NJ, If you all felt I was that suspicious of a character, you should have voted for me, It wouldn't have changed the innocent dead count at all. (nor the mafia, for those that need that spelled out)

I think we all really need to smarten up, We lost the detective, we are in TROUBLEif we can't get our acts together, Now I only have one other question, I agree with wanting to know what everyone else is thinking, but I wouldn't keep posting lists of suspects, If you get them all right, do you really think they are going to lynch that particular person?..Um no, because we will then vote for everyone on that list, and that would be a stupid move on their part. I suggest, we maybe name one, and our reasoning, that way, you can still see what other people are thinking, and become less of a mafia pawn by doing so.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
JL I stand corrected by myself - in fact Jensons voted jpappy...still interested in the reason...I was suspicious of jpappy though (no offence, we're all suspects)
 
Coler said:
I am back home and playing again.

The detective and 3 innocents on day/night one ????

Its all uphill for the town from here on in; I'm going to be completely honest and say that I have no clue who to vote for, although I can see the point of voting Corylover.

JL - you voted jpappy; is there a good reason for that ?
Click to expand...

Welcome back! You were missed!

I assume that, since I am the only one who voted for jpappy, that you are asking me if I had good reasons. See my last post (48_?, I think) for my reasons.

~brandy
 
OgreMkV said:
1] I posted the odds already2] dd is in the clear as for as i'm concerned. surely the mafia knows how many there are... unless she's snowing me.
Click to expand...

I am not getting what you are saying here?..Why would dd be clear for you unless you know, because you are in the mafia. we are all guilty in this game until we are killed, and shown otherwise?..

And since no mafia were killed, there should only be six, ..why would that even be a question?..

I am also curious as to why you suggest that mad, and you be "investigated"?..
You and he play so differently, yet, you both command such attention form the other players?..I am not calling you mafia, nor mad, I am undecided, because you both play so forward, I have a hard time feeling you two out.
So, I am just asking, that since you two are both so influential, if you two, could maybe keep that in mind, when "talking in the thread" we are in a dire situation here, and I would hate to see the mafia get the town, I kinda like it here.
 
^ Ogre...just because someone 'pretends' not to know how many mafia there are...doesn't mean they're not mafia...I'm not saying DD is or anything but come on...

...anyway...we only have the mayor left to investigate...it might not be a bad idea to investigate e.g. madcrawdad...not doing much posting which I think is a little different from the other games.
 
Madcrawdad said:
Hmmm. Kind of a knee-jerk reaction to toss a vote for Cory Lover this early in Day 2, isn't it? It seems unlikely to me that the mafia would have pegged Ice's true identity so soon; their hit on the detective was probably just lucky.

The mafia probably predicted the townies' reaction to lynch Cory Lover, as Ice was hot on his trail (for the only reason that Cory Lover claimed to be an innocent). It was only Day 1, and any case against anyone was pretty weak. Whacking anyone for getting 'too close' seems a little unlikely at this point in time.

I'm not telling folks not to vote for Cory Lover, just keep looking carefully elsewhere at the same time. Don't let let the fact that the detective got whacked cloud your judgement.
Click to expand...

I could not have said this better myself...Although I tried, and failed miserably, lmao, I guess I am just to wordy...
 
judgemax said:
Ok,first off, for those of you that do not know me, I am FEMALE, lol, my name is Julie,Secondly, I posted in an earlier post that I wouldn't be on much fri, or sat., I am a officer for The local F.O.E, I had to paint an assemble an entire float, to be ready by sat morn at 10:00am, I also have 5 dogs, two small children, 7 fish tanks, and run a small photography business out of my home, I re-home dogs, and had a special case brought to me yes. eve., AND I mod for a bully breed board, I am trying to pack to move, lmao, I am busy! I am not choosing when I post, I am simply posting when I can.
Click to expand...

Sorry Julie! lol No offense intended...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom