Mafia Game #4 The Play

[ZSandmann]

Ogre you summed it all up nicely and tastefully too I will add. No need to discuss this further till after this game is over in my opinion.

My lists:

Mafia:
Mee-Mee
bkw1982, although like I said I think your recent posts increased your cred with me.
KOTD? Still don't really like this pick.
Jensons?
SHK-ATK?


Innocent:
judgemax
guppyguppyfish
Ogre
MadCrawdad

a lot of this is just feeling from the Tone of their posts. Of course it is easy in text to imply a Tone that does not exist.

 

[ZSandmann]

I am changing my vote from Mee-mee to Coler

my guess is that someone may have been watching his profile, and when night ended saw that he was the one PMing (maybe sending a hit to rbishop).
Coler IS the Don......

Set 'em up, guys....let's knock 'em down. Won't this be fun!!??

Woah, wait, what? How'd I miss this? I'm not convinced he is Don. The whole you don't want to vote for me, because I'm innocent, and it would be a very bad idea thing, is a little over the top.

 

[OgreMkV]

I am changing my vote from Mee-mee to Coler

my guess is that someone may have been watching his profile, and when night ended saw that he was the one PMing (maybe sending a hit to rbishop).
Coler IS the Don......

Set 'em up, guys....let's knock 'em down. Won't this be fun!!??

This is the kind of thing that makes me very nervous about you Mad. You've been on mee-mee for two days... now a switch... sets my antenna aquiver

 

[Sovran]

After wading through the last 5 pages, there is nothing new! Have you never heard the term divide and conquer? The mafia must have!

I do like the precis of HN's posts - I still think he is mafia
Mee-Mee is still the one I am voting to lynch tonight
I have a gut feeling that Coler is, as well as MadCrawdad

Just my 2 cents worth.

 

[OgreMkV]

After wading through the last 5 pages, there is nothing new! Have you never heard the term divide and conquer? The mafia must have!

Agreed

I do like the precis of HN's posts - I still think he is mafia
Mee-Mee is still the one I am voting to lynch tonight
I have a gut feeling that Coler is, as well as MadCrawdad

Just my 2 cents worth.

Tell me why on Hooked Newbie cause I really didn't see anything.

 

[Madcrawdad]

This is the kind of thing that makes me very nervous about you Mad. You've been on mee-mee for two days... now a switch... sets my antenna aquiver

I seriously think that Mee-mee is mafia and that we can take her next.... To truly test the 'list,' I think we need to take someone other than Mee-mee, as Mee-mee was already pegged before the list came to light.

If folks think that the list has any chance of being accurate, testing with Coler makes more sense. After all he was accused of being the Don, so why not take him out and if he is guilty the mafia won't get their 3rd and final investigation? If he's innocent, that's very unfortunate, as he's a smart player and the townies can use him. But, I think it's clear that he's been a little uninvolved this game and the town may not suffer too much.

 

[FireDancer7905]

This has been a very interesting read. I do not believe that someone would cheat in an AC game. It would be silly. I do believe that judgemax is probably innocent, based on being miraculously saved by the doc. I think that mee-mee will prove to be the next person lynched, and I believe that she is mafia, more likely than not. I will vote for her at the end of this post. My top mafia suspects remain fairly solid from my previous posting, only a few small changes:

mee-mee - you have been screaming mafia from the very first, defending CL more loudly than anyone else

Jpappy- I think that you are a quiet, well spoken player who is subtly pushing votes

SHK_ATK - weak reasoning- but he seems to follow jpappy and sandy (sp?) in his voting/thinking

ZSandsmann- follows jpappy, again without reason, couldn't find the quote I was looking for.. and now I am on his mafia suspects list, without a reason, just like I was with jpappy.

The above players all seem to me to follow each other and be fairly consistent. I think that at the very least, we ned to look at them a bit mroe closely.

Hooked and BKW, I am on the fence about. I will reread posts about them after I get home from my errands.

I agree with you, sandy, about Ogre's post.

Ogre you summed it all up nicely and tastefully too I will add. No need to discuss this further till after this game is over in my opinion.

My lists:

Mafia:
Mee-Mee
bkw1982, although like I said I think your recent posts increased your cred with me.
KOTD? Still don't really like this pick.
Jensons?
SHK-ATK?

Innocent:
judgemax
guppyguppyfish
Ogre
MadCrawdad

a lot of this is just feeling from the Tone of their posts. Of course it is easy in text to imply a Tone that does not exist.

I am curious as to why I am on your list. I would be more than happy to refute claims, if I knew what they were.

I vote to lynch mee-mee.

~ Cheers! ~ brandy ~

 

[mee-mee]

Y'all have fun playing the game, since it seems I am going to be lynched...and won't you be surprised to see "Innocent" next to my name when I am lynched..I am not going to defend myself any longer, cuz it just seems to dig me a bigger hole...I have tried to say things over and over again, but everyone just takes them out of context,..so enjoy the game..

(btw, JM,,,cute puppies ya got...)

 

[ZSandmann]

I am curious as to why I am on your list. I would be more than happy to refute claims, if I knew what they were.

As I said, nothing solid on you, I just had a feeling. But note how far down the list you are. I said a while back I think some of the quieter layers are Mafia lying back and waiting and you fit that description, but so do several others.

I don't think I follow jpappy or anyone for that matter. I've been listening to everyone and making my own observations. Some I clearly say have backing, some clearly do not. I'm not trying to be anything other than what I am. But I'm glad you're watching me, if you're a Townie you should be cautious of everyone.

 

[FireDancer7905]

As I said, nothing solid on you, I just had a feeling. But note how far down the list you are. I said a while back I think some of the quieter layers are Mafia lying back and waiting and you fit that description, but so do several others.

I don't think I follow jpappy or anyone for that matter. I've been listening to everyone and making my own observations. Some I clearly say have backing, some clearly do not. I'm not trying to be anything other than what I am. But I'm glad you're watching me, if you're a Townie you should be cautious of everyone.

Cool beans.