Mafia Game #4 The Play

[NeonJulie]

You will be the first person to know huh?..are you setting it up now?..Cory lover maybe mafia, but I know you are, and I strongly suspect hooked newbie, some pieces just fell together in my head, as I reread things, ...If he is, with or with out my vote, hes probably gone tonight, I am not switching my vote off you., although, I would like to see some more on you!..

And back to the confidence. And a new look - a feisty look to go along with confused, timid, scared, defensive, and unsure.

When most people clinch the whole shebang, simply by "rereading things" it's kind of nice to catch the rest of us up, by at least LEADING us to what you were rereading, and letting us use our grey cells, whether or not we can... Just saying... otherwise, it sounds like a lot of, well nothing again. Again you try and sway people to vote with you, "although, I would like to see some more on you!..." without giving anyone reasons!

 

[NeonJulie]

Interesting twist there. I always find a sudden switch to left field without any explanations interesting. I am not saying I disbelieve you, just reluctant to start pointing fingers just on a random say so. Please post your reasons for suddenly deciding to get rid of both Coler and Hooked - you might be onto something there, just want to look at your reasoning.

Just so people don't think I'm the only one with a big Mystery Axe to grind... other innocents begin to feel bewildered like me and want some proof. More will come later. All will be refused though.

 

[judgemax]

Wait this isn't the clue is it? Corey Lover's "ma...." post?? It seems like that would be really obvious... or something everyone would completely miss, and would be no benefit to us Townies. Remember, no one even got my "do no harm" and "curing" and "altruistic" hints about me being the doctor...

just so you know, as I was reading the last game, i did catch that you were the dr, but thats irrelevant at this point..

 

[FireDancer7905]

*gameoff*
NeonJulie, You torrent of posts is proving to be informative, in more ways than one. Please, please go back and read the last post by JudgeMax. Even though this is a game, it is still possible to hurt feelings.
*game on*

 

[NeonJulie]

JM, by all means, please post your reasoning. If you want us to switch, you have to provide more than that.

As far as I'm concerned, I suspect you lots more than Coler.

Again, most people can't make a change so outlandish and not expect some questions answered. It's well, s u s p i c i o u s. Coler up to that point had been mildly suspicious on Ogre's radar, and with that you leap above him. Obviously that changes later (which as this story unfolds, I am eager to learn why everyone's opinion of you changes, which I think is simply because you survived a hit, not because you're posting behaviour has been so outlandish, most of us at this point don't remember how to play a normal game. *lol*)

In a nutshell... "you have to provide more than that." But have you...? More to come. I'm going to dig for this clue, and I'm digging about the clue giver, and not until I'm done will I make a cast for a vote, but I will most certainly go off of my own research and brain, even if it's apparently not up to the standard I once thought it was. *lol* :headshake2:

 

[Hooked Newbie]

It may take me some time to digest all your posts, NJ. I'm not gonna ignore them, but I'm gonna address HN first.



Well, HN, my one line agreement was just that. I was just communicating to Judge why you might still be a good Mafia suspect. But please note that I did not put you on my list. I still do not have a solid 3rd Mafia candidate. The timing of your vote on that 1st night made me suspect you. And if you were really trying to ally yourself with DD, you would have casted your vote for CL as she did. So I've not ruled you out as Mafia either, but then a lot of ppl fit into that category.

As far as being smart, I haven't claimed it. As far as my posts not being substantial, I have however posted my observations and opinions as I am able to post. I think it's more quality than quantity. I did try to rally votes for CL on night 1. I did point out my suspicions on CL, mee-mee, and KOTD on day 2. I have tried to put up a case explaining why I think KOTD is Mafia. And today I will vote for KOTD or Coler, whomever I decide is most likely to be the Mafia Don. And I will post more observations and opinions as I get them.

And I've appreciated the "substantial" posts from you which is why I would have liked to see more in that case. That is why I said you semmed smart, not because you claimed it. I went throw every post last night and tried to pull the one's that I was curious about or that raised my hackles some. They're really in no particular order.

(Has anyone else noticed that the amount of posts are insane? (Good, but insane...).

 

[bkw1982]

NJ i enjoy reading your post but i think your tryin to bleed a rock. Judge can't be mafia. If she is mafia i will hail her as the greatest mafia ever. In order for her to pull off almost being killed and saved by the doctor wold take almost supernatural powers, or some type of time machine....judge do u have a time machine?

 

[NeonJulie]

Unfortunatly, I can not give my arguments at this time, I may put someone we need in jeopardy, please just believe me, And if I am wrong, you can lynch me, but we need coler gone, like last night.

just give me this, I will try and put together my reasoning, however , i do not have time now, And if I don't get it together, and they lynch me, I can not stress more, to you, to watch hooked newbie! ..

It's always a good cover up for secrecy to claim you are doing it to help the town, and because you may oust someone's secret important identity. Well. You've been so unforthcoming with names previously, that if you did give the arguments, which would most likely consist of pronouns and vague context and repeating what others have said... no one would probably know who it is you were ever talking about.....

And it's true... you say we need Coler gone, like last night. And yet no one seems to be all the concerned about him. It seems fickle makes a come back later, since I have to be the one apparently, to remind the Town that he's looking most definitely mafia, and very good reason, to be the Don.

Oh, don't forget, you stress, to watch Hooked Newbie! Well... thanks for somewhat insulting our intelligence, but we HAVE been, we are watching EVERYBODY. What are we to look for?

It's really kind of sad that you can't find some way to explain it to us, and leave the innocent bystander out of this. Even a hint, would likely have eased my wonder by now.

If it's one thing I've learned about people, and so it's obvious that you must know this too with criminology 101, it's that when you tell people 'I can't tell you, it's a secret, just believe me' all it does it make us want to know MORE. It doesn't calm curiosity a bit! *lol*

 

[ZSandmann]

NJ i enjoy reading your post but i think your tryin to bleed a rock. Judge can't be mafia. If she is mafia i will hail her as the greatest mafia ever. In order for her to pull off almost being killed and saved by the doctor wold take almost supernatural powers, or some type of time machine....judge do u have a time machine?

BKW I agree with you! (shock ) NJ is doing back reading which is great but she's hitting issues we've long since addressed. Once she gets to the Night 2 hit, she'll see.

 

[NeonJulie]

Whew! Just got caught up. Mighty interesting discussions today and as I suspected since I haven't been around to roleplay today my name has fallen off most peoples public Mafia lists. Except JL66 which is interesting to me. Why does he continue to count me such a high priority suspect? Rest assured that the roleplaying will return after dinner. My vote remains on CL.

#2 bkw1982: For all my previous reasons.

#3 Now johnlarson66: At first I just thought it was because I was roleplaying but now I think it is because I make an easy target for you to try and put out there. Since you're probably Mafia you would want to have people like myself to point at the take heat off any real Mafia targets we, the citizens, nail. You may still be a civilian that just doesn't like RP, but I'm watching more closely now.

Well, whether or not JohnLarson66 and Bkw1982 are of similar mind again... it still appears these 3 are suspicious of eachother.

Ok... JL and Bk both think Zs. Zs thinks both of them. JL changes to include BK as a suspect. That means of the triangle, both Sz and JL are suspicious of BK. And so am I, from the beginning, has definitely not been a community thinking-and reason finder. Just... points...