Mafia who done it! The Play

[IceH2O]

CL- Why would anyone need to "hint" to their team? They can communicate right? It seems as if Jpappy may be a night one mafia target to me...

I retract my vote to lynch bkw and vote to lynch Cory Lover.

If Jpap was going to be the 1st night hit then why would they even bother throwing any suspicion his way? I think CL inadvertently brought focus to something that was supposed to be a hint to the innocents. Or Jpap is trying to make us think that.

To add to that post...I hardly saw it was colored gray...until I looked closer. Most people probably read it and didn't see it.

Ok...one last thing...then give me a reason you think he would shade it gray?

Your right most didn't see it most likely. I'm sure it wasn't something he wanted focused on either. I'll let you think about why "saving" might be a lighter colored word. Bet the mafia have figured it out.

Ok pick the easy one who was not on-line....(was in class last night) and I do believe BK is you better bet for mustard.

Why is BK a better choice then RB CS or Mad?


I kind of agree with Ogre that RB is looking less then townie. He came in made 1 quick post about how Andi is Col Mustard, obviously a BS post, then left. There was actually a bit of posting last night to talk about.

I know I said they don't need to distance but Ogre is correct that they'll probably try. Its sort of built into the actions of being mafia.

Is Andi protecting RB and CS by pointing HN towards BK?


Just for kicks here are my Fave 5:

Mad
Andi
RB
CS
Emo

Chances are some are in fact mafia, chances are that not all of them are mafia. This is merely a 1st look gut feeling list and something to look back at and see how right or wrong I was.

 

[Madcrawdad]

(post clipped)Why is BK a better choice then RB CS or Mad?

Just for kicks here are my Fave 5:

Mad
Andi
RB
CS
Emo

Chances are some are in fact mafia, chances are that not all of them are mafia. This is merely a 1st look gut feeling list and something to look back at and see how right or wrong I was.

Here's the thing Ice, it's fine if you want to trust your 'gut,' but when you start pushing me as an 'obvious' choice to the rest of the town, because of your 'gut instinct,' I really have to wonder about your affiliation.

As far as your 'gut' being such a good indicator about me being scum, I'll enlighten you. In the whole time I've been playing mafia on AC, I've only been scum 3 times: Vampire Game I, Zombie Game I, and Pirate Game.

Vampire Game I - you modded that game, so I don't think your gut told you that I was scum then...

Zombie Game I - you remarked after the game that you thought I was the Doctor, so I don't think your gut told you that I was scum then...

Pirate Game - I do recall you saying after the game that you thought I might be scum, and that, as guard, you considered hitting me. So, I'll give you this one...

Apparently that leaves one time where you thought that I might be scum, and actually was. Therefore you're basing your 'gut instinct' on one case. That would make your 'every time' statement a little misleading, wouldn't you say?

An interesting point is that in the last game we played together you were scum and I wasn't.... You pulled out the same 'gut instinct' argument against me then, too. Pretty interesting, don't you think?

 

[jpappy789]

Hmmm...interesting Ice. Below is Andis post in question...

Ok pick the easy one who was not on-line....(was in class last night) and I do believe BK is you better bet for mustard.

Not hard to understand until you look at what this was in response to...below are the 4 posts she quoted.

If you read between the letters, andi spells Col Mustard...

Good idea Andi. I think I've already spotted a scumbag.
I vote to lynch Andi.

Note the above section highlighted in red. You say your vote for me is mostly random. Mostly random. Which part isn't random? The fact that you want to vote for someone who might disrupt your evil plan??? And already making excuses so you can lay low for a couple days??? Should I salute you Colonel???

I'm not jumping on an easy train and that looks suspicious? The last couple games have been in very different formats. I'm not comfortable in this format (almost 50/50) with taking an "easy" vote... the only reason that I don't vote you now is that I remember how easy it was to railroad you and I don't want to see that happen this game if you're innocent and the vote by bkw looked suspect. Curious that you seem to defend him after he "randomly" voted you... I think I might smell something... Is that mustard on bk's breath?

Ok pick the easy one who was not on-line....(was in class last night) and I do believe BK is you better bet for mustard.

Seems like her first part was a response to Rb and Chas "picking" on her (The first two posts) but then she completely turns around and uses Hn's slight suspicions of Bkw to deflect attention? Hn's post had nothing to do with her but somehow she found the need to use it in her defense. Without Hn's quote that would be quite a statement, saying that bkw is the one that should be looked at w/o any evidence, yet with Hn's post is andi trying to build on the slightest suspicion while attatching herself to Hn? Seems odd to me...

 

[LesbianChap]

With about 25 hours till nightfall, here's the post counts:

User Name Posts
Cory Lover - 15
Hooked Newbie - 11
IceH2O - 9
Madcrawdad - 8
LesbianChap - 8
judgemax - 6
bkw1982 - 5
bethkira2000 - 4
OgreMkV - 4
andi872 - 3
charlie_stubbs - 3
jpappy789 - 3
punk_kid(emo_batsukeman) - 1
rbishop - 1

Don't think it says much...but there it is...RB is being quieter then usual, Emo isn't saying a word, Jpap isn't posting as much as in previous games...I'm sure all of them have excuses, of course. Jpap with school, RB with "playing it easy" from the drama in the last 3 games...and Emo, well he's just being Emo...

Some people seem to be talking more (Bkw, Andi, Ogre), but are really just not getting drowned out in this game compared to others where we'd be 3 pages in by now. We got a couple loudmouths (HN/Cory) which seems about usual for them, and everyone else is sitting around average.

I'm not seeing anything in the numbers by themselves, but I'd like to see some people post more so we can actually see who's side they're on.

 

[IceH2O]

Lets just cut to the chase and drop some dead weight


I vote to lynch Lchap

if he didnt proclaim tht he did it cause he didnt want to ud i woulda taken it as a joke vote.

If nightfall ended tonight my vote would either stay on LC or land on JP.

LC-is acting way to calm and isnt as out there, and yes im aware that its only been a few post, but compared to last game he was all over the place. My assumption is tht he either matured in the game(*note not a shot at your actually maturity lvl) or he is being instructed by someone

JP-the joke vote for c-stubbs and proclaiming he'll be away so he did so he wont UD

BK if you thought that Jpaps vote was a joke then why does that put him on your list?
As for LC we all have played with our style till we found something that fit us. LC has finally figured out that being all over the place doesn't help you as either team. Doesn't point to him being innocent or mafia but I don't think it can be chalked up to coaching.

Please tell me were LC defended me, seems your trying hard to make connections....Excuse HN.....is that grey poupon you're using?





After i vote LC u jump out and defend him and then vote me? are you the reason LC is so calm and collected?

Now I have to agree I didn't see LC protect you,except to not put you on his list of people he is watching, but I also don't see HN protecting LC. I just see HN being a bit more careful this game as we don't have the numbers to screw up. We have to hit mafia no ands ifs or buts about it.


Tell you the truth you kind of made me rethink my list. Maybe its you and not Mad that should be sitting on top.

 

[LesbianChap]

Oh, and I got an early mission tomorrow out here, so I'm popping an Ambien here in a little bit and going to bed. Sorry I won't be around to post much, but I promise to be around tomorrow afternoon and evening before nightfall unless the world falls apart over here.

And just in case the world falls apart, I'm going to put my vote on someone that's seeming the least townie at the moment:
I vote to lynch RB.

And as always, it's subject to change.

 

[IceH2O]

Here's the thing Ice, it's fine if you want to trust your 'gut,' but when you start pushing me as an 'obvious' choice to the rest of the town, because of your 'gut instinct,' I really have to wonder about your affiliation.

As far as your 'gut' being such a good indicator about me being scum, I'll enlighten you. In the whole time I've been playing mafia on AC, I've only been scum 3 times: Vampire Game I, Zombie Game I, and Pirate Game.

Vampire Game I - you modded that game, so I don't think your gut told you that I was scum then...

Zombie Game I - you remarked after the game that you thought I was the Doctor, so I don't think your gut told you that I was scum then...

Pirate Game - I do recall you saying after the game that you thought I might be scum, and that, as guard, you considered hitting me. So, I'll give you this one...

Apparently that leaves one time where you thought that I might be scum, and actually was. Therefore you're basing your 'gut instinct' on one case. That would make your 'every time' statement a little misleading, wouldn't you say?

An interesting point is that in the last game we played together you were scum and I wasn't.... You pulled out the same 'gut instinct' argument against me then, too. Pretty interesting, don't you think?

Maybe the statement should have been my gut has been right on what side you've been on. I haven't gone back and won't to check on if you've only been bad 3 times because it seems like twice I had a chance to take a shot at you and would have been right both times. The zombie game might have been the 1st one that I wish I had taken the shot because of gut feeling but then you made me think you were the Dr. But the original feeling was evil.

Either way you're starting to be really defensive over something I'm not even pushing that hard.

I actually want to see what transpires tonight and tomorrow before I cement my vote. I agree that we need to take out the lurkers, especially ones that are normally talkative like RB. But your defensiveness is making it harder to look away from you.

 

[bethkira2000]

Well,
LC- nothing to go on either way yet

CL- I think its funny how quick you make a big deal out of Jpaps shading. Not saying that there is nothing there, just not jumping to conclusions yet

Ice-well he's Ice to hard to read yet.

Mad-just normal day one stuff, nothing either way yet

Ogre-Nothing either

Jpap-your shaded post was off, but not sure there is anything too it

Andi-not sure of you yet this is only the second game with you as well

LC-nothing yet, but you seem to be back to normal.

Bk-nothing either way yet

HN-nothing on you either

RB-well he is Rb

Beth-well I know myself enough said

It really is too early to have a definate thought on people.

Hopefully I didn't miss anyone

 

[bethkira2000]

Sorry I forgot 1
Emo-serioudly dude if your not gonna play why sign up

 

[Madcrawdad]

Either way you're starting to be really defensive over something I'm not even pushing that hard.

Not defensive in the least... Just trying to find scum.

Using the 'gut instinct' rationale versus any logic tends to get my attention. It kind of falls in with naming someone as scum because 'their posting just seems off,' or 'you just can't put your finger on it...'. Usually it's scum (or poorer players) who whip these lines out.