Mafia who done it! The Play

[andi872]

Ok....



Umm..that was your tree kicking session? Musta been kicking mini trees.....

:rofl:


or to busy at the hot dog stand....

Thats to funny. You're unwilling to help the town lynch someone you think is mafia?

Since Andi never did come back and post anything after she said she would and I think the Col would be more then likely to be quiet I retract my vote on Mad and vote to lynch Andi.

Ok....I vote to lynch Andi...but it is subject to change...especially depending on what rb does.

Maybe a bit, but I think I have reason.





I agree that Andi's bonzai kicking is lacking and worthy of note, but the timing here is shady at best. Cory and Ice both move up, though I think Ice would be smart enough to tell him not to vote immediately after he did.

OFF GAME} This is to explain the above situation, after my post my whole office was called in to a staff meeting, Yes I post at work, anyone who has played with me knows this. We where givin disturbing news, so I have to focus on some other things the rest of the day. In a nut shell my company will be doing lay-offs if some thing does not change with the econimy in the next 30 to 60 days, I work with subdivisions, and most of you relise the housing market sucks ATM.

And Last night I had to study for a test that I have tonight{game on

 

[Madcrawdad]

This is a very general, 'duh' statement... but it might show some insight.

It seems that there are many people voting their own way here. Well, duh, Ogre, what does that mean? It means that we are screwed. Almost half the field is mafia, with all of us innocents voting individually, it won't even take the entire mafia team to move the vote however they want to.

I don't know if everyone is afraid to start a kynch train or what is going on, but what we have now means we're pretty dead.

Unfortunately, the info we have to go on is not the best. I've been thinking about this and I vote to lynch Ice. I'm not 'following' rb because he's pertty much admitted to an OMGUS vote. Here are my reasons:

1) The 'instant' analysis that occured very early in the game
2) The 'gut instinct' comments
3) IMO, Ice is playing very aggressive, even for him. It's almost like he wants us to vote for him. Maybe this is a distraction from the Colonel?

If Ice is mafia, then we're in good shape for tomorrow whether he's the Colonel or not. I'd rather get the Colonel tonight, but the chances of that are slim. I just think Ice is our best shot at a bad guy right now.

Ice has seriously piqued my interest this game. While Ice is generally a more bold player, his logic usually makes sense. This game, though, his logic has been pretty useless.

Ice generally likes to play out in front, even when mafia. When scum, he also likes to play psychological games to make people wonder 'why would he do that if he were scum?' As Ice started off pretty early in this game, I don't know that he's protecting anyone....I wouldn't be surprised to find out that he was actually Col. Mustard himself (although I wouldn't bank on it, either).

I still would like folks to at least take a look at LChap. Later in the day, if it looks like I'm wasting my vote, I would strongly consider moving over to Ice.

 

[andi872]

Beth, go back to post #79. Jpap says something to the effect 'I didn't even notice that.' Says to me that he's claiming that it was unintentional. I absolutely don't think it makes him scum, but it's a little weird is all.

However Little weird is sometimes all we have to go on with the first night of any game, a slip is a slip.

 

[andi872]

OFF GAME} This is to explain the above situation, after my post my whole office was called in to a staff meeting, Yes I post at work, anyone who has played with me knows this. We where givin disturbing news, so I have to focus on some other things the rest of the day. In a nut shell my company will be doing lay-offs if some thing does not change with the econimy in the next 30 to 60 days, I work with subdivisions, and most of you relise the housing market sucks ATM.

And Last night I had to study for a test that I have tonight{game on

Sorry I see in the post above my spelling sucks as well

 

[Cory Lover]

OFF GAME} This is to explain the above situation, after my post my whole office was called in to a staff meeting, Yes I post at work, anyone who has played with me knows this. We where givin disturbing news, so I have to focus on some other things the rest of the day. In a nut shell my company will be doing lay-offs if some thing does not change with the econimy in the next 30 to 60 days, I work with subdivisions, and most of you relise the housing market sucks ATM.

And Last night I had to study for a test that I have tonight{game on

Ok...well...start tree kicking now then...

My vote is staying on you for now...though with that explanation it doesn't make the vote that firm on you anymore...and I may change it.

 

[Cory Lover]

So Ice... how do you feel about playing follow the leader with the voting?

I'll call my Emo with your Cory. lmao

Oh go suck an egg :silly:

 

[andi872]

Ok...well...start tree kicking now then...

My vote is staying on you for now...though with that explanation it doesn't make the vote that firm on you anymore...and I may change it.

At lunch time I will, there are so mant to kick ATM, the only person I'm sure about is me....lol

 

[Cory Lover]

Okay Mad fair enough, I think that CL should have let the whole "Shading incident go. And I told him to. But then you say that Jpap said he never did it, The only reference that I could find about that was #79 where he said he didn't see that he needed to hint to a team mate. But did he actually say he didn't do it?

Could you please show me the post you told me to let it go? I looked through all your posts...couldn't find anything.

 

[Cory Lover]

Mafia-meter:

Andi-7

RB-6

jpap-6

Ice-5

Charlie-5

Mad-5

HN-6

bkw-5

emo-5

beth-4

LC-5

Ogre-4


As you can see...not a wide ranging difference.

Later today, I will post a list of the players with my thoughts, and re-evaluate my vote if need be.

Matt

 

[Hooked Newbie]

@Cory/HN
I don't really see where HN has defended JPap quite a bit, but apparently HN somewhat agrees... HN, you mention that you have reason to defend JPap. What reason?

I'd really rather not right now in case I am right. I do right now believe he's innocent though.