Mafia who done it! The Play

I agree with what others have said regarding Ice. Something isn't quite kosher there. LChap has piqued my interest with his comment to Mad about himself and others being the towns strongest innocents. I think i smell a rat. Ice being the more dangerous of the two, I retract my vote for Andi, and vote to lynch Ice.
 
Haha I knew Charlie would come off Andi once there were enough votes to make it dangerous to be there. Of course he moved to me as I'm the most dangerous to his group,his words not mine.

Andi still hasn't given me reason to come off of her so I'm staying put.

RBs reasons for voting me are non existent, at least Ogre gave reasoning and I respect that. Though you'd think townies would pull posts to backup claims.Charlie jumped on for the reason I posted above.

You guys can think what you want about my aggressiveness this round. With being statistically outnumbered I decided that I was going to attack anything I thought worthwhile and force players to have to post and answer. I don't think we have time to sit back and think things through and watch. I'm definitely not going to let someone lurk in the shadows and stay quiet.Thus the reason for my vote on Andi. If she had posted something today worth while I would have switched to Beth as while she has posted she hasn't exactly pointed out anything.



Andi I'd like to know what you think was a slip? What do you gather from the graying of the word?


I think I might have been pretty darn close with my original list of Mad RB Charlie Andi though Emo I'm not sure I was correct on. You'd think he'd be better coached then to say HN is playing the same as him. If I had to add someone and since you guys are going to let the mafia lynch me I'd say Bkw or Ogre could be good choices for a fifth. Though I think the Col is most important to get so I'd start with the quieter of the list Andi,RB,Charlie,BKW/Ogre then Mad.

The only thing that bothers me is 3 on my possible list being on me. Most times they won't do that though my teams have in the past. With the game being able to be over quickly though it might not be as hurtful to them to do it. I would probably take Ogre off my list and put Bkw in his place based on that reason above that 3 probably wouldn't be on me at this time.

I'll bet tonights hit is Jpap and if I'm lynched then you're down 2 innocents. Then all they need to do is trick you into lynching another innocent and its game over. It'll be 6-5 after tonight then 5-5 if you lynch an innocent and then their hit gives them 4-5. Pretty quick game in any case.
 
IceH2O said:
Haha I knew Charlie would come off Andi once there were enough votes to make it dangerous to be there. Of course he moved to me as I'm the most dangerous to his group,his words not mine.

Andi still hasn't given me reason to come off of her so I'm staying put.

RBs reasons for voting me are non existent, at least Ogre gave reasoning and I respect that. Though you'd think townies would pull posts to backup claims.Charlie jumped on for the reason I posted above.

You guys can think what you want about my aggressiveness this round. With being statistically outnumbered I decided that I was going to attack anything I thought worthwhile and force players to have to post and answer. I don't think we have time to sit back and think things through and watch. I'm definitely not going to let someone lurk in the shadows and stay quiet.Thus the reason for my vote on Andi. If she had posted something today worth while I would have switched to Beth as while she has posted she hasn't exactly pointed out anything.



Andi I'd like to know what you think was a slip? What do you gather from the graying of the word?


I think I might have been pretty darn close with my original list of Mad RB Charlie Andi though Emo I'm not sure I was correct on. You'd think he'd be better coached then to say HN is playing the same as him. If I had to add someone and since you guys are going to let the mafia lynch me I'd say Bkw or Ogre could be good choices for a fifth. Though I think the Col is most important to get so I'd start with the quieter of the list Andi,RB,Charlie,BKW/Ogre then Mad.

The only thing that bothers me is 3 on my possible list being on me. Most times they won't do that though my teams have in the past. With the game being able to be over quickly though it might not be as hurtful to them to do it. I would probably take Ogre off my list and put Bkw in his place based on that reason above that 3 probably wouldn't be on me at this time.

I'll bet tonights hit is Jpap and if I'm lynched then you're down 2 innocents. Then all they need to do is trick you into lynching another innocent and its game over. It'll be 6-5 after tonight then 5-5 if you lynch an innocent and then their hit gives them 4-5. Pretty quick game in any case.
Click to expand...

Ice, I share your concerns about Beth not really pointing anything out. What are your thoughts on LChap? Don't you think it's odd that he says that you, Hooked Newbie, Beth and himself may be the town's strongest innocents?
 
Madcrawdad said:
Ice, I share your concerns about Beth not really pointing anything out. What are your thoughts on LChap? Don't you think it's odd that he says that you, Hooked Newbie, Beth and himself may be the town's strongest innocents?
Click to expand...

Because I think most of that list IS innocent...with maybe 1-2 people that are truly guilty on your list. If you're Mafia, which many seem to think you are, you'd put some people on your own suspects list to keep it looking honest. Ice is still on my watched list...he's not piquing my radar like he did the one game we WAS mafia, but that in itself doesn't say he's innocent.

You're being watched as well...and if you're guilty, and naming off two powerful players (Ice, HN) which have little reason to be guilty, other then the whole targeting you in Ice's case...now you target me when I discredit you. I may change my vote in the end...I've got to re-do my vote tallies and see where things lie first.
 
LesbianChap said:
Because I think most of that list IS innocent...with maybe 1-2 people that are truly guilty on your list. If you're Mafia, which many seem to think you are, you'd put some people on your own suspects list to keep it looking honest. Ice is still on my watched list...he's not piquing my radar like he did the one game we WAS mafia, but that in itself doesn't say he's innocent.

You're being watched as well...and if you're guilty, and naming off two powerful players (Ice, HN) which have little reason to be guilty, other then the whole targeting you in Ice's case...now you target me when I discredit you. I may change my vote in the end...I've got to re-do my vote tallies and see where things lie first.
Click to expand...

Who are these 'many' that think I'm mafia? I've heard from Ice, so far, and nobody else...
 
current vote tally up to post 176:

HN( 0 ) EMO(93)
CHAS ( 0 ) JPAP(6)
MAD ( 0 ) Ice(10)
LCHAP ( 2 ) BKW(18), Mad(154)
BKW ( 0 ) HN(31)
ANDI ( 2 ) chas(38), Ice(148), Cory(149)
Cory ( 1 ) HN(46)
RB ( 1 ) Ogre(78), LC(86)
EMO ( 1 ) JPAP(126)
JPAP ( 1 ) EMO(127)
Ice ( 3 ) RB(152), Ogre(157), Chas(171)

I wonder if Beth's gonna fix her vote.
 
Cory Lover said:
Oh go suck an egg :silly:
Click to expand...
hahah
but you are still on my list

LesbianChap said:
current vote tally up to post 176:

HN( 0 ) EMO(93)
CHAS ( 0 ) JPAP(6)
MAD ( 0 ) Ice(10)
LCHAP ( 2 ) BKW(18), Mad(154)
BKW ( 0 ) HN(31)
ANDI ( 2 ) chas(38), Ice(148), Cory(149)
Cory ( 1 ) HN(46)
RB ( 1 ) Ogre(78), LC(86)
EMO ( 1 ) JPAP(126)
JPAP ( 1 ) EMO(127)
Ice ( 3 ) RB(152), Ogre(157), Chas(171)

I wonder if Beth's gonna fix her vote.
Click to expand...
i think i missc ount the people who voted for me, and i know i should let that slide, but it's fair.
 
Well, I think Ice is innocent and getting ran on, and unless I do something, he'll be gone tonight.

I vote to lynch Emo. No one's going to go on RB, and he's since added a bit more content. Emo worries me. His only post with any content and he votes for HN claiming HN revealed to him that he was Mafia...and I see three scenarios where that's possible:

A) HN broke the rules and PM'd Emo...HN would be UD'd in this case.
B) Both HN and Emo are Mafia, and Emo's trying to sacrifice HN.
C) Emo's Mafia, and trying to force a Lynch on an Innocent.
D) Emo's innocent, saw something HN said but didn't tell the rest of us.

I don't see A being the case, and so I'm going to rule it out. If D is the case, then Emo should have pointed out what HN said...as he still hasn't, that leaves me B or C...Both leave Emo being Mafia...but only one makes HN Mafia. I just can't take that risk, we need to take out a Mafia tonight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom