Mafia who done it! The Play

[Hooked Newbie]

With regard to possibly looking scummy by not answering the question, 'so what?' You would possibly be protecting the doctor. If you were just an innocent, you'd have to realize that the doctor is more important to the town than yourself, right?

The fact that you're starting to wig out really makes me wonder...

LOL. I'm not wigging, I actually have the chance to be in the thread real time. You're right, jpap was more valuable than me. Excuse me for being a bit pissed at losing him (and him doing that).

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Hooked, bkw and Beth....maybe.....

Thanks for the in depth analysis Colonel.

 

[IceH2O]

If you were paying attention to the thread at the time, you'd have seen that someone pointed out the fact that Andi hadn't voted. I did suspect her, look at my posts, but why waste a vote on an inevitible UD? When was the last game that someone didn't on night 1. Like I've said (at least twice), I thought Emo slipped. Yea, I chose the "easy route", but I did because of his post. At least I was paying attention. I'm still not sure I buy your reasons for staying on the sidelines Mad. Even if it wasn't a vote, you never spoke out.

Yeah I pointed it out

I just noticed Andi hasn't voted.

But that was post 236, you voted in post 220 for RB then post 224 for Emo.

If you can find a post beforehand that shows someone mentioning Andi hadn't voted I'll believe you. If not then I think you're busted.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I'm still not sure I buy your reasons for staying on the sidelines Mad. Even if it wasn't a vote, you never spoke out.

What would you like for me to have said? 'Uhhh, it's possible that Ice is scum AND it's possible that Emo is scum, but I like LChap for scum the most?'

The only reason I've got Ice leaning innocent now is because we now know Andi's status as scum. Ice did seem to park on her early enough to seem pretty legit. Had the late move onto Emo not come, though, I would have been more convinced.

 

[OgreMkV]

Ogre, speaking of those low posters slipping by...

Again, I'm not sure I believe you. Of course, the only other to really push Ice is rbishop and that's almost as worrying.

Please show me the pissing match between Ice and I.

You're right and I apologize. There hasn't been any actual comments directed between you two at each other. It seems to be bkw and Mad both commenting about you and Ice... which lends some credence to your comments below.

I happen to (god help me) think Ice is on our side this game. I don't mind questions or even accusations, but there are gaps in your reasoning. What if Ice votes for me and I'm innocent or mafia?

The questioning was why you didn't vote for Ice, so that's what I analyzed.

I happen to believe that someone's (Mad / bkw) are trying to goad me and Ice into a fight. It's happened in the past and hurt the town. If the folks think I'm guilty, they can lynch me. Otherwise I'm gonna keep waving the BS flag until I'm hit.

bkw and mad... Things that make you go hmmm....

 

[IceH2O]

Now Ice is protecting Hooked. I agree with the logic here... though it makes it seem like both Hooked and Ice are mafia.


So hooked doesn't vote for Ice... even though if both are mafia, it make Hooked look bad. So, I don't think both are mafia. Of the two, I think it makes more sense for Ice to be mafia. Unless they're both innocent and it another duel innocent pissing match.

For the present (and to shake the trees a bit) I vote to lynch charlie.

Let's see what happens.

Ok First I'm not protecting HN, I was just giving my opinion on why I thought HN was innocent.

2nd. Where do you see a pissing match between me and HN?

Its posts like these that make you guys look mafia. Its like you pull something out of the air and hope that others aren't really paying attention and just go by your words.

You know how they say this thread is worthless without pics?
Well this post is worthless without quotes. Show the town where HN and I have argued.

 

[IceH2O]

Ok I see where you admit to a mixup.

 

[Cory Lover]

Hmmm...I don't like this...no one is trying to protect beth or swing the vote to someone else...which leads me to believe she may be innocent...I retract my vote from beth and I vote to lynch Charlie. Because of his 'non caring attitude', and his 'off' behavior compared to other games.

Matt

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Yeah I pointed it out



But that was post 236, you voted in post 220 for RB then post 224 for Emo.

If you can find a post beforehand that shows someone mentioning Andi hadn't voted I'll believe you. If not then I think you're busted.

Ok I'm not sure that Andi is the Col and I'm going to hate myself if she is. But Emo just admitted to being mafia.

I retract my vote on Andi and vote to lynch Emo.

You changed late as well...

current vote tally up to post 176:

HN( 0 ) EMO(93)
CHAS ( 0 ) JPAP(6)
MAD ( 0 ) Ice(10)
LCHAP ( 2 ) BKW(18), Mad(154)
BKW ( 0 ) HN(31)
ANDI ( 2 ) chas(38), Ice(148), Cory(149)
Cory ( 1 ) HN(46)
RB ( 1 ) Ogre(78), LC(86)
EMO ( 1 ) JPAP(126)
JPAP ( 1 ) EMO(127)
Ice ( 3 ) RB(152), Ogre(157), Chas(171)

I wonder if Beth's gonna fix her vote.

Note that Andi doesn't have a vote placed. I may have mis-spoke, but if you want my spreadsheet I'll share it.

 

[IceH2O]

You changed late as well...



Note that Andi doesn't have a vote placed. I may have mis-spoke, but if you want my spreadsheet I'll share it.

Yeah I did change late, I myself didn't notice that Andi hadn't voted until after I switched to Emo. If Emo hadn't said what he did my vote would have stayed put and I would have been lynched with my vote sitting on a UD.