Mafia who done it! The Play

BTW lchap, Charlie is a he :p:


Ok...heres me list:

RB-rbishop, for some reason your posts are not just making that much sense to me. You seem 'off' this game and it worries me. Leaning mafia.

Ice-I was leaning innocent with you...now I'm slightly leaning mafia. I don't feel all your posts are really helping the town, just trying to spread confusion.

Charlie-I remember playing with you before. You were vocal. You aren't now. Just voting and running. Makes me suspicious of you and leaning mafia.

Mad-I feel you are trying to help the town. Your posts seem innocent'ish, therefore leaning innocent.

HN-While I was thinking more about it...when you went after be about the shading thing. I think you were either trying to look good and innocent, or trying to make me slip. Leaning mafia.

bkw-Don't know about you.

beth-You are playing like beth normally does play. Somethings seem a little bit off (btw, you never answered me question...lol) like voting for ogre....I don't know about you.

LC-I think that PM jm sent you was interesting...titled "READ IT!!". I don't know about you though.

Ogre-I think you are here to help the town, your posts don't seem fishy. Leaning innocent.


I'm very interested to see how the vote plays out. I'm thinking of switching my vote to HN, thats what my gut says to do. But I'm waiting for a little longer to see what happens.

Matt
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Some have their minds made up (or rather their target set) on me and that is fine. I do have a question for Mad though.

You made what I read as a pretty strong case against Beth and stated as fact that she was mafia. I voted based on that case as stated. Now that vote seems scummy to you? The hit and run vote from Charlie was suspect at best, but I have no control of someone else's vote. It seems to me that you are casting suspicions everywhere. Would you do me a favor and list your current suspects since they seem to change so often? Personally, I think my vote's in a good place right now based on your case and some of her posts stating that she knows that Ice is innocent.
Click to expand...

IMO Beth is a poor choice for a vote in a lynch or lose situation. I realize that I built a case on her, and that she still could be mafia, but I'm hestitant to lynch her today. History has shown that Beth has frequently looked scummy, even when playing an innocent. While her timeline was off, and it does appear that she could indeed be busted, it's not impossible for Beth to have made that goof as an innocent.


LesbianChap said:
Mad seems fixated on the fact that I didn't initially vote for Andi, and went after Emo instead...

Yes, I meant that first vote for Emo (where I forgot to retract the vote for RB) to count...I didn't know what role Andi or Emo was. I could have gone either, but I figured forcing a vote between two people I suspected were Mafia (Emo and Andi) even though o
Click to expand...

LChap, I'm fixated because it's a scum move on your part. You say that you're off to save Ice, and then hop on Emo. All the while Ice is sitting on Andi, and according to your vote count at the time, Andi would have been the more sensible vote (for you to save Ice).

IceH2O said:
Mad why the sudden switch to HN when LC was your top suspect and HN never even made your list?

HN jumped from not making your list all the way to the top bypassing Charlie Beth LC and a watchful eye on Ogre and Bkw.
Click to expand...

Mainly nobody seems all that interested in listening about LChap. As far as Hooked, when his name came up, alot of people got really defensive and seemed to spring into action. I just mentioned a questionable post of his, and I've got you jumping down my throat. Hooked Newbie starts getting bent out of shape, and then LChap votes for BKW for going after HN. It looks a little like rallying to me. HN may be the Colonel.

I had considered throwing a safe vote on Chas this morning, as I don't anticipate having a lot of time on the thread today. Instead I decided to test the waters and see what would happen with a HN vote. Boy! You sprang into action again. You moved your vote onto Chas, shuffled your list around and started your 'smear Mad' campaign full force again. Coincidence? I'm not so sure...

At any rate, should the town fail to agree, I likely would vote for Chas. The town needs to realize, though, that in a lynch or lose situation the mafia can actually jump up and down and vote on their own members. If they can split the vote across 2-3 mafia members they can still move late onto an innocent for the win. The town pretty much needs a unanimous vote to even stand a chance...
 
Just noticed I forgot to retract again, suprised no one called me on it...so fixing it...
I retract my vote for Bkw and vote to lynch Charlie

Day 2 as of Post 413

Cory
RB 0
Ice 1 RB(310)
Charlie 4 Ogre(325) Cory(338) Ice(369) LC(413)
Mad 0
HN 2 Bkw(307)Mad(368)
Bkw 0 Ice(270) LC(364)
Beth 2 Charlie(301)HN(304)Cory(305)
LC 0
Ogre 1 Beth(371)
 
Madcrawdad said:
IMO Beth is a poor choice for a vote in a lynch or lose situation. I realize that I built a case on her, and that she still could be mafia, but I'm hestitant to lynch her today. History has shown that Beth has frequently looked scummy, even when playing an innocent. While her timeline was off, and it does appear that she could indeed be busted, it's not impossible for Beth to have made that goof as an innocent.




LChap, I'm fixated because it's a scum move on your part. You say that you're off to save Ice, and then hop on Emo. All the while Ice is sitting on Andi, and according to your vote count at the time, Andi would have been the more sensible vote (for you to save Ice).



Mainly nobody seems all that interested in listening about LChap. As far as Hooked, when his name came up, alot of people got really defensive and seemed to spring into action. I just mentioned a questionable post of his, and I've got you jumping down my throat. Hooked Newbie starts getting bent out of shape, and then LChap votes for BKW for going after HN. It looks a little like rallying to me. HN may be the Colonel.

I had considered throwing a safe vote on Chas this morning, as I don't anticipate having a lot of time on the thread today. Instead I decided to test the waters and see what would happen with a HN vote. Boy! You sprang into action again. You moved your vote onto Chas, shuffled your list around and started your 'smear Mad' campaign full force again. Coincidence? I'm not so sure...

At any rate, should the town fail to agree, I likely would vote for Chas. The town needs to realize, though, that in a lynch or lose situation the mafia can actually jump up and down and vote on their own members. If they can split the vote across 2-3 mafia members they can still move late onto an innocent for the win. The town pretty much needs a unanimous vote to even stand a chance...
Click to expand...


I just don't see that happening with the current list of players and this format...shame. It may have been a one sided game set up to get folks back into the play, but it doesn't have any basis for driving folks to play, with equal footing.

I know I am innocent and I feel Ice is more Mafia from what he has posted and dodged about (IMO), so my vote will stay there for now.

And Ice, there are only a few hundred posts...go find them yourself. As should anyone else interested in the game.
 
im staying with my vote.


Im watching to see if the CS votes stay, or who'll move to save em(either on or off him)
 
Well there's two players saying within minutes of eachother that they'd not be changing their vote...Is this perhaps a plot to keep us feeling secure before a last-minute vote-swap? I don't like how that looks...either way.
 
rbishop said:
I know I am innocent and I feel Ice is more Mafia from what he has posted and dodged about (IMO), so my vote will stay there for now.

And Ice, there are only a few hundred posts...go find them yourself. As should anyone else interested in the game.
Click to expand...

Again RB shows that he refuses to show the town what he thinks he sees. That is anti town. How anyone can think its not is unreal.

I think that RB, and Mad to a point, are trying to draw votes away from Charlie. I for one am staying put. I don't care if RB admits to being mafia. I am chasing what I think is the Col. If the game is going to end tonight its because we found the Col not because the mafia tricked us into voting for an innocent.

Mad is really pushing HN and I guess me since I'm supposedly his partner in crime. They are trying to take the focus off the non existent posting Charlie. The only reason to hide is if you are hiding something. Since Charlie can't be hiding an innocent PR then he must be the Col.
 
LesbianChap said:
Just noticed I forgot to retract again, suprised no one called me on it...so fixing it...
I retract my vote for Bkw and vote to lynch Charlie
Click to expand...

Are you really surprised? Why would the mafia want to point out that your vote on Charlie wouldn't count since you never retracted off Bkw? They were hoping you never caught it so that would be 1 less person on the Col.
 
Hmm...lets make it interesting....I vote to lynch HN. With this it ends up in a tie between HN and Charlie...it will be interesting to see who trys to break the tie.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom