Mafia who done it! The Play

[IceH2O]

Lol thanks for making me look smart. I so called mafia setting ice up later.

Why are you following ice, maybe you should think for yourself. This tells me either ice is feeding your votes or your tryin to set him up....either way your mafia.

Like i said i like a vote on either LC or HN. I agree with either one of them

Good point Bkw.

I actually should have known something when HN said he thought I was innocent.


LC -I don't recall ever asking you to follow anything. You followed on your own.Those votes were your choice. I haven't even pushed a case on anyone. Emo pretty much admitted to being mafia and Charlie didn't show up to defend or help us to decide he wasn't.

I think Bkw is on to something. I'm more then willing to replace Beth with LC, it makes more sense. But I just don't get why you think RB is innocent. What are you seeing that I'm not?

 

[Madcrawdad]

Well I don't think anyone can really take the blame for Charlies lynch as he didn't quite help us not lynch him. A total of 5 posts and no input at all. May as well just UD and gave us a chance at finding the real mafia instead of wasting 48 hours IMO.


Actually Mad jumping to Charlie from HN has given me a feeling that he is indeed mafia. At the time it was 4-3. One vote switch would have tied it up. Mad made sure it wouldn't be. So if anyone looks scummy to me its Mad not Ogre.

Of course it does, Ice. To think otherwise would require the use of logic on your part...something that's been lacking all game long. You're really having trouble grasping the fact that 6 townie votes spread across two candidates allows the mafia to move their 4 votes late. It's really not that complicated...Maybe someone else can try explaining it to you, as for some reason you're just not getting it when I say it.
My new list

RB
Mad
HN
Beth?

I think RBs LMAO was in reference to my post in which I said I felt like I just got played hard.

.

 

[IceH2O]

Well ok Mad, you were right about LC wanting to jump to Emo and not Andi to start and HN wanting to jump to RB.

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt. So who are your top 4 and who do you think might be the Col?

 

[IceH2O]

I'm getting ready to watch 28 Days Later, I'll be back in about 2 hours or so.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Good point Bkw.

I actually should have known something when HN said he thought I was innocent.


LC -I don't recall ever asking you to follow anything. You followed on your own.Those votes were your choice. I haven't even pushed a case on anyone. Emo pretty much admitted to being mafia and Charlie didn't show up to defend or help us to decide he wasn't.

I think Bkw is on to something. I'm more then willing to replace Beth with LC, it makes more sense. But I just don't get why you think RB is innocent. What are you seeing that I'm not?

Well I don't think anyone can really take the blame for Charlies lynch as he didn't quite help us not lynch him. A total of 5 posts and no input at all. May as well just UD and gave us a chance at finding the real mafia instead of wasting 48 hours IMO.


Actually Mad jumping to Charlie from HN has given me a feeling that he is indeed mafia. At the time it was 4-3. One vote switch would have tied it up. Mad made sure it wouldn't be. So if anyone looks scummy to me its Mad not Ogre.

My new list

RB
Mad
HN
Beth?

I think RBs LMAO was in reference to my post in which I said I felt like I just got played hard.

I was seeing you as innocent, but you have led the charge on two innocents now. Right now... you, Rb, and bkw seem to be the ones playing people. I need to clear my head and go back to square one. I'm not sure about anyone at this point that hasn't been killed.

I do find it interesting that you name Rb as your top suspect, but yet feel the need to explain his post for him.

 

[bkw1982]

I was seeing you as innocent, but you have led the charge on two innocents now. Right now... you, Rb, and bkw seem to be the ones playing people. I need to clear my head and go back to square one. I'm not sure about anyone at this point that hasn't been killed.

I do find it interesting that you name Rb as your top suspect, but yet feel the need to explain his post for him.

I feel like Lupin the way i called that, not the MOD, the Detective lupin.

umm i predict the superbowl score the superbowl to be 31-27 Pats, as a side note Kotd will cry like a lil girl cause giants lost.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Well ok Mad, you were right about LC wanting to jump to Emo and not Andi to start and HN wanting to jump to RB.

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt. So who are your top 4 and who do you think might be the Col?

LChap
HN
Ice
Beth/Ogre*

I suspect that HN may be Colonel, but that LChap is probably a safer bet for scum, period... LChap seems to have been protective of both you and HN which is a little unusual. The fact that you haven't addressed that he's now possibly selling you down the river is a little unusual, too.

* I really need to think about RB's 'LMAO!' post some more. While I can see it being viewed as gloating, I can also see him laughing (based on yours/his history this game) at the fact that you were acting oblivious to the fact that the mafia probably wouldn't let a coin flip occur on the vote.

On a side note, I'm likely off for the night....

 

[Madcrawdad]

Well ok Mad, you were right about LC wanting to jump to Emo and not Andi to start and HN wanting to jump to RB.

I just addressed this post, but forgot to ask about the first part.... I don't recall me saying anything about HN wanting to jump to RB. Can you refresh my memory?

 

[IceH2O]

I was seeing you as innocent, but you have led the charge on two innocents now. Right now... you, Rb, and bkw seem to be the ones playing people. I need to clear my head and go back to square one. I'm not sure about anyone at this point that hasn't been killed.

I do find it interesting that you name Rb as your top suspect, but yet feel the need to explain his post for him.

How did I lead the charge on Emo? He made it sound like he was mafia and I voted for him.

How did I lead the charge on Charlie? Charlies death was of his own doing.I would have preferred he had just PMed JM and told her to UD him then make us waste all this time for nothing.

If you read the explanation of RBs post then you'd see I was pointing a finger at him, not protecting him. I was pointing out that he was laughing at the mafia playing me and that he thought it was game over.

 

[IceH2O]

I just addressed this post, but forgot to ask about the first part.... I don't recall me saying anything about HN wanting to jump to RB. Can you refresh my memory?

My bad, you didn't say RB. It was post 321 where you mentioned that it took Emo for HN to save me that he didn't jump on when it was Andi. I knew he had voted RB 1st then switched to Emo and got it mixed up thinking you had said RB.