Thanks for all the replies, good or bad. Now my wife likes to rub it in my face that more people agree with her. It still wasn't getting along with one of our other BP's so its in the 29 with my convict pair. Its alot easier to treat 29 gallons of water than 75. I use stress coat at waterchanges and I have been dosing some salt and melafix so the damage should start healing soon, part of its tail had begun to regrow before she brought it home so the outlook is good. part of the large black blotch faded on top of its head. After it is healed I will try to introduce it back to the main tank and see how that works.