More light depends on how much you want to do to keep on top of nutrient dosing. Algae occurs when some nutrient is depleted, what kind of algae depends on the nutrient. But all the same it does seem like you could go with a bit more light and have more options plant wise. Some of the plants you tried may not have gotten enough light and had the nutrient deficiency problem on top of that.
When I had two 18" t8 plant bulbs over a 20 tall I could grow a quite limited number of plants. I'm happier with the options I have with two 24" t5 high output bulbs over a 20 long. The height of the tank is another matter though. I like the light, but the short tank makes trimming needed more often. It is a learning curve though, because with more light deficiencies happen faster and so do the problems. It is rewarding though to see the plants respond to proper dosing.
When I had two 18" t8 plant bulbs over a 20 tall I could grow a quite limited number of plants. I'm happier with the options I have with two 24" t5 high output bulbs over a 20 long. The height of the tank is another matter though. I like the light, but the short tank makes trimming needed more often. It is a learning curve though, because with more light deficiencies happen faster and so do the problems. It is rewarding though to see the plants respond to proper dosing.