Sand in marine fish tanks

FloridaBoy

AC Members
Jan 10, 2005
375
0
0
Sand, sand sand.
Home Depot sand, silica sand, beach sand, pink sand, live sand, dead sand, shallow sand, deep sand and even deeper sand.
I see a lot of references to sand these days... entire sections of some sites are dedicated to it. IMHO, the jury is still out on using sand for marine fish set ups. I have spent a lot of time looking at this on many sites and there is clearly a lot of confusion, differing opinions and questions regarding the sand issue. Some are claiming their deep sand beds are becoming magic nitrate reducing machines, others are watching the DSB suddenly turn into a hydogen sulphide bomb or algae/diatom-fest.
Certainly the remote planted DSB refugium holds promise, but some are adding deep layers of sand, even silica sand, into the bottom of their fish tanks, and adding rock on top of that, often creating dangerous situations in my experience. Some very reliable sources claim the sand should be less than 1/2 inch or deeper than 5 inches. Some claim the sand should be sifted and maintained, others insist the sand should be layered and never disturbed. Some prescribe a plenum under the sand, others have seen their sand turn into solid concrete when their water chemistry strayed. Some call deep sand "mud" and suggest it will cure HLLE in your fish, others claim sand should not be used for marine fish tanks at all, esp. those with moderate to robust fish populations. It's no wonder we have such a high failure rate in this hobby. As usual, I am seeing a lot of confusion and mixed advice based on A:fish only/B:LR/C:true reef system esperience. My advice is; be careful with sand in fish tanks... be careful using mixed advice which often produces failure. 1/2 advice from source A and 1/2 advice from source B will produce a "hybrid" system which has no proven track record or limited long term results.
Research the systems you are seeking to mimic; when you decide on the best system, sand, plan, etc. then stick with it, but make sure the template has a long term success record and make sure you are following the pattern closely and not leaving out an important part or straying from the intended goals.
(for example trying to maintain a moderate to heavy bio load using a filter designed for sparse populations). As more and more hobbyists succeed and fail with sand perhaps we will all learn... but again, use caution; I remember not long ago when trickle filters were touted as the silver bullet to all our problems.
 
Its the same thing as using a skimmer or not? Someone else would swear by a Skimmer, while i can prove that you can run a successful system without a Skimmer, but that doesnt mean i am right or the other person is right, since its almost impossible to match the ecosystem of the ocean 100%


However in terms of a DSB, the only way they can potentially become any of those problems are lack of proper maintenance. Often people add something and think "it will take care of itsself and i have to do nothing", which is where alot of failure comes from. In a closed system there is no natural exchange of contaminates and clean water 24/7.

However i use Silica playsand (note, only free silca is used by Diatoms, the sand itsself doesnt break down which would cause Silica to leak into the water) and LR in my set up without a skimmer and it does fine, just have to keep the bioload stable and make sure the sand bed sometimes gets sifted enough, and its last for 2 years so far. In terms of thier sand becomming solid, thats usually from Aragonite based sand and an excess of calcium, since Aragonite is Calcium based it can bind with Calcium in the water if there is too much making a solid block, essentially cementing the sand together.
 
My sandbed is made up of about 1" of LFS aragonite, just a little crushed coral that came along with my LR and about 100 small emty hermit crab shells from when I had my Octopus Hitchikers.

Last week I added a Blue Streek Goby that turns the entire sandbed over about twice per day. I used to have some slight algae problems that bothered me, the Goby sure cured it. He's the hardest worker I've ever hand and my substrate look incredible!! He also kind of makes a mess around my lower corals but that's another story :( Every Goby I've seen sits on the bottom and sifts sand. Ours swims all over the tank sprinkling sand everywhere :confused: I'm looking forward to adding a sump/refuge in a few weeks so I can maintain a normal sandbed with pods, etc. In the meantime, he's not afraid to eat chopped clams, flake food and whatever else is offered. I also ad Cyclopeeze so he gets something from his daily sand sifting. "Earthmover" as we call him also burrows under my LR so my sand bed is down to the glass in some areas and about 4" deep in other areas :rolleyes:

His hardwork and personality is outweighing his ability to be a pain in the BUTT.............

bluestreakgoby1lr.jpg
 
AquariaCentral.com