THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[Hooked Newbie]

Folks, my thoughts haven't changed yet. I still think DD is suspicious as well as Liz, but I fear DD more so unless JL posts very soon my vote will go back to her.

Ice- I really hope you read the rules. No mafia can communicate yet so even the mention of a mafia "strategy" at this point looks to be mis-information (especially in a game with a few newbs) and very suspicious IMO. Plus, I'm not used to your hit and run posting. You are usually much more active. I know, I know... you're tired of the same players doing all the posting blah, blah, blah... Z used that same attempt last game and you and I knew it and managed a last minute lynch on him, so don't even bother going there bud.

 

[IceH2O]

Rb, what heat was on me? No votes, just DD's accusations against me which I am not really considering at this point because I think she is mafia.



Plant, this was exactly my point earlier las night. DD didn't get the sarcasm, then got it, then she came back and still didn't think it was sarcastic...



Yes, Ice, I missed the comma. Believe me if you want to but I don't really care if you do not at this point. But how could all 3 of us be mafia and be working together? There are 3 original but no spouses yet. Only spouses can communicate.

Skimming Jpap? You quoted Atnixon then asked RB the question.

 

[IceH2O]

Folks, my thoughts haven't changed yet. I still think DD is suspicious as well as Liz, but I fear DD more so unless JL posts very soon my vote will go back to her.

Ice- I really hope you read the rules. No mafia can communicate yet so even the mention of a mafia "strategy" at this point looks to be mis-information (especially in a game with a few newbs) and very suspicious IMO. Plus, I'm not used to your hit and run posting. You are usually much more active. I know, I know... you're tired of the same players doing all the posting blah, blah, blah... Z used that same attempt last game and you and I knew it and managed a last minute lynch on him, so don't even bother going there bud.

They can't communicate but they can try to play together. If I was mafia and thought you were mafia I'd try to follow along with you. I might not know per PM but I could try to follow as a feeling. For all we know 2 of them are spouses.

Same way we look for mafia they are. They don't want to lynch mafia. So they see one working on an innocent they join in.

I'm not saying all 3 are definite mafia but they way they are playing together looks suspicious.

 

[judgemax]

nightfall in two hours!

 

[IceH2O]

Ice your defending DD a awful lot here, if she is innocent I'm thinking maybe you are not and she was your intended sig other...didn't you make a point to mention you don't think the "experienced" would not team up...was this a reverse thing for you?

The spouses had to be chosen the 1st night, not the 1st nightfall.

I'm not defending DD because we're partners. That would just be stupid.

I'm defending DD because 3 people have come at her hard and for reasons that are either explainable or happens to us all.

Just because DD is a vet doesn't mean she'll play her best game everytime. You 3 worry me more.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

They can't communicate but they can try to play together. If I was mafia and thought you were mafia I'd try to follow along with you. I might not know per PM but I could try to follow as a feeling. For all we know 2 of them are spouses.

Same way we look for mafia they are. They don't want to lynch mafia. So they see one working on an innocent they join in.

I'm not saying all 3 are definite mafia but they way they are playing together looks suspicious.

Spouses have not been chosen yet.

DD leads with Liz close behind and look at Ice flying up the outside into second place!

 

[Hooked Newbie]

The spouses had to be chosen the 1st night, not the 1st nightfall.

I'm not defending DD because we're partners. That would just be stupid.

I'm defending DD because 3 people have come at her hard and for reasons that are either explainable or happens to us all.

Just because DD is a vet doesn't mean she'll play her best game everytime. You 3 worry me more.

Judge- Rule clarification needed. Have they been chosen or are they chosen tonight?

 

[IceH2O]

Spouses have not been chosen yet.

DD leads with Liz close behind and look at Ice flying up the outside into second place!

How do you know?

Judge- Rule clarification needed. Have they been chosen or are they chosen tonight?

The rule says

There will originally be three mafia, and they will be able to "choose" who their partner will be. By the first night, they must PM me with up to three choices, and they will be given a spouse.

I took that as the 1st actual night not 48 hours later. I'd like clarification also.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

How do you know?

I don't, I read it different than you. I took it that they'd have to PM JM by the first "night", but wouldn't find out until "night" is over.


The rule says

There will originally be three mafia, and they will be able to "choose" who their partner will be. By the first night, they must PM me with up to three choices, and they will be given a spouse.

I took that as the 1st actual night not 48 hours later. I'd like clarification also.

So, did you already send in your PM and find out who your partner is?

 

[IceH2O]

Folks, my thoughts haven't changed yet. I still think DD is suspicious as well as Liz, but I fear DD more so unless JL posts very soon my vote will go back to her.

Ice- I really hope you read the rules. No mafia can communicate yet so even the mention of a mafia "strategy" at this point looks to be mis-information (especially in a game with a few newbs) and very suspicious IMO. Plus, I'm not used to your hit and run posting. You are usually much more active. I know, I know... you're tired of the same players doing all the posting blah, blah, blah... Z used that same attempt last game and you and I knew it and managed a last minute lynch on him, so don't even bother going there bud.

Did you skim by my post explaining why I'm playing this way?

Just in case here its is in a nutshell.

More newbs then usual, I want to watch and see if I can pick them out by posts. I don't want to get them all flustered and afraid to post as we learn nothing that way.

I'll get more active, thats a fact but I want to make sure I'm not part of lynching any innocents,especially newbs, the 1st night.