THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

IceH2O said:
It was a feeling and it was right on. DD does not screw up that easily. I don't expect any vet to screw up like that. Ogre didn't really screw up as much as he took a chance and it backfired.
Click to expand...

Ice, I was going to bring this up yesterday but forgot. Remember when DD said that she was 100% sure of LG being innocent in the vampire game (I think it was that one)? That was a screw up and people picked at her about it. She was my minion. So don't say that you knew she was innocent because she wouldn't screw up like that if she was mafia.

Ok, I am defending a vote from last night AGAIN! I need some ductape...:lipssealedsmilie:

Anyways, not sure if I can believe what you say 100% but I am not chalking you up as mafia quite yet...
 
atnixon said:
JPappy....Why highlight my name in post 575 but not make a comment? is this a secret code to your spouse or something?
Click to expand...

Ummm did you read my comments or just see you name and freak out? Jo was talking about newbs and I asked why he mentioned all 3 of you as suspicious. You are a newb. Hence the highlight.
 
jpappy789 said:
Ummm did you read my comments or just see you name and freak out? Jo was talking about newbs and I asked why he mentioned all 3 of you as suspicious. You are a newb. Hence the highlight.
Click to expand...

i did not freak nor have a need too, just a legit question to ask...
 
jpappy789 said:
Ice, I was going to bring this up yesterday but forgot. Remember when DD said that she was 100% sure of LG being innocent in the vampire game (I think it was that one)? That was a screw up and people picked at her about it. She was my minion. So don't say that you knew she was innocent because she wouldn't screw up like that if she was mafia.

Ok, I am defending a vote from last night AGAIN! I need some ductape...:lipssealedsmilie:

Anyways, not sure if I can believe what you say 100% but I am not chalking you up as mafia quite yet...
Click to expand...

Well it wasn't Vampire because RB and Mad were the vamps to start off and turned Ogre and LG I modded the game. I had to look back at notes.

But I do remember her saying that, which game I'm not sure. But it wasn't Day 1 was it? This is different in the sense that DD was attacking someone and messed up. She wasn't making a case, she merely messed up on certain aspects as you have also done this game.

Only difference being she didn't twist anything to suit her needs.
 
Ice-

My concerns are more with your lack of participation than last night's vote. You have actually been the one referring back to it to "show" that you thought DD was innocent and protected her for that reason. I agree with you about the format differences, but look at it this way for one second. You are one of the best players, so if you weren't mafia to begin with, it would stand to reason that you'd be chosen as a partner by one. That is where the possibility of DD being mafia (I suspected it and was wrong) and you being innocent (but expecting to be chosen yourself) came from. Hopefully you're innocent and weren't chosen. Even better if our bickering caused them to PM to "unchoose" you. If you are innocent, I'd expect to see more typical Ice than any of us have seen so far.
 
IceH2O said:
Well it wasn't Vampire because RB and Mad were the vamps to start off and turned Ogre and LG I modded the game. I had to look back at notes.

But I do remember her saying that, which game I'm not sure. But it wasn't Day 1 was it? This is different in the sense that DD was attacking someone and messed up. She wasn't making a case, she merely messed up on certain aspects as you have also done this game.

Only difference being she didn't twist anything to suit her needs.
Click to expand...

That should read

This is different in the sense that DD wasn't attacking someone and messed up. She wasn't making a case, she merely messed up on certain aspects as you have also done this game.
 
atnixon said:
JPappy....Why highlight my name in post 575 but not make a comment? is this a secret code to your spouse or something?
Click to expand...

I took it he was pointing out that Jo was naming all the newb's as suspicious, don't think it was intended against you, JMO.
 
IceH2O said:
That should read

This is different in the sense that DD wasn't attacking someone and messed up. She wasn't making a case, she merely messed up on certain aspects as you have also done this game.
Click to expand...

Ok, makes sense. Just that you keep using that excuse for you thinking DD to be innocent. Innocents make mistakes (as we have just seen) but so do mafia, even vets who are scum. I just don't like how you were so sure that DD was innocent but JMO.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom