case for liz.
I'm going to put everything together in one post here to try to show everyone my case for liz.
Hang on, this is a long one.
sorry guysss had a busy day and school and everythinggg.
Will be less busy most of the time
I don't have time to read the whole thread tonight, but I will before I cast a vote.
???
Starts off the game making excuses (what else is new?)
Lady G is very suspicious, mafia in cognito in drag?
I have a feeling one of these days they are going to make us all mafia or all townies.
ahaha
Throws in a useless post. (ok, we all do it)
Why are we all posting as townies out to get the mafia. Why don't we put a spin on things and post as the mafia out to terrorize the townies?
Game doesnt work like that liz... (ok, shes a newb)
yuh cuz if I was mafia I'd want to make it obvious.
Perhaps I'll vote to lynch atnixon, it's very suspicious that he wants to lynch an innocent.
ps "at" is a preposition and you shouldn't end a sentence with a preposition. lol. I had that crap drilled into my head wayyy too much.
Heyyy what do you know an oh my god you suck for voting me idea!
this seems kind of silly to me because the whole analyzation could go in endless circles you know? Seems it kind of happens by chance, you cant really reason it. I'm not sure how to begin...
Ok, well we have to analyze otherwise we would never get anywhere.
clown lover and plantling are both suspicious to me, since they didn't jump at the "lynch liz for she is obviously mafia" bandwagon, which I guess was legitimate because a lot of people did it, and they didn't have very strong reasons not to/they voted to lynch someone with a weaker case than I.
Let me look at that, see who they voted to lynch and if they had a stronger mafia case than I do...
Usually people arent suspected for not jumping on an early train...but good try to come up with some suspects... i like the effort (i guess?)
well it might be odd or different but doesn't it make sense?
I hadn't done anything to indicate that I am innocent,
I have only hinted that I am mafia.
So I think I'm the most suspicious one here. And the people who are voting for other people simply for not posting or for lesser reasons... i don't know. It's kind of suspicious?
I don't know who is more suspicious, clown-lover who suspected I am mafia and then chose to lynch someone less suspicious (Is dd less suspicious? I havent read the whole thread)... or plantling, who chose to lynch someone other than me simply because they haven't posted
I don't think anything I said has particularly indicated that I am mafia, but it must indicate it to other people since I've had so many votes against me (assumably from townies suspecting I am mafia, since I haven't given the mafia any good reasons to believe I am a townie). It's hard to tell though. Maybe plantling and clown lover didn't read into it as much? Maybe they didn't think I had a strong case against me? Hard to tell.
she sure got those statements correct (even a blind squirrel finds a nut every now and then)
Well I have ruled some people out as not being mafia.
hmmm... I am not sure if plantling just didn't see my posts as suggesting I am mafia, but I vote to lynch plantling.
I'll probably change my vote as things progress though.
Here she goes on her "they didnt vote for me, they must be mafia" theory...
Ugh I hate this. I think I got one, but I'll have to wait and see until they post again...
Ok..? You think you have one because they didnt vote for you?
nope.
I can't explain it or it won't work lol
This was in the response to someone asking her if she was talking about plant in the post before (directly above) WTH? You cant explain why you think it is annoying?
Well... idk.
I believe the people who voted to lynch me are townies, since I am apparently suspicious. And I don't see why any mafia would vote me, since I hadn't indicated at all that I was a townie. Unless some of the people who voted to lynch me were mafia trying to look innocent, later to retract their votes.
But clown lover voted to lynch DD, instead of me who everyone else found more suspicious. That in itself is suspicious. Then, to me, DD made herself obvious that she is innocent, since she vote to lynch me and she wouldn't have had the motive to do that had she been mafia.
If he saw that and retracted his vote on her, he would not be mafia.
If he did not retract his vote, he possibly didn't see that the same way I did, or else he is mafia.
But now, Lady G, who also voted to lynch me therefor exposing she was innocent, has voted to lynch DD, who also did the same. So I guess I'm takng everything differently than other people.
I don't understand why someone voting to lynch someone else on basically no basis would indicate that they are mafia?
Wouldn't mafia look for someone who was obviously a townie to vote for?
Well I suppose they have to disguise their votes somehow, maybe with no good "innocent" basis so they use a stupid reason to cover?
is that why someone voting someone for a dumb reason indicates they are mafia?
Like being a newb, and not being around enough? Sounds about right to me liz.
Am I supposed to assume/know these things or gradually figure them out as I play?
Because I feel dumb. heh
yes, it should be comming any time now (at least i think?... maybe not)
haha was that an insult to my intelligence?
if so that would be kind of silly.
nope... not at all.
anyhow, I see all of your points about DD being suspicious, but it's hard for me to know because I haven't played with her before.
(I'm not going to read those other games)
of course you wont, that would like help the town right? Like OMG.
Ok, intermission. I know this is a lot (almost everything she has said so far) and know im going to cut it down some. I'm only going to post things i have a good solid reason to post now.
I vote to lynch everybody
Showing that she thinks the game is a joke, or is it a mafia tactic to still try and make people believe she is confused? Either way... i dont want her on my side...
oh no, the mafia is complimenting me. A mafia would only compliment another mafia.
I must be mafia!
RAWRAWRAWR I VOTE TO LYNCH ME
Same as before.. its all a big joke.
Aiii this is too much to read and follow :/
I had a gut feeling on Tuesday, something about Jo struck me as a little suspicious, but I couldn't pinpoint it and I didn't want to try to catch anything on him. So I didn't mention it (I don't think I did?)
Another excuse.
Also, she had a "gut" feeling about me... something struck her as suspicious about me.. she just thought better not to mention it? Right... i believe that 100 %..
No it was DD. On the same basis I was judging other people (incorrectly). She had voted for me who I guess was at the time apparently mafia, and once that was over with, if she retracted her vote she would have been innocent.
I don't remember why I thought he's suspicious. It was a gut feeling. Maybe I'll go back and look now.
must have been a true hard gut feeling.... no dont worry about it you dont have to go back and look that would be wayy to much reading... just keep cruising along liz, no one else seems to care.
Ok Joander was bothering me from pretty much the beginning because he's basically just been throwing accusations all over the place, seems very defensive and... I don't know. Antsy? It indicates to me that he is hiding something. It is just quite suspicious to me. He also is kind of overly-enthusiastic and pushy about a post "screaming mafia" without really much good reason (I think?) and he keeps pushing his innocence so aggressively and... he just seems like he's over exaggerating everything.
He just doesn't seem innocent. It seems to me like he is way too enthusiastic about accusing everyone of being mafia so boldly... left and right. And suspect him and he gets aggressive and forces that he is innocent. I guess it's also the forcefulness, trying to guide the game or something.
Yes liz, unlike you i want people to think im innocent, becaus i am innocent. Yes liz, unlike you i pushed hard to get someone lynched who i thought was mafia.
Yes liz, unlike you i like to throw accusations all over the place and kick down doors, its how the game is played.
It doesn't seem to me like an innocent would have to try so hard to convince others they are innocent from the get-go... I mean if I am correct in my observations of his behavior, that would be a very bad strategy for a mafia... obviously trying so hard to appear innocent. But why would an innocent have that behavior?
Again, it seems to me like he's eager to jump on everyone, which seems antsy and suspicious to me, and very defensive about being innocent.
at this point, with no better candidates in my mind, I vote to lynch Joander
Big surprise here.. she follows suit... aww thats so sweet. How exactly have i been trying to hard to appear innocent since the very beginning of the game? I think i have done the exact opposite by knocking down as many doors as possible, as well as pushing to get someone lynched.
Nice try though...
That was liz's last post to date. Seems to me shes a lot of help to the town right ? WRONG.
Just my thoughts.....
My list as of now is
Liz
Ice
Sploke Now obviously everyone of them is not mafia,
CL but they are my top suspects.
DC
Kuhli.
