Wayne, that looks like pachyclavularia (GSP) but I cant say enough how difficult (and often innacurate) trying to ID a mystery coral from just a picture is. While it most likely is star polyp another possibility for both your colony and the original post by trancefusion would be an encrusting briarium, which is often mistaken for pachyclavularia. There are two major species of briarium in the aquarium hobby, B. asbestinum which will encrust and usually eventually grow single branches rising from the base (its often called corcky sea finger in the hobby), or B. Strechei which also encrusts and looks similar to GSP but can typically be identified by a more brown to grey mat