The sick one died...
He was really bad when I came home that day with the new medicine. I think my changing the water pushed him over the edge. Within 2 hours, he died. I feel so bad. I don't know if he would have survived being let go or not, where his mouth was so damaged by the hook, but I feel like he would have had a better chance...not as many strange things to shock his system.
I am continuing the treatment of the Maracyn Plus for the remaining fish, just to make sure she doesn't end up with the same thing. This is made by Mardel. It says it is for Mouth fungus, Popeye, Dropsy and Ulcers. The active ingredients are Sulfadimidine and trimethoprin. This fish (my daughter named her Jill) seems to be doing great. I really think she has grown since we got her (or him?). She watches us, like she is waiting for us to feed her. She is really pretty too...kind of a pale yellow color almost. I still feel like we should let her go, but the medicine said not to use for fish that could be used for human consumption, so I don't know if it would be legal to let her go. I am pretty sure it probably is illegal to keep her. We don't live in Florida, but in Tennessee, and I know it is illegal to keep any wildlife you find, so I am sure that applies to fish as well. The father of one of my daughter's friends from school is a TVA police officer. We might ask him what he thinks we should do. My husband would probably listen to him.
Thanks for all the input! One last question, once I am done with the Maracyn treatments (it said to do it on day 1, 3, & 5), how often & much should I cycle the water? I don't have the carbon filter in right now, because it said not to use it.
Kristen