Zombies -- Mafia #11
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Folks, it looks like once again that we are spread all over the place on the vote. As Swayde pointed out, it's REALLY important that we hit a zombie tonight. I think we need to focus the list a little a little more.
I'm willing to move my vote. At this point, I still need to consider where, though.
unvote Lady G
I am willing to vote on either Bkw or DC....I do not believe JL or LG are zombies unless turned night 2. I also don't think Ewurm is a zombie unless turned night 2. I believe Mad and Jpappy to be innocent. I think Ice and Coler were being played against each other (with Ogre thrown in as well) and both are innocent, unless one was turned night 2. My vote is based on Day 1/Day 2 behaviour. I am still undecided on who could possibly be turned from Night 2.
Apparently you don't read so often, but I offerred up 4 people who I thought were evil. I still stand by that list. If you think I'm evil because I don't make a new list every 5 minutes then you have a warped perception on playing this game. We all have different styles of play, just because someone doesn't have your style doesn't make them evil.
Regardless of who the candidates are this evening, it's important that they at least defend themselves. It seems like eveyone has gotten pretty complacent with the old 'Go ahead and lynch me then, you'll be sorry...' defense. This really borders on anti-town, as an easy surrender doesn't help the town make a decision.
It's getting to be lynch correctly or lose....if you're an innocent, and it looks like you could be lynched, at least say something helpful (ie, what you've done, why it doesn't make sense that you're scum, etc.).
I guess I agree with your logic, but naming achievements hasn't done much more for people than the "you'll be sorry" routine. Often the achievements get twisted against the person and the lynch-train comes anyway.
I'm willing to consider ice, JL, swayde...also Mad for lynching.
I wouldn't be as happy to vote for Lady G at this time because of DD being a zombie, however there is a possibility she was turned since.
bkw, ewurm, DC and jpappy are in my opinion poorer candidates at this time - because there is less material out there on them. Unfortunately if one of them/three of them are zombies they have stayed off the radar. In a tight situation (I havn't worked out if this is lynch or lose - I think it is depending on turns ?) it is therefore difficult to be sure enough about them.
I can see an argument that ice, JL and swayde are zombies. I stress that what I mean by this is that it is plausible. No more than that.
@mad - I played a few posts in one newbie game on mafiascum.net - dropped out; wasn't moving quickly enough. Its a totally different game over there in many ways in my opinion. Not least the voting system alone - I don't accept that changing votes mean the same in this game as over there; I'm interested in what you think about this.
I wouldn't be as happy to vote for Lady G at this time because of DD being a zombie, however there is a possibility she was turned since.
bkw, ewurm, DC and jpappy are in my opinion poorer candidates at this time - because there is less material out there on them. Unfortunately if one of them/three of them are zombies they have stayed off the radar. In a tight situation (I havn't worked out if this is lynch or lose - I think it is depending on turns ?) it is therefore difficult to be sure enough about them.
I can see an argument that ice, JL and swayde are zombies. I stress that what I mean by this is that it is plausible. No more than that.
@mad - I played a few posts in one newbie game on mafiascum.net - dropped out; wasn't moving quickly enough. Its a totally different game over there in many ways in my opinion. Not least the voting system alone - I don't accept that changing votes mean the same in this game as over there; I'm interested in what you think about this.
Ok guys, I am willing to retract my vote on JL, against my better judgement (still say he is #1evil) for the better of the town. I want to get a zombie tonight and we wont accomplish anything if everyone votes someone different. Of coarse I would prefer others join me against JL as he IS the one I am most comfortable with.
My last post doesn't really make "feel" coler is for sure Zombie, just some thoughts on things. And wanted to know what others felt. I will be off and on alot today and just wanted to at least get this post out.
I guess I would be comfortable with DC, Bkw, poss. coler (less comfortable about that as of right now though). I leave my vote open at this time, and will most likely talk about JL some more to see if anyone would be willing to switch.
Coler this is the part I don't understand (in red), are you saying it is a choice between yourself, Ogre and Ice as evil?? That is how it reads to me, that is why I found it odd
My last post doesn't really make "feel" coler is for sure Zombie, just some thoughts on things. And wanted to know what others felt. I will be off and on alot today and just wanted to at least get this post out.
I guess I would be comfortable with DC, Bkw, poss. coler (less comfortable about that as of right now though). I leave my vote open at this time, and will most likely talk about JL some more to see if anyone would be willing to switch.
Coler this is the part I don't understand (in red), are you saying it is a choice between yourself, Ogre and Ice as evil?? That is how it reads to me, that is why I found it odd
No. I am saying that a) I also suspect who Ogre suspected and that b) I myself am torn between Ogre and Ice for a third suspect. I wasn't putting myself forward as a third suspect if that's what you thought.
