Mafia #6.....The Play

MikenDanielle said:
I think for now on anyone who doesnt agree with this strategy of offing someone who is going to die anyways is VERY high up on my list. IF JM is innocent, she is going to die anyways... along with possibly another townie... if she is mafia.. SCORE! We took one out. I think anyone who can;t follow this simle reasoning has something to hide and needs to possibly be done with.
Click to expand...

thts nothing but a bully tactic, stating if u don't do this it's because ur mafia. THe whole thing with Jm is we don't know if she is mafia or not. you're assumong alot when u vote for her. This plan was a wash last night and its a wash this round.

I vote to lynch MikenDanielle

on the grounds that he is danger to the town and himself
 
MikenDanielle said:
I think for now on anyone who doesnt agree with this strategy of offing someone who is going to die anyways is VERY high up on my list. IF JM is innocent, she is going to die anyways... along with possibly another townie... if she is mafia.. SCORE! We took one out. I think anyone who can;t follow this simle reasoning has something to hide and needs to possibly be done with.
Click to expand...


LOL think before you speak, if she is a mafia and doesnt post, she will die as well. That theory makes no sense, why lynch her if shes dieing on her own. We have nothing to judge her by, we are simply playing the odds that she is one of the 7 mafia.

Form opinions and vote to lynch who seems mafia to you and others, dont always take others opinions and make them your own. mike has got to go, he was voted to be lynched last night and i dont see how we can let it go un-noticed again today.

game off//
does the doctor know the roles as well as the mafia?
game on//

I vote to lynch mikendanielle.

throwing suspicion anywhere he can find it, and jumping on who ever comes his way, not to mention the early slip ups.
 
:( I give up. I think we DO get information. JM isn't just being quiet. She is absent. She could be Mafia. I think numbers are as important as information in this Round with such a large Mafia percentage. I'm not attacking you Ogre, you're a 6 on my list right now, 10 is Innocent. I just think we have very different philosophies on how to play the JM death. I don't want to vote JM, I want to vote Mad or Mike. But a vote for Mike is pointless because the Doctor thinks he is Innocent. Hopefully JM will show up before tomorrow night and we can move past this.

My List:

1) MikenDanielle: Winner of the Corey Lover Newbie Slip Up Award. Dug a hole deep enough to bury a Buick yesterday, today pretty quiet, probably counting his stars the Doctor likes him.

2) MadCrawdad: Got defensive of the JM plan but in a strange way, different from the way other disagreers stated their case. Also, Coler's #1 pick.

3) bkw... KIDDING, watch this be the round he IS Mafia though, lol

Also, on my radar are Hooked Newbie: Voted Ice early, switched to MadCrawdad. First to vote for BOTH of these people. Then withdrew vote and did not vote on Day 1. Swayde: Voted jl66 as a revenge vote, then jumped on the JM train. Withdrew vote when that fell apart and never voted. KOTD: No vote at all on Day 1.
 
bkw1982 said:
thts nothing but a bully tactic, stating if u don't do this it's because ur mafia. THe whole thing with Jm is we don't know if she is mafia or not. you're assumong alot when u vote for her. This plan was a wash last night and its a wash this round.

I vote to lynch MikenDanielle

on the grounds that he is danger to the town and himself
Click to expand...

I agree but and I'm the President of the lynch JM club, but remember if we vote Mike the Doctor could save him again, wasting our Nightly chance to off a Mafia.
 
OgreMkV said:
OK, I know that you feel the lynch JMax thing is a valid plan. Here's why I disagree... we potentially lose two players your way and potentially three my way. BUT we get NO NEW information if we do it your way. We're basically giving the mafia a free ride for the day... letting them slip into their roles with no defending required. We start day three exactly where we are now, but with two fewer players.

I would rather take a chance on getting a mafia tonight and have lots of new information than just let the mafia get a free day. I believe that the mafia want this free day. So those on my original list remain so at this time. Note that these are the players that are attacking me.
Click to expand...


From a standpoint of garnering as much pure information as we can, this point of view makes sense, now that I go back and think about both sides of it. I posted before that it would be a 70% chance of lynching another townie, but even when that happens we get new information to go back and analyze. So, the choice is a) vote for JM, lose her and a townie to the mafia hit, and have some info from who the mafia hits, or b) let jm go regardless, take info from the mafia hit, and lynch someone we think is mafia, and get info from that as well.

No doubt its a tough choice, and a fairly cold point of view, saying yes we might lose another innocent but the expense is worth it to gain a little more insight. I'm just hoping jm makes an appearance and negates the whole debate.
 
I'm just surprised at the town's attitude. I understand the you guys don't want to lose 3 townies a night but who says that we are going to? The odds?!?! Come on...everybody is playing too defensively. Why not have a go at the mafia? I for one don't want to lynch jm. If she doesn't want to play or can't because she's too busy than we should just ignore her and play like we normally do...
 
i am assuming mike is mafia. but consider this. i have been reading all mad's posts over as colers ghost commanded.
on post 174 he votes swayde.
post 210 he begins to distance himself from mike. at this point the mafia that have contacted each other are realizing mike is lost to them
post 214 more distance from mike
post 235 is now intent on distance from mike but adds no helpful info to the town. his vote from swayze hasnt changed
post 299 begins to cast doubt on dwarf puffer, the earlier victim of mike posts. worth note: mike has also voted dwarf puffer at this point
post 304 now seems to protect judge who has not posted and on the suscpicious list of many townie for not doing so at this point. worth note: judge at this point has been active in the forum, but not on this thread.
post 311 still more deflection from judge. worth note: other townies have discovered people are veiwing the thread from invisible mode. i suspect judge has or is currently doing this but am at a loss as to why
post 315 coler names mad his chief suspect from a list that i am on and don't really agree with with the exception of mad worth note: i am this point suspicious of coler and move him to a 8 on my list and decide to build a case against him
post 472 begins to build a case for coler, who by this point he knows is going to be hit but wants to create seperation from since coler has named him as his chief suspect and he knows people will now be watching colers list very carefully if the hit isnt botched
i think i smell a rat
i vote to lynch madcrawdad
 
ok, thanks for the clarification on the doctor, my vote will stay where it is now.

Mike, how do you not see that she dies NO MATTER WHAT WE DO, why even vote for her. If you dont want anyone but her to die, then vote to lynch no one until she returns.

But by waiting to lynch, and by not taking our chances, we are simply waiting to be picked off by mafia hits. Every night, they get a hit... and if we dont do any lynching, the numbers become even worse for us then they already are. We need to make a lynch vote, and since you are so strongly against doing so, you are making me believe that you may SOMEHOW be giving people an even bigger mafia vibe then you already have.

If you are indeed innocent,like you claim to be, and you get lynched... your strategy for playing this game is no use to the town anyways, you are only hurting the town by existing.


i vote to lynch mikendanielle, again and again and again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom