Zombies -- Mafia #11

[Coler]

general observation as regards the above :

If JL, Lady G, Ogre were zombies, the other zombie would have done something about it...probably jump Charlie.

Ice as zombie only works if it is JL that is the other zombie, as he was the last to jump of JL and seal CS's doom. If Lady G or Ogre is a zombie, then you have to look at jpappy or swayde as they start the move onto Charlie.

There is of course a possibility that all this was just innocent movement. One reason why it might not be is because Charlie it would appear could be relied upon not to come and defend himself, and there was nothing anyone else could really say in his Defence either.

So, if the Charlie vote was zombie led/influenced, one of those three that had votes is a zombie.

Ice has his vote on JL and if JL is a zombie then so is Ice...otherwise JL is just not a bad suspect at the moment. I retract my vote for Ice and I vote to lynch JL

 

[Coler]

final possibility. Looking at the proximity in time of the jappy/swayde vote swap, there is a possibility that they were rattled at the prospect of having even one vote on each other and opted to load up on Charlie to make sure of no risk.

actually, that last point deserves some scrutiny - a jappy/swayde day 1 zombie combination

 

[Coler]

OK with under 5 hours to go that is how far I have got. In the interests of transparency, if it isn't obvious already, I am vote-tracking ice by moving onto JL as I believe that JL is objectively a good suspect and that there is information to be gained by doing so.

 

[Swayde]

final possibility. Looking at the proximity in time of the jappy/swayde vote swap, there is a possibility that they were rattled at the prospect of having even one vote on each other and opted to load up on Charlie to make sure of no risk.

actually, that last point deserves some scrutiny - a jappy/swayde day 1 zombie combination

Scrutinize away if you really think I may be evil. I may not always go about things as logically as I should, or even think things through as well as I should, but I do have the town's best interest at heart. Jpappy really doesn't look evil to me either, but I suppose if you believe that only zombies would have voted for Charlie, then you would have to assume that Jpappy, Ice, Ogre and myself are all zombies, but that's 4 people and only 2 could have possibly been zombies, so there goes that theory. You are voting for JL and he didn't vote for Charlie...DD still looks really suspicious and apparently you think so as well, but she didn't vote for Charlie. Is it possible that all of the people voting for Charlie are innocent who just couldnt' stomach the tought of lynching a fellow townie who could quite possibly be a power role? Well that's the way I think it happend because that's exactly what I was thinking.

 

[Coler]

Scrutinize away if you really think I may be evil. I may not always go about things as logically as I should, or even think things through as well as I should, but I do have the town's best interest at heart. Jpappy really doesn't look evil to me either,

Jpappy would not look evil to you at all if you two are our day 1 zombies

but I suppose if you believe that only zombies would have voted for Charlie, then you would have to assume that Jpappy, Ice, Ogre and myself are all zombies, but that's 4 people and only 2 could have possibly been zombies, so there goes that theory.

^ Not a fair characterisation of my post. I acknowledge this, quite obviously.

You are voting for JL and he didn't vote for Charlie...DD still looks really suspicious and apparently you think so as well, but she didn't vote for Charlie.

correct

Is it possible that all of the people voting for Charlie are innocent who just couldnt' stomach the tought of lynching a fellow townie who could quite possibly be a power role? Well that's the way I think it happend because that's exactly what I was thinking.

of course it is

edit : why charlie ? why not Guppy ? or KOTD ?...because Charlie had a vote, in a tight contest for the noose that mean a couple more votes made him very likely to win that prize. This really does make you an jpappy look very bad actually. I note also that Ice said with clarity why he was voting for Charlie - I don't believe you or jpappy did.

 

[johnlarson66]

general observation as regards the above :

If JL, Lady G, Ogre were zombies, the other zombie would have done something about it...probably jump Charlie.

Ice as zombie only works if it is JL that is the other zombie, as he was the last to jump of JL and seal CS's doom. If Lady G or Ogre is a zombie, then you have to look at jpappy or swayde as they start the move onto Charlie.

There is of course a possibility that all this was just innocent movement. One reason why it might not be is because Charlie it would appear could be relied upon not to come and defend himself, and there was nothing anyone else could really say in his Defence either.

So, if the Charlie vote was zombie led/influenced, one of those three that had votes is a zombie.

Ice has his vote on JL and if JL is a zombie then so is Ice...otherwise JL is just not a bad suspect at the moment. I retract my vote for Ice and I vote to lynch JL

While I am glad someone has looked into this end of day activity. I agree if Ice and me were both zombies it would make perfect sense for him to come to my rescue, especially if I was unwilling to do it myself.

If I am Ice's zombie partner, well then I suck. Why would I be the one to be pointing this out, over and over. I have been told to drop it, but no matter how I look at it, it makes no sense. The kicker is that he thought and still thinks I am a zombie, but had the chance to lynch me and took his vote off of me.

Armed with this knowledge, Coler, you have decided that Ice and I are both Zombies, but have switched back to me off of him. If we are both zombies, then why does it matter which one gets lynched?

What did Ice do to have you take your vote off of him? What did I do to put your vote back on me?

 

[Coler]

this next point is too important to add by way of edit :

Ice voted for Charlie and explained why - rather lose a townie than risk a power role. There is some logic in this.

Neither you nor jappy explained with clarity why Charlie. And you picked him at a point when there was other options as regards non power players. Ice picked him in a straight shoot out between JL and Charlie. Ice's reason has some merit to it. Yours has less/none and it seems like you are now adopting Ice's reasoning.

edit : for clarity this post was addressed to swayde

 

[Swayde]

Jpappy would not look evil to you at all if you two are our day 1 zombies



^ Not a fair characterisation of my post. I acknowledge this, quite obviously.



correct



of course it is

edit : why charlie ? why not Guppy ? or KOTD ?...because Charlie had a vote, in a tight contest for the noose that mean a couple more votes made him very likely to win that prize. This really does make you an jpappy look very bad actually. I note also that Ice said with clarity why he was voting for Charlie - I don't believe you or jpappy did.

Dunno about anyone else, but to me Charlie seemed most likely to be a zombie waiting until the last minute to cast a vote. He was not playing his normal game and as I've mentioned, I was already suspicious of him. Do you actually read what people post?

 

[Coler]

Armed with this knowledge, Coler, you have decided that Ice and I are both Zombies, but have switched back to me off of him. If we are both zombies, then why does it matter which one gets lynched?

What did Ice do to have you take your vote off of him? What did I do to put your vote back on me?

nope I didn't decide you were both zombies - you may have missed some of my posts while typing.

swayde/jpappy anyone ?

 

[Coler]

I was already suspicious of him. Do you actually read what people post?

no I prefer to rely on my laptop to mime what people post through the medium of charades.

lets see now...one word...two syllables...sounds like abercrombie...