Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Dangerdoll]

G, please come back to the room...

 

[johnlarson66]

I will try not to make this too long of a post. I wanted to get my list of who most likely mafia, once (or if) DD is found to be mafia.

This list is in the order of the posts I am using to back me up.

Jensons - this post was right after the day had started, instead of discussing Lady G's claim to be the Detective, she wants to go on a wild goose chase of who lynched DJ and then wants to know how many "townies" she can count on. Well he has not told us any counts before, why would he now. I find this post very suspect.

I see why Lady G has her as a suspect. I hope she is investigated soon.

Sorry, I was on the phone and composing, so I didn't realize night had fallen. We need to look at who made sucha case for dj. I admit that I thought he was guilty at the end, so look at me if necessary.

rb: can you tell me how many townies I can count on now? or am I s.o.l.? btw, GREAT narration!

clown-lover - another post soon after the day had started. He had challanged Lady G on being the Detective, but now in the new day, he wants to believe her. Instead it is a mafia play and votes to lynch her. I just do not like the "I want to believe you", she has been his number one suspect.

Lady G as much I want to believe you.. I think it was a mafia ploy..

I vote to lynch LadyG

judgemax - real quick to jump on board with Lady G, which I can understand, they were both voting for Blue and since their "disagreement" have been more on the same page, but then this post. I am at a loss. What did RB say she did?

how can I not when RB all but said exactly what she did?...

Blueiz - I have thought she was either mafia or a power role. If Lady G is the Detective, then I doubt she is the Doctor. I am fairly sure that she will be the next investigation. It would not suprise me that she was the other Don.

I am not fully convinced LG is the detective. I asked to see what her response would be. I know that if the doctor came out we would be screwed, that is obvious. I see a lot of off the wall questions such as the one I just asked, asked to see what the response will be.

OgreMvk - has mixed it up some this game, but has added to the confussion more than helped. I also think it is odd to throw Blue into this at this time. It really seems at this point it is about Lady G and Dangerdoll.

Again to attempt to forestall the mad rush... in the interest of discussion and because a few of those posts were insanely mafia like I vote to lynch Blueiz.

I will probably switch later.

In the interest of full disclosure, this is driving me nuts. I read one post that says she's the det, and I think, "Yeah, I can see that." Then I read the next post that says something isn't right and I think, "Yeah, I can see that too."

So you investigated DD first and she's a Don.
You did not investigate blue, jensons, or clownlover, even though they are your top suspects?

You investigated people that are hard to read...

I can see that. I don't think I agree with it, but I can see the logic behind your plan. We have plenty of time, so let's work this out and decide, as a town, if we should follow LadyG.

To be honest, as I write this, I'm leaning more and more her way. I still think discussion is better than a lack of discussion, so I'll keep my vote where it is for now.

This list of course will not mean anything if this is a trick by Lady G. I would be really impressed if it was, but at this point, I think she is the Detective.

 

[johnlarson66]

Well, since the person I investigated is innocent...I can tell you it wasn't Jensons, Blue or CL...so they are all still suspicious to me. I do know we will get a Mafia Don tomorrow night! With that I can sleep better! I chose the hardest for me to read first so I could quit trying to guess on them.

I hope you investigate one of these three.

You know what would even make it better, if one mafia team hit the other team.

This is going to be a long day. I would have liked 24 hours, but can understand 48. The waiting is the hardest part.

 

[johnlarson66]

This has concerned me about DC too. Also what concerns me is that he goes and puts out this big explanation and then a ist without reasons for people right after it's been noted that lists without reason look suspicious, claiming he has no time and needs to get to work. If that were the case, why even put out a list? Seems to me, he may be trying to appear helpful.


why is it that people post what they want to do such as read through to find such and such but will do so later? G is talking about she couldn't sleep because of all this yet she says she's coming back tomorrow to explain.... was this really just a vent?

DD, it was 3AM...no I wasn't going to sit here and go through all the post's at that time!:drool: I said I couldn't sleep because I felt like I needed to apologize for what I had said, I did that...And NO that post was not a vent the one before it was, funny how you are the only one to post about it and take it that way.

Speaking of things...where have you been DD? What happened to the oh so helpful DD of last game?

G, I'm doing all I can here. Facts are that there are a lot of things people are picking up on in a few people, I am trying to keep the town from being focused on only one or two because realistically, there are more mafia. Last game, we were sweeped horribly. I am trying not to have that done this game too.

G, where's your explanation..... it is tomorrow, you know.

Yes DD, I know what day it is..you know when your actually looking through things and not skimming it takes a while sometimes, after all the helpful post from you last game one would think you would know this.

yep, I know all about it, G.... and I am finding it really cool that you brought your "explanations out" once being called on it. Good for you.

There is no "explanation" just observations at this point, I'm glad you find it "cool", cause I find it "cool" that you want to try and bring something on me from this.:grinyes:

So I'm wondering this is just a "feeling" at the moment, IF Rb hand picked roles.
Wouldn't it be Rb like to make you a Don, to take out Charlie for tricking you last game

that would be, Lady but the fact is, Charlie has tricked me before and I don't think rb would have made things that obvious because I am not mafia, nor the don. I am working for the town, not against it, contrary to what you may be trying to imply. How is it that you go from being very complacent to being this attacking after one night? Is it that I called you out?

No, I doubt you are the Don..but I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried about you.
No, DD others have said things to me also, even voted for me.

Above is the highlights of the discussion that took part at the start of Day Two. I am assuming by this time, Lady G has already investigated Dangerdoll and has contacted the Doctor. Lady G's last post has me a little concerned. I am hoping she can shed some light on it. I find these transactions odd, especially if Lady G knew that DangerDoll was mafia and a Don.

I also noticed something odd during this time and I am pretty sure I posted about it. The whole DD and Charlie thing seemed different. DD did not really have the same type of conversations with Charlie as in prior games.

 

[johnlarson66]

I am here. I am reading the posts.

I will not die an untimely death. I appreciate the townies thoughts on this issue. Not a good idea. Got it.

I did not propose this plan to be unsportsmanlike. Please understand, I was thinking (admittedly not carefully) about what is best for the town. Keep in mind, when i was the snitch, I even lied to my teamates about my role, as to do otherwise was in violation of the games rules. I am unwilling to go outside of the rules of the game in an effort to win. I would not like it if that is what people thought i was trying to do.

I will re read the thread, more carefully and look for clues. I will vote before nightfalls.

I think this is the closest we will find that Charlie was the Accident.

I also want to point out this post again:

There is no "explanation" just observations at this point, I'm glad you find it "cool", cause I find it "cool" that you want to try and bring something on me from this.:grinyes:

So I'm wondering this is just a "feeling" at the moment, IF Rb hand picked roles.
Wouldn't it be Rb like to make you a Don, to take out Charlie for tricking you last game

I think RB handpicked the roles.

I think Charlie was the Accident. Dangerdoll and Blueiz are Don's. Lady G is the Detective.

 

[johnlarson66]

Please clarify

My list has my reasons listed for who I listed, as well as my post voting to lynch you has my reason listed. Where have I noted the ones that I think are innocent?

To also add, I explained why I mentioned DC in post 747. This is the second time you have questioned this, and I have already given you the answer. You are following right along with JL. Look at posts 744 and post 745, my answer is in 747. You ask the same thing again in post 759, worded slightly differntly.

Are you and JL working together? Trying the gang up on one person, throw the same questions at them worded differently routine? Thats pretty obvious to me. It might would work better if you tried the good cop, bad cop routine. However, that would be impossible for you two to do since its very doubtful either of you are good.

I am not on any side with Lady G. The fact that we agree on a few things bothers me.

I have her more leaning mafia. Her and Blueiz. Let's not forget about JudgeMax.

I am also concerned about cooldude. I think each mafia team has a noob.

I had forgot about this. Also this will be my last post for a while, I really should be working...

I just wanted point out this exchange. I hope Blueiz gets investigated next. More and more I think she is the other Don.

I think rbishop "tweaked" this game too much.

 

[johnlarson66]

right now i'm worried about the DD and blue Vs. lady thing going on.this could be a mafia vs. innocent thing w/ DD and blue being mafia, or it could be a lady really is mafia and DD and blue are right. There has been alot of post brought up within this thing, but some are from the first night, when we are not sure what to think.
anyone else have any thoughts on this or is it just me?

remember that there is a possibility that they are all bad...not a very good one because I doubt that if blueiz and dd were on the same team they would both be going after the same person. And neither of them would be going after Lg if they were on the same team as her...so I guess I could rule that out. My guess is that two of them are mafia and like you I have no idea which one is at this point. If I had to pick it would be Lg and Blueiz. But I am still watching DD, of course.

Okay I am still reading. Also DP is online and I am hoping to see what he has to say. I found these posts and thought they were relevant. It also changes how I feel about cooldude.

 

[Dwarf Puffers]

Okay I am still reading. Also DP is online and I am hoping to see what he has to say. I found these posts and thought they were relevant. It also changes how I feel about cooldude.

Whew, lots of reading, and not as much info as I expected. I'm probably going to end up voting for DD or G in the end, probably DD, but I'm holding my "tongue" for now on this one... Have to see what happens...

When's night time?

 

[Swayde]

Whew, lots of reading, and not as much info as I expected. I'm probably going to end up voting for DD or G in the end, probably DD, but I'm holding my "tongue" for now on this one... Have to see what happens...

When's night time?

Tip...read RB's posts.

 

[johnlarson66]

I just noticed I had 6 posts in a row.

No one has commented on any of it. I really need to get away from my computer. I hope to be back on this evening.