Oh my...let me perhaps go back and edit the post I was working on...LadyG did you just goof up majorly?
Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play
- Thread starter clown-lover
- Start date
NO, LOL...really I don't know why that was there, I clicked on the post that you (HN) had posted to me and was replying to that...believe me it threw me off HUGE when I seen that one there.
No HN, I am not trying to build a case on you. If I were, there would of been a case..maybe it is a sing though:lipssealedsmilie:
Anyway HN, had I "Multi-quoted" it would of had that quote with the one I intended to be there:silly:
My thoughts on where everyone stands:
green=known, pink=strong evidence or clues
Innocent:
jpappy789
Madcrawdad
JP because he has hardly been here and he voted with JL the first night and Mad well Mad because I think you have been the perfect mix of players. You've been helpful, you've posted but not too much, and pretty much been a hard nut to crack. The ONLY thing that doesn't fit is that you voted for Beth the first night when it wasn't needed due to the town lynching the girl. However you did help push for her to remain our target at the end and one of the players (LG or HN?) pointed that out back then. I'm not going to dig the post up right now but I will if I must. I have a reason though why I think you voted for Beth the first night.
I think you were protecting your captain by helping to lynch an innocent (Beth) and allowing your captain to throw her vote elsewhere. I think the original captain was JM...and when the pirates saw how many eyes were starting to shift to her you all drank a few more glasses of grog and decided to have JM promote you as the new Captain. Which made JM just a regular pirate when she was lynched. Mad I think you're not only a pirate, but I think you're Blackbeard.
If the townspeople want to convince me that JPap is a more likely target...fine. But for right now
I vote to make Mad walk the plank.
green=known, pink=strong evidence or clues
Innocent:
- Mgamer20o0
- Beth
- Lupin
- Ice (guard)
- rbishop (guard)
- Grins (the one the pirates are wanting to smack right now)
- mee-mee (she isn't making the goof ups you've all mentioned she would if mafia)
- LesbianChap (have not seen anything that screams mafia, in fact those saying he exudes mafia have been on my top mafia suspects all along)
- Hooked Newbie (his votes and questions have matched what an innocent's would seem to)
- Malbri (she has hardly been here granted, but other than only posting about Rb for the most part she doesn't seem mafia to me. She just seems how she is out of the game, just Mal.)
- ______________
- judgemax
- johnlarson66
- Blueiz (but trying to hide Blackbeard by putting heat more on herself)
- Dangerdoll (not as obvious as Blue, but still seems very much a pirate to me, call it a gut feeling if you must. I don't think she is Blackbeard either. I think she is busy this time of year, and maybe not helping out her fellow pirates as much?)
- LadyG (I admit I'm waffling on her. I was sure she was a pirate, then her post about Mad had me thinking otherwise, but then the weird post she just made had me come back and move her off my innocent list to the pirate list. LadyG, you're a pirate or much like Bob you're making yourself look pirate when you're innocent.
- ______________
jpappy789
Madcrawdad
JP because he has hardly been here and he voted with JL the first night and Mad well Mad because I think you have been the perfect mix of players. You've been helpful, you've posted but not too much, and pretty much been a hard nut to crack. The ONLY thing that doesn't fit is that you voted for Beth the first night when it wasn't needed due to the town lynching the girl. However you did help push for her to remain our target at the end and one of the players (LG or HN?) pointed that out back then. I'm not going to dig the post up right now but I will if I must. I have a reason though why I think you voted for Beth the first night.
I think you were protecting your captain by helping to lynch an innocent (Beth) and allowing your captain to throw her vote elsewhere. I think the original captain was JM...and when the pirates saw how many eyes were starting to shift to her you all drank a few more glasses of grog and decided to have JM promote you as the new Captain. Which made JM just a regular pirate when she was lynched. Mad I think you're not only a pirate, but I think you're Blackbeard.
If the townspeople want to convince me that JPap is a more likely target...fine. But for right now
I vote to make Mad walk the plank.
and yeah I know JM was killed by the guard and not lynched but I've been posting a lot..give me a break
I'm going to say, I pretty much agree with your list's (well except for me of coarse
)
But I'm not so sold on HN as you are, I've been fooled by him and pretty bad a few times.
Also not sold on Mal or Lchap, Mal really didn't say anything last game either, and when she was hit by the innocents I was completely surprised they hit her.
Lchap-well honestly I have gone back and forth quite a bit on...there are just some posts he has made that really bother me.
)But I'm not so sold on HN as you are, I've been fooled by him and pretty bad a few times.
Also not sold on Mal or Lchap, Mal really didn't say anything last game either, and when she was hit by the innocents I was completely surprised they hit her.
Lchap-well honestly I have gone back and forth quite a bit on...there are just some posts he has made that really bother me.
erv: