Mafia 62- The Play

[Dangerdoll]

wow, lots of work has been accomplished with you guys kicking in them bushes. Really sorry I haven't been giving too much, I have been resting a lot... but hopefully, I will be in better shape soon enough...

I do think the evidence against Dawg at this point is compelling and leaves one no other choice but to vote for him. For now, I vote to lynch Dawg...

however, I would like to hear more form Mich who has seemed to drop off the face ever since the odd remarks on day 1.

 

[AnniesNotOK]

DAY THREE

Razz-3- Ice(#459), Jpap(#505), Lab(#516)
Ice-0- Dawg(#482)
Lab-1- Razz(#501)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#510)
Dawg-3- JB(#552), JL(#569), DD(#571)
JB-1- Dawg(#555)
Zaffy-1- ZS(#564)

No vote from Mich

NIGHTFALL IN 5HRS 33MINS

PM'S AS REQUIRED

 

[jpappy789]

Taking a look at JL.

Is this Ice's way of claiming innocence?

Jab at Ice...

Rich reacted very calmly...

Right hook at Rich...

I don't think I have played with LR, but I have read last game. I need to re-read and see who was evil.



So LR has played before on another site with AlexW, who is normally a low poster. Three players may get LR's vote because they have not posted yet.



The same three players have not voted, but LR puts out a vote for a player they have had experience playing with and is normally a low poster. This is not their first game, but they forget to bold. Do you have to place votes in bold on the other site?



Catches the bold very quickly and revotes. Is this a random vote to play along with rich or is this a vote. If AlexW is not a UD canidate and is a high vote getter, I would be suprised to see this vote not change.

One of many posts on Lab.

Kash holding on to her vote is once again very anti-town. She does this every time she has been mafia. If she waits until 2 hours before nightfall to place a vote, I will be all over it. I hope others are also.

You can change your vote!

I have already found Lab_Rat's vote on AlexW to be suspicous. Ice's "I am innocent" post, plus he did not say he was number ____". Rich trying to get folks to place random votes and then you waiting it out. All sorts of suspicious things going on.

Maybe you are too busy hiding and not looking.

Going after Kash...

Thank you for the vote. If someone else had voted for me then you would not have voted for me? Since LR voted AlexW you did not want to place your vote on AlexW.

I am guessing this is your first game, have you played any where else?

I think this was to Michwol?

Here is another player that has played with the infamously quiet AlexW. Looks like I am the first player to get two votes. And both coming from friends of AlexW.

Thank you.

To Agass.

It was Lab_Rat who said AlexW was quiet before. Maybe Agi said it also, but I only recall LR posting it.

More on Lab.

Maybe JL was not on the site! I can't believe you would find this alarming. I can believe it from the noobs, but not from someone who has been around a few games. Next you are going to be suprised that I sometimes skim.

I find it alarming that you find it alarming.

This is to Z...

Ice, I would assume that you would be investigated fairly early. I doubt if you were to get lynched on day.

I think this post is odd and very un-Ice like. I don't remember all of the details of the pocket mafia from before, but I don't have good memories of it.

You putting the mafia on the edge, wtf is that? So now if you don't get hit, it will be because of this doctor trick. Already setting up for the next day?

I am guessing you are drinking the beer the noods stopped drinking or are smoking medical marijauna.

Are you afriad the town is going to lynch you on day one?

I have no interest in pocket mafia.

More on Ice.

Do they have UD's on the other site that you play? How many games have you played on the other site.

There is also a difference between "Low" posters and those who have not posted. Also using post count to find mafia, IME does not work. I wish it did. My main beef with low posters is posting is part of the game. If they did not want to post, why play. There are many players that play and don't post much. Like your friend AlexW. That is just their style.

While I might not like it, it does not mean they are mafia.

I think this is to Lab.

Here I am. I will be around more. Odd that you don't want to hear from your untalkative mutal friend AlexW.

For the record, I can be very talkative and post in spurts. I also have been known to skim to catch up. I am a workaholic in full relapse, but when I can I will get on here.

The few people from here that I chat with know that I have been pretty busy the last few months. Even those that I don't chat with know that I work lots. I am not making any excuses. I am here now and doing my best to catch up (and not just skim).

I think Lab, again.

I am caught up.

I hope some folks will comment on some of my comments.

My top suspect is Lab_Rat.

Their vote is for someone that had not posted yet, but they knew was a low poster from past games at another web site.

Why they did not place a vote for a non-UD risk player or change it when they had to see all of the heat Agas was taking for their logic in placing a vote on me, who at the time was a UD risk.

They even jumped on board giving Agas a hard time for calling me talkative and accusing Agas and I to be talking off site. All the while having their own vote on a player that had not posted, but was deemed a low poster.

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

For the record, I am highly concerned with Kashata's wait and see attitiude and I am a little freaked out by Ice's pocket mafia and doctor maybe protect me plea.

More on Lab...a little about Kash and Ice as well.

Well this changes my thoughts on Lab_Rat. They say they are innocent and trying to help the town. Who can argue with that. Lab_Rat has to be innocent.

I retract my vote on Lab_Rat.

More on Lab (vote was re-voted)

Seems to me you went from your low poster idea and switched it to the highest poster.

More and more I like my vote on Lab_Rat.

Lab again.

So why did you choose to vote jpap?

I don't know if you are innocent or mafia. A good way to find out is to lynch you. So far you are my top suspect. I am not sure if I have "led the charge against" you or if anyone really even trusts me enough to follow me. It is not like their is a train on you. It is day one and someone is going to get lynched. Who is your top suspect now? Any suspects of people not voting for you? Why are two of the three people voting for you mafia or even all three?

Grilling Lab.

I am not sure who your vote is even on today.

If Lab_Rat comes up innocent, then I can see why noods or anyone voting for Lab_Rat might be a good suspect (including myself).

If Lab_Rat comes up mafia, will Noods still be tomorrows vote?

Besides claiming your own innocence, now you are claiming Lab_Rat's innocence?

I will give you this much Ice, you have switched up your play style.

To Ice...

While I like what Kash has said about Ice as I agree with most of it, I don't agree with her vote on Ice when there are 3 players with multiple votes.

I have not seen anyone else even question Ice's plea and change of game play. This is a concern. I would expect jpap amoung others to catch on to some of it.

More concern about Ice (I did think it was unusual by the way, and made an pretty lengthy post outlining my thoughts, thank you very much John "the Skimmer" Larson)

So I am guessing the Detective would focus on finding the Doctor, plus they can find 100% mafia players. This is not the first game that the Don comes up innocent.

What do you attribute your change of style to? Last game killing 3 mafia? Where is the old Ice?

Ice again...

You had no problem voting for Ag, blaming jpap for your vote?

Kicks some bushes ala DD

Not as bad as your day is going to be.

I am guessing you have never played mafia before. You switched your lone worthless vote to another lone worthless vote at (really after) nightfall. Kind of pointless. I think you will have some explaining to do.

Good luck.

I think there is a difference between being mafia and a noobatard. Right now I am leaning towards the latter.

Like I said good luck.

Pokes at Michwol.

I vote for Lab_Rat

Mostly for reasons stated before and the jump to blame jpap.

Why did you hit Kash?

Lab again.

So was Kash on to something? She did not have many posts. I think she voted on Agas. I need to look to see who she was onto besides Ice.

I really can't see Ice hitting Kash again.

Eases up on Ice here. Something to take note of.

Lab_Rat, you missed part of my post in your quote -



So why did you hit Kash, to set up Ice?

Lab again...surprised?

My top four suspects -

Lab-Rat: I have not liked any of the reasons given for their votes and I don't like the look this way but vote that way. Atempting to blame jpap for lynching Ag.

Dangerdoll: The late, just before nightfall vote on Ag. Pretty safe vote on a player that was leading the votes and then atempting to blame jpap for Ag getting lynched.

Noods: Not as much activity as I would expect from her. I don't understand the whole Steven King thing or the not drinking beer angle. I know that if she is mafia, she will crack. I get a weird feeling that she is agreeing with me to keep me off of her.

Ice: Not sure if I understand the new Ice. I go back and forth on how I feel about Ice. I did not like the pocket mafia or the plea to have the Doc protect them.

Finally a suspect list. Noods is in here...odd since I don't believe I saw him direct anything at her nor anything indicating that she seemed remotely scummy. Nor have I seen Noods respond to anything JL had said...so not sure where this "agreement" is coming from. (I will be triple checking) The other candidates are somewhat obvious.

I would not have believed Ag if he would have came out as the detective. He had no way to prove it. I think Ag should have put up some sort of aurguement. I don't think coming out would have saved him.

I think it is odd that dawg thinks that Ag was hit or could have been protected by the doctor. Besides Lab_Rat, no one really has said much about dawg, that I remember. Is this an attempt to have us think that since dawg didn't know who was hit he had nothing to do with it?

Dawg isn't one to skim.

I couldn't find another post about the doc, but I do skim.

The only one I have seen put anything in the docs head has been Ice. I am sure Ice confused the heck out of the doc.

Dawg now comes up.

I don't think I have ever seen Ice as a player do a vote count. Trying to be helpful?

A quick jab at Ice.

I think at least one person voting Lab_Rat is mafia.

I also think at least one person tha has not voted is mafia.

So that just leaves Lab_Rat and Dawg not in those two groups. I would think that there is a good chance at least one of them is mafia.

Lab and now more on Dawg.

Did noods cry, hear comes a train, just after getting one vote from Lab_Rat? Or did she have two whole votes. Something just does not seem right.

I smell a rat. How was Lab cleared? By being the first vote on noods? I am trying to figure what Lab did not to be a suspect. I am not trying to be just focused on Lab_Rat, but something is bothering me here.

I know that noods is no good at being evil, but this meltdown doesn't add up. She was on a few suspects lists, but this seems just over the top.

Does the Don have powers that the goons don't have? Was this a way to protect the Don? I need to check the rules.

I also don't get the hit on Rich.

Still on Lab.

I see no reason why the mafia would need to protect the Don. The Don's only power was to show up innocent and with out a detective, that power is of no use.

I have been focused in on Lab_Rat from day one and when I re-read the thread, I come up with completely different thoughts on Lab_Rat.

I have Lab_Rat leaning innocent.

I think that atleast one person voting on noods was mafia also. Part of me can't get away from the feeling that noods wanted to die. She had peaked a few radars, but was not really in the conversation of being a target. The train statement seemed too over the top, but then again, noods has had a history of melting down while being mafia.

Now believes Lab is more innocent...

I vote to lynch Dawg


I have not seen him state that he has been skimming or has been needing to catch up. Some of the statements he has made just do not make sense.

I felt at a point that either him or Lab_Rat were mafia. I have Lab_Rat leaning innocent.

...and now to Dawg.


I dunno what to think really. JL's certainly taken quite a few jabs at numerous players but I guess that is to be expected from him no matter the role. What concerns me is that he suddenly had noods as a suspect without really interacting with her at all. Then when she comes up mafia he still keeps thinking about Lab only to switch when the general consensus changes direction to other people. I understand skimming but it really only took a quick 30 second glance at the rules to realize that there is no reason the mafia would need to save the don but he still had to get Labs name out there again. Add in the fact that like Zaffy he has Noods as a suspect but basically only comments on the fact that she will have a melt down if she is mafia and I think JL will be staying on my short list.

 

[jpappy789]

So I took the liberty of quoting everyone of JL and Noods posts (in order minus the first) to see where JL thought Noods was agreeing with him and therefore was somewhat scummy.

Here's his list, post #266 I believe.

My top four suspects -

Lab-Rat: I have not liked any of the reasons given for their votes and I don't like the look this way but vote that way. Atempting to blame jpap for lynching Ag.

Dangerdoll: The late, just before nightfall vote on Ag. Pretty safe vote on a player that was leading the votes and then atempting to blame jpap for Ag getting lynched.

Noods: Not as much activity as I would expect from her. I don't understand the whole Steven King thing or the not drinking beer angle. I know that if she is mafia, she will crack. I get a weird feeling that she is agreeing with me to keep me off of her.

Ice: Not sure if I understand the new Ice. I go back and forth on how I feel about Ice. I did not like the pocket mafia or the plea to have the Doc protect them.

And off we go!

Oh boy! Lucky number 13! I was not on the forum at all yesterday and almost missed the game!! :nilly:

well thanks dawg! FYI - I was sick all day yesterday and had not been on the forum at all. This morning I checked before I hopped in the shower before work and noted the game had started. That is all but feel free to read into anything you wish, Lawd knows many of you will! LOL

Anyway, it is good to play another game. Seems like forever since I played. (altho I did have the new Stephen King novel to keep me occupied) :dance:
Need to read over the thread thus far, as I had minimal time to think about at work today, and see who is stringing a line of BS on day one.

This makes the meter ping a little bit. This early in the game it just seems like an easy way to distance from a team mate; too easy.



not sure I like this. Just cause a player does not post much does not make them instant innocent!



What is PSTD?



Good question.....




again - :silly:



hhhmmm, another player that says Alex plays quiet. Could be true but....:huh: more pings on the meter.......

Missed this while I was typing my post....very good point...

well, I s'pose I will go ahead and vote my uselss day one vote before i get on with my own evening.
I vote to lynch Dangerdoll, because I can and it feels good to type! This is subject to change as obviously a lone is useless, but then again it is nite one, so who knows what may or may not present itself.

Then again....some of the others have piqued my interest as I stated earlier...I must go shower and think. hhhhhmmmmm, wish I had not quit drinking beer. I miss the way it helped me think!

I have skimmed to get up to speed. I see I am quite the subject of conversation. I had no idea the game started and have not been on AC.

I will be able to play. Work is crazy, but I also have plenty of access to computers and the internet. I enjoyed what I read on the last game. I have missed playing.

I still need to read and don't worry noobs, I will be posting. I post in spurts and in the middle of the night.

I still really don't have a good way of placing a day one vote. Anyone want to role play? That seemed to work as good as anything else.

I need to drive back to work and I will be reading and posting later. Am I the only one that had not posted?

Is this Ice's way of claiming innocence?

Rich reacted very calmly...

I don't think I have played with LR, but I have read last game. I need to re-read and see who was evil.



So LR has played before on another site with AlexW, who is normally a low poster. Three players may get LR's vote because they have not posted yet.



The same three players have not voted, but LR puts out a vote for a player they have had experience playing with and is normally a low poster. This is not their first game, but they forget to bold. Do you have to place votes in bold on the other site?



Catches the bold very quickly and revotes. Is this a random vote to play along with rich or is this a vote. If AlexW is not a UD canidate and is a high vote getter, I would be suprised to see this vote not change.

Kash holding on to her vote is once again very anti-town. She does this every time she has been mafia. If she waits until 2 hours before nightfall to place a vote, I will be all over it. I hope others are also.

You can change your vote!

I have already found Lab_Rat's vote on AlexW to be suspicous. Ice's "I am innocent" post, plus he did not say he was number ____". Rich trying to get folks to place random votes and then you waiting it out. All sorts of suspicious things going on.

Maybe you are too busy hiding and not looking.

Thank you for the vote. If someone else had voted for me then you would not have voted for me? Since LR voted AlexW you did not want to place your vote on AlexW.

I am guessing this is your first game, have you played any where else?

Here is another player that has played with the infamously quiet AlexW. Looks like I am the first player to get two votes. And both coming from friends of AlexW.

Thank you.

It was Lab_Rat who said AlexW was quiet before. Maybe Agi said it also, but I only recall LR posting it.

Maybe JL was not on the site! I can't believe you would find this alarming. I can believe it from the noobs, but not from someone who has been around a few games. Next you are going to be suprised that I sometimes skim.

I find it alarming that you find it alarming.

You just did.

:lipssealedsmilie:

Ice, I would assume that you would be investigated fairly early. I doubt if you were to get lynched on day.

I think this post is odd and very un-Ice like. I don't remember all of the details of the pocket mafia from before, but I don't have good memories of it.

You putting the mafia on the edge, wtf is that? So now if you don't get hit, it will be because of this doctor trick. Already setting up for the next day?

I am guessing you are drinking the beer the noods stopped drinking or are smoking medical marijauna.

Are you afriad the town is going to lynch you on day one?

I have no interest in pocket mafia.

Do they have UD's on the other site that you play? How many games have you played on the other site.

There is also a difference between "Low" posters and those who have not posted. Also using post count to find mafia, IME does not work. I wish it did. My main beef with low posters is posting is part of the game. If they did not want to post, why play. There are many players that play and don't post much. Like your friend AlexW. That is just their style.

While I might not like it, it does not mean they are mafia.

Here I am. I will be around more. Odd that you don't want to hear from your untalkative mutal friend AlexW.

For the record, I can be very talkative and post in spurts. I also have been known to skim to catch up. I am a workaholic in full relapse, but when I can I will get on here.

The few people from here that I chat with know that I have been pretty busy the last few months. Even those that I don't chat with know that I work lots. I am not making any excuses. I am here now and doing my best to catch up (and not just skim).

Thank you jpap.

You have to PM annie to resign. I am against resigning. It is your choice.

Before you quit, which one of your friends (LR or Agas) seems more scummy based on your past experience. If you had to choose one or the other, who would you lynch?

I am caught up.

I hope some folks will comment on some of my comments.

My top suspect is Lab_Rat.

Their vote is for someone that had not posted yet, but they knew was a low poster from past games at another web site.

Why they did not place a vote for a non-UD risk player or change it when they had to see all of the heat Agas was taking for their logic in placing a vote on me, who at the time was a UD risk.

They even jumped on board giving Agas a hard time for calling me talkative and accusing Agas and I to be talking off site. All the while having their own vote on a player that had not posted, but was deemed a low poster.

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

For the record, I am highly concerned with Kashata's wait and see attitiude and I am a little freaked out by Ice's pocket mafia and doctor maybe protect me plea.

Looks like I have a lot of catching up to do and only a 20 minute lunch break to do it in! Arg! Be back in a few............

I retract my vote for Dangerdoll and vote to lynch Labby I think that ties it up again but not sure if my tracking is correct. (work has been crazy)
Not sure my vote will stay there til nightfall but I feel pretty good about it right now. She has proven herself to be a pretty good player and able to pull the wool over even vets eyes. At this point I am not willing to take the chance.....I will do my best to sneak on here in an hour or so and try to put up a list altho one it is pretty flimsy.......

You have been active, that does not mean you are a townie. I agree that my vote is largely based on how well you have played the past couple of games but the comments made about Alex and then your vote for him are a bit fishy. As for Rich, no, not suspicious, yet. the banter between Ag and JP seems pretty typical for JP. He finds something to pick at and keeps picking away until he is satisfied. (eeewww, wonder if he picked his scabs as a kid!) LOL

the rest in no particular order:

Ice, I got nothin yet except that he seems resigned to the fact hat he will be hit or lynched early.

Kash, pretty quiet thus far but it is day one..

Zaffy, no read
DD, evil to the core! (JK, I have no idea)
Dawg, no read
JL, no read
Zsand - suspicious as we have not had a "question" yet and it is almost the end of day one!

JB, creeping up on the meter, but this could also be residual from him killing off Santa! :angryfire:

Razz, no read yet.

Obviously, day one has me pretty baffled and right now my vote sits where I feel it is best. This certainly may change as the daylight fades........

oops, forgot the new kid on the block...:huh:
think that is everyone.

Well this changes my thoughts on Lab_Rat. They say they are innocent and trying to help the town. Who can argue with that. Lab_Rat has to be innocent.

I retract my vote on Lab_Rat.

NOT!

I vote to lynch Lab_Rat.

Seems to me you went from your low poster idea and switched it to the highest poster.

More and more I like my vote on Lab_Rat.

Ok, so below here is the only thing I see that could possibly be seen as Noods agreeing with JL...and it comes in the form of them both questioning the same post of Ice's.

I am not sure who your vote is even on today.

If Lab_Rat comes up innocent, then I can see why noods or anyone voting for Lab_Rat might be a good suspect (including myself).

If Lab_Rat comes up mafia, will Noods still be tomorrows vote?

Besides claiming your own innocence, now you are claiming Lab_Rat's innocence?

I will give you this much Ice, you have switched up your play style.

You conveniently overlooked the later part of my post. apparently you are so certain that you are not voting for a possible townie, right? Man, you are good to be sooo certain on day one.

I voted for what I found to be the most fishy at this early point in the game. Isn't that what most do, especially on day one? Unless of course you are on a comm. team and know for certain that is.........

And the rest are just the ones leading up to JL's list.

:rofl: it took you how many games to note there is something "off" with me?
:silly: sorry, I have been reading stephen king lately and it seems to warp my sense of humor! any other SK fans here?

So why did you choose to vote jpap?

I don't know if you are innocent or mafia. A good way to find out is to lynch you. So far you are my top suspect. I am not sure if I have "led the charge against" you or if anyone really even trusts me enough to follow me. It is not like their is a train on you. It is day one and someone is going to get lynched. Who is your top suspect now? Any suspects of people not voting for you? Why are two of the three people voting for you mafia or even all three?

annie, can you post who has not voted and is in danger of UD?

Thanks

While I like what Kash has said about Ice as I agree with most of it, I don't agree with her vote on Ice when there are 3 players with multiple votes.

I have not seen anyone else even question Ice's plea and change of game play. This is a concern. I would expect jpap amoung others to catch on to some of it.

So I am guessing the Detective would focus on finding the Doctor, plus they can find 100% mafia players. This is not the first game that the Don comes up innocent.

What do you attribute your change of style to? Last game killing 3 mafia? Where is the old Ice?

LMAO! I am not blaming Stephen King! (the man is god-like and has no faults) I said I always post a bit 'off' and am usually supsect. I excused my current wicked sense of humor on being into a SK novel. It is day 1 for crying in the mud. excuuuuuuuse me for not having any solid suspects that move you down the list. Me distance form Dawg? ok, I never trust Dawg and not seeing any distancing going on. There are quite a few players on you and not seeing how it comes down to me and dawg. looks like you may be safe tonite anyway so chil. I fully expect to be in the hot seat tomorrow which is ok. been there - done that.

And Z - Under the Dome was excellent. Not quite on the same level as The Stand but excellent none the less! :silly:

Now, I need to finish cleaning up the mess in the kitchen and hit the shower...........

mg: 3 for 3 SUCKS!!!

you are kinda stinky right now, but I need to reread and rethink this mess over.....GAH!

I really wish Agas would have put up some sort of defense. I had them as a suspect and am real suprised they were the detective. Not a good day one at all.

AlexW was not much of a loss, I wish he would have atleast posted a vote. I am glad he was not a power role. It would been better if he were mafia.

Speaking of mafia, I guess the hit on Kash should have been expected. More and more people fear her. She is much better evil than innocent, but there are those that are afraid of her.

Not a good day one at all. Pretty busy nightfall from day one.

You had no problem voting for Ag, blaming jpap for your vote?

Not as bad as your day is going to be.

I am guessing you have never played mafia before. You switched your lone worthless vote to another lone worthless vote at (really after) nightfall. Kind of pointless. I think you will have some explaining to do.

Good luck.

I think there is a difference between being mafia and a noobatard. Right now I am leaning towards the latter.

Like I said good luck.

I vote for Lab_Rat

Mostly for reasons stated before and the jump to blame jpap.

Why did you hit Kash?

:thud:....I must think....and sleep...........and dream of beer! :cheers:

They added the part after being too late.

I am sure they didn't know the do not edit rule.

Just post again Michwol, editing posts for any reason is not allowed. Either is posting during nightfall...jpap!

So was Kash on to something? She did not have many posts. I think she voted on Agas. I need to look to see who she was onto besides Ice.

I really can't see Ice hitting Kash again.

Lab_Rat, you missed part of my post in your quote -



So why did you hit Kash, to set up Ice?

ok, before I go for the night, I am going to go with my initial instinct and vote to lynch LabRat..............

So theres absolutely no direct interaction between them and only one post that they mutually disagreed with, although on slightly different grounds. I cannot understand why JL truly felt Noodles was a strong enough suspect to put on his list when he had be badgering almost every player except her. This only leads me to the conclusion that he just wanted to look good. We all know he's all for sacrificing teammates after all...I bet he would have been right on board to go after Noods if/when Lab came up innocent. And even though the voting changed he still needed to get a final word in on Lab.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Was it Dawg that said that Agas was hit?

Yep, here it is. I have never known dawg to be a skimmer.

Not to put words into his mouth but I think Dawg suggested that if Agass came out as detective enough people would back off so he wasn't the top lynch candidate and then could be protected from the hit.

This has all been talked about before and explained more than once. JPap is correct but since some people seem like they have not seen it yet here it is again...

Let me clarify my thinking here. I know Ag wasn't hit. But if someone role claims most of the time people would give them the benefit of the doubt so as not to make a major mistake. The doc would have to protect them from the hit because if the role was claimed and votes were backed off the mafia would surely want to hit the det.

Hope that helps JL.

I vote to lynch Dawg

I have not seen him state that he has been skimming or has been needing to catch up. Some of the statements he has made just do not make sense.

I felt at a point that either him or Lab_Rat were mafia. I have Lab_Rat leaning innocent.

No skimming required in order to misread the rules. This is the part that confused me at first..."The Snitch does not reveal his identity to anybody, not even the Don, except by me upon their death." I originally took this to mean not even the Don knew the snitch was mafia. I thought the snitch knew who the mafia was but the mafia didn't know the snitch as a team member.

I have no problems if the town wants to hang me for it but it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me that a mafia member would make the mistake that I did.

 

[RazzleFish]

DAY THREE

Razz-3- Ice(#459), Jpap(#505), Lab(#516)
Ice-0- Dawg(#482)
Lab-1- Razz(#501)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#510)
Dawg-3- JB(#552), JL(#569), DD(#571)
JB-1- Dawg(#555)
Zaffy-1- ZS(#564)

No vote from Mich

NIGHTFALL IN 5HRS 33MINS

PM'S AS REQUIRED

So I looked back at this and my lone vote isn't doing anything for the town. I still think Lab is mafia but just one vote on her isn't going to help so that being said I turn to the towns suspects. I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Dawg.

 

[IceH2O]

DAY THREE

Razz-3- Ice(#459), Jpap(#505), Lab(#516)
Ice-0- Dawg(#482)
Lab-1- Razz(#501)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#510)
Dawg-3- JB(#552), JL(#569), DD(#571)
JB-1- Dawg(#555)
Zaffy-1- ZS(#564)

No vote from Mich

NIGHTFALL IN 5HRS 33MINS

PM'S AS REQUIRED

Question to the singleton votes (Razz,Zaffy,Dawg,Z)

Who would you move to if needed?
I'm sure Dawg would move to Razz to save himself and Razz will move to Dawg.I'm pretty sure I know where Z would move so that leaves Zaffy.

Zaffy has only mentioned Z as a suspect and I'd have to go back but I think me sometime during day 2. I'd be a waste of a vote so who would you vote for if 1 votre was needed to put Razz or Dawg over the top?

 

[RazzleFish]

I already switched.

 

[IceH2O]

Ok I see Razz moved to Dawg while I was posting.

Dawg is really the lowest of my suspects but alas still a suspect. I'd really rather see JL go up against Razz though. I feel the cases against them are stronger.

 

[IceH2O]

I hit submit before I finished.

I've been thinking and been wondering if Dawg would screw up that much as a mafia player on the snitch rules.

I've lowered him as suspect because I don't think there are more then 4 mafia players.

Noods is confirmed

Razz
JL
Zaffy

They all fit the bill better IMO.