Mafia 62- The Play

[jpappy789]

Ice, why do you belive so strongly that I am mafia? Why don't you think Dawg is? I think you are the only one that doesn't have dawg on their list, why is that?

Nope, I don't have Dawg on my short list any more.

 

[jbradt]

Don't humor me, do what you feel is best. Do you think Razz is mafia then vote her,if not then vote Dawg.

I'm solidly on Razz,there isn't much of a doubt in my mind she is mafia.

This is what I'm saying... I have no clue what is best at the moment. As I read back through the thread, my best suspect always turns out to be the author of whatever post I'm reading at the moment. I have suspicions but nothing solid. I can come up with reasons to suspect everyone.

I have as much suspicion on Razz as I do on Dawg, so to me a coin toss is as good as my best guess. My gut is telling me that you are innocent, so I'm going to go with it for now and see what happens. That is what I feel is best.

 

[jpappy789]

Hey Razz, this is why you are mafia to me...

I feel like there are enough people voting for Lab to make it a "town decision" so I feel comfortable going with the rest of the townies (Hopefully) and vote to lynch Lab.

If you look back, Lab was and is at the top of my list. She has proved herself to be a very good player and may be doing it again this game.

The more of Labs posts I read the more she looks less scummy. That may just be a good player tricking me but I almost want to switch my vote........ Now who looks more scummy?
Labrat

I think are innocent, I think are mafia, I can't tell yet

Dawg - I don't see anything scummy about Dawg. They seem to be helping the town.
DD - Hasn't been around much so I cannot lean her either way as of now.
Ice - Seems very different. It may just him being tired of being killed early or it may be a way for him to keep the town from lynching a mafia player.
JB - I can't tell for sure but there is just something about him that makes me think he is a mafia player. Mostly a gut feeling
JL - Seems pro-town but with what everyone else is saying I can't decide if I should take him completly off my list of suspects.
Jpap - Very pro-town, and very helpful so far.
Labrat - The more I read what she has said the less I think she is mafia. Again, she may be pulling the wool over my eyes so I am leaning mafia but not quite. (She would be my 4th pick for mafia.)
Mich - Hasn't voted, hasn't put anything out there for us to go on and I son't know why. It worries me that he may be trying to stay off the radar with his lack of posting.
Noodles - I don't understand why people think she is mafia. Unless I missed something I don't see the case against her.
Razz - I know my role.
Rich - Again is a low poster and is only putting things out there that can't be built on.
Zaffy - Good player but I don't know their playing habits so I can't go either way.
Zsand - A good player but he just isn't sitting right with me. I can't put my finger on it but they just seem like they are playing a game from the mafia side.

HTH

JB should be red. My bad I must have missed his name when I went back and changed the colors.

I don't think she is completly innocent but the way it sounds I could see her being innocent. I didn't change my vote because she is still my strongest suspect so I don't want to change to someone I don't feel as strongly about. But then again, Ice, you seem to react rather odd to my post when I put you on the mafia team. Why is it that you look to my most trusted players over my least trusted players? Is it because you are mafia and you are trying to make it seem like I am? Why am I on your list? I posted my thoughts and now I'm evil? I may have to vote you tonight but I'll wait for your responce before I change my vote.

I don't get how I didn't see that. I just couldn't see the argument about noods...... I have to rethink my list. Also, was Rich getting to something? Why would the mafia hit him? It didn't really stop any suspicions, right? I have to look through his posts and see if he was hinting at something.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Interestingly enough...I went back to review the voting switches on Lab and Noods. I wanted to see if what JB said actually made sense about mafia piling on Noods at the end of the night. Here's what I found...

I vote for Lab_Rat

Lab-1
Noods-0

I vote to lynch Lab

Lab-2
Noods-0

vote to lynch LabRat

Lab-3
Noods-0

I retract my vote for Labby

Lab-2
Noods-0

I vote to lynch Lab

Lab-3
Noods-0

I vote to lynch Lab

Lab-4
Noods-0

I vote to lynch Labby

Lab-5
Noods-0

vote to lynch Lab

Lab-6
Noods-0

I retract my vote on jpap. I vote to lynch Noods

Lab-6
Noods-1

I vote to lynch Noods

Lab-6
Noods-2

I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Noodles

Lab-5
Noods-3

I retract my vote for Lab and vote to lynch Noods

Lab-4
Noods-4

*gasp* et tu brutus? :thud:

Above is a quote from Noods which Ceasar said when he was betrayed by his own and stabbed by Brutus. Not sure if it means anything literally but I found this interesting.

I retract my vote on Lab

Lab-3
Noods-4

I vote to lynch Noods

Lab-3
Noods-5

I vote to lynch Lab

Lab-4
Noods-5

I retract my vote on Razz and vote to lynch Noodles

Lab-4
Noods-6

I'm stil doubting that mafia piled on at the end with Noods. Even a tie would have been better for the mafia than taking her out. What I do find interesting is that Z seems to be following Ice around like a little corgi. Maybe Z, Ice, Noods...I have no idea but with the et tu brutus quote Z definitely peaked my interests. Since I really don't have any other choice right now...

I retract my vote for JB and vote to lynch Razz

 

[IceH2O]

Ice, why do you belive so strongly that I am mafia? Why don't you think Dawg is? I think you are the only one that doesn't have dawg on their list, why is that?

Dawgs on my list but he dropped pretty low down.

You are for sure mafia, your list and then your insistence that Lab is mafia.

The cases pulled up on JL and I already suspected him.

Zaffys lack of suspects and genuine hiding out in the game.

Then Dawg..and I'm not even wholeheartedly on that.

I kind of used Dawg hoping he was innocent. He was the only one really questioning me about things.I didn't twist words but I kept pressure on him to make an easy target of him. If he cracked and ended up mafia then good for us, if he is innocent then mafia would move to him to save their own. . I thought Razz would get the votes and Dawg had a safety zone I could work with. I just think innocents got caught up in it and so I'm speaking out before its to late. I could be wrong and Dawg could be mafia and you guys are sacrificing him but I am more sure Razz is mafia. I also think Zaffy is a single vote that was to be moved last minute if needed to lynch Dawg.

JL and Razz are on Dawg.

 

[jbradt]

Interestingly enough...I went back to review the voting switches on Lab and Noods. I wanted to see if what JB said actually made sense about mafia piling on Noods at the end of the night. Here's what I found...


Lab-1
Noods-0


Lab-2
Noods-0


Lab-3
Noods-0


Lab-2
Noods-0


Lab-3
Noods-0


Lab-4
Noods-0


Lab-5
Noods-0


Lab-6
Noods-0


Lab-6
Noods-1


Lab-6
Noods-2


Lab-5
Noods-3


Lab-4
Noods-4

Above is a quote from Noods which Ceasar said when he was betrayed by his own and stabbed by Brutus. Not sure if it means anything literally but I found this interesting.


Lab-3
Noods-4


Lab-3
Noods-5


Lab-4
Noods-5


Lab-4
Noods-6

I'm stil doubting that mafia piled on at the end with Noods. Even a tie would have been better for the mafia than taking her out. What I do find interesting is that Z seems to be following Ice around like a little corgi. Maybe Z, Ice, Noods...I have no idea but with the et tu brutus quote Z definitely peaked my interests. Since I really don't have any other choice right now...

I retract my vote for JB and vote to lynch Razz

I noticed the et tu brute comment when it was posted. It gave me that same little tickle I got last game from Labby's avatar and response to the suspense joke. Hmmmm....

 

[jpappy789]

I wouldnt think that Noods would give something away like that. I bet she was trying to use the quote saying she was betrayed by townies to portray herself as innocent. No way mafia would openly state that they are being betrayed by a teammate.

 

[jbradt]

I wouldnt think that Noods would give something away like that. I bet she was trying to use the quote saying she was betrayed by townies to portray herself as innocent. No way mafia would openly state that they are being betrayed by a teammate.

That thought is why I didn't comment earlier.

 

[IceH2O]

I wouldnt think that Noods would give something away like that. I bet she was trying to use the quote saying she was betrayed by townies to portray herself as innocent. No way mafia would openly state that they are being betrayed by a teammate.

That thought is why I didn't comment earlier.

That was my thought at the time also.

 

[jbradt]

Since I really don't have any other choice right now...

I retract my vote for JB and vote to lynch Razz

I don't understand this, Dawg. There is a choice, you can vote for whomever you like. You seemed pretty conviced that I'm scum a few hours ago. In fact, you thanked me for making your job so easy. Why the switch? Why the "I don't have any other choice"?