Mafia 62- The Play

[RazzleFish]

Yay, I fixed it! Zaffy, once this game is over, I forgive you! But until then.........................

 

[Lab_Rat]

Thanks for pulling those posts Ice, it confirms what I was thinking. I went back and got that vote too.

1 - Jpap - Labrat(231)
6 - Labrat - JL(243), Jpap(252), Noodles(257), Ice(310), Zsand(322), Noodles(327), Razz(330)
1 - Ice - Dawg(320)

No votes from: Zaffy, DD, Mich, Rich, JB

I think this is accurate.

At this point, it's a landslide vote on me. Zaffy has yet to vote.

I vote to lynch Zsandmann

Pulling your posts is hard, you haven't said anything of substance yet. I just get an overall sense that you're not probing for scum at all. You're throwing other peoples arguments out there and making it look like you're helping the town, but you're really not.



It's easy to hide in a landslide, but you gotta give a reason. You were the 3rd vote, which is a strong vote on day 1 I might add.


It's a reason, but it's a go with the flow status quo reason.

Yes, Ag was leading most of the night, partly due to your vote (#3) on him.

Naw, you're scum. You'll just have to hit me tonight so I don't link you with her. It's a tough life.

So Zaffy, you said you suspected Noods. Your whole tinfoil theory centers on Noods and SK. That is your excuse later for voting Zs. Because he said something about a SK book. Where you totally lose me is the fact that Noods has zero votes. Why did you vote Zs over Noods? She is the center of the tinfoil conspiracy. Neither had a single vote.

Did you notice since last night that I've totally abandoned that supposed "shield". I'm drinking the water now.

She was already lynched, there was no need for me to change my vote.

Actually I didn't want to break the tie. I had no significant thoughts of either Dawg nor razz at the time.

Tie me with Michwol tomorrow night. Compare our voting records head to head.

You've abandon your shield because it has many gaping holes. Noods was not "already lynched" until the last minute. I honestly thought I was going to come back to myself being lynched. It was quite the surprise that I wasn't. With a vote of 6 for Noods and 4 for me, your lone vote switched onto me would not have saved your mafia scum friend.

See Zaffy, I think you created your tinfoil conspiracy to give a reason as to why you didn't vote Noods and voted Zs instead. Throwing Noods name around was distancing, so you could come back later and say "see, I suspected her". Too bad the timing does not support what you say.

I don't think a tie with Michwol is in the town's best interest. Now a tie between you and Razz should be productive, one way or another.

g/o Happy Birthday! g/o

 

[Zaffy]

Can't quote your post, so here it is.

#427 by Zaffy

Quote:
Richs vote makes me wonder if you're on to something. If noodles is scum, then it looks like rich is trying to get her off the hook even though he's got such sound reasoning.

Why didn't you follow up on this? You keep naming off suspects but rarely follow up on anything.

I didn't follow up, because you guys hit him that night. So why follow up and claim he's scum?

#746 by Zaffy

Quote:
Jpap
Quote:
- voting behavior.
Lab - voting behavior
DD - for not voting Razz right now.
Michwol42795 - Post more!
Ice - Apparently clean now.
Dawg - Scum stacked against him.
ZSandman - cleared on voting behavior, mostly.
JB - Has had lots to say, I want to read it again, my gut says nice guy.
Razz - Scummy McScumscum
Zaffy - included for a complete list. Innocent!

I can't understand why I got it for saying I thought people were innocent and you didn't. This may be OMGUSy but how can you be sure of so many people's roles? You have DD, Mich, JB and half of Zs on your list with me leading it..... Are you waiting for one of them to come back mafia so you can say "I knew it!" later on? Distanceing are we?

Distancing on day 4, with a suspect list like this? really? Am I that bad at this game? You got in trouble because you did it way early in the game, with no reasons to back it up. My posts immediately prior to the one you quoted outlined a general posting pattern that I noticed. This list is directly from that outline.


Wow, this formatting is a mess, hopefully it's readable.

 

[Lab_Rat]

DAY TWO

Jpap-0- Lab(#231)
Lab-4- JL(#243), Jpap(#252), Noods(#257), Ice(#310), ZS(#322), Noods(#327), Razz(#330), Rich(#422)
Ice-2- Dawg(#320), Mich(#392)
ZS-1- Zaffy(#350)
Noods-6- Lab(#365), JB(#369), Ice(#400), ZS(#408), DD(#414), Jpap(#426)
Razz-0- Jpap(#421)

I find this vote very distinguishing for scum vs. townie. I really don't think there can be a good case for anyone who voted for Noods to be scum. All they had to do was jump to me to tie things up and give their teammate a 50/50 chance. Note that Zaffy jumping to me would not have saved Noods. Neither would a jump from Michwol. I think if both Zaffy and Michwol were scum they would have coordinated a dual jump last minute to tie it up. So I'm thinking it's one or the other, which kind of eliminates my suspicions of all 3 (Razz, Zaffy, and Michwol) being mafia.

I'm really thinking, with all the tears in Zaffy's tinfoil, he is scum. Razz I don't doubt is scum.

 

[Michwol42795]

I vote to lynch Zaffy

His off the wall conspiracies and always changing behavior puts him ahead of Razz. He's gone from pointing fingers at everyone else, being aggressive, and making conspiracies to this

You should vote for me then.


Feed me to the sharks please.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Looks like we've got our tie.

Michwol, could you please give a spectrum of your suspects, from most scummy to most innocent? I'm wanting to see your thoughts on the rest of the field.

 

[Zaffy]

Thanks for pulling those posts Ice, it confirms what I was thinking. I went back and got that vote too.




At this point, it's a landslide vote on me. Zaffy has yet to vote.


So Zaffy, you said you suspected Noods. Your whole tinfoil theory centers on Noods and SK. That is your excuse later for voting Zs. Because he said something about a SK book. Where you totally lose me is the fact that Noods has zero votes. Why did you vote Zs over Noods? She is the center of the tinfoil conspiracy. Neither had a single vote.


You've abandon your shield because it has many gaping holes. Noods was not "already lynched" until the last minute. I honestly thought I was going to come back to myself being lynched. It was quite the surprise that I wasn't. With a vote of 6 for Noods and 4 for me, your lone vote switched onto me would not have saved your mafia scum friend.

See Zaffy, I think you created your tinfoil conspiracy to give a reason as to why you didn't vote Noods and voted Zs instead. Throwing Noods name around was distancing, so you could come back later and say "see, I suspected her". Too bad the timing does not support what you say.

I don't think a tie with Michwol is in the town's best interest. Now a tie between you and Razz should be productive, one way or another.

g/o Happy Birthday! g/o

I actually voted Zs Before I announced my crackpot tinfoil theory. Post #350. I made my theory public in post 510, the next day. My first vote on him was for a weak reason, but not because I thought annie put something in the water. I was still deciding if my crackpot theory meant that the bookclub was scum or not.

But my tinfoil reason was a terrible reason. And it's shown to be wrong. She was lynched without my help at all. I was going

Thanks, I'm going out for Sushi tonight!

 

[Zaffy]

DAY FOUR

Razz-4- Ice(#684), Jpap(#685), Zaffy(#739), Lab(#756)
Zaffy-2- ZS(#691), DD(#728)

No vote from Mich or Razz

AFTER WEDNESDAY, WE WILL SWITCH TO 24 HOUR DAYS.

NIGHTFALL IN 25 HOURS

PM'S AS REQUIRED

So, when Razz and Mich put their votes in, you get your tie.

...

All I have to say here is that I am a guy!
After that I vote to lynch Zaffy.

...

I vote to lynch Zaffy

His off the wall conspiracies and always changing behavior puts him ahead of Razz. He's gone from pointing fingers at everyone else, being aggressive, and making conspiracies to this

You should vote for me then.


Feed me to the sharks please.

I must have ESPN or something.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I voted Jpap because I thought that he had trapped Ag.
I voted Zsand because I thought my tinfoil conspiracy was plausible enough to go with.
I voted Zsand again because I had no more information to go on. I didn't change my vote late in the day because it was a tie and I was in no position to break that tie.
I voted Razz today because I think she's scum because of her voting record.
I'll vote Mich tomorrow because of his voting record, unless new information comes up that clears him.

I actually voted Zs Before I announced my crackpot tinfoil theory. Post #350. I made my theory public in post 510, the next day. My first vote on him was for a weak reason, but not because I thought annie put something in the water. I was still deciding if my crackpot theory meant that the bookclub was scum or not.

But my tinfoil reason was a terrible reason. And it's shown to be wrong. She was lynched without my help at all. I was going

Thanks, I'm going out for Sushi tonight!

Ouch Zaffy, I think you just jumped into the shark tank with that blatant contradiction of why you voted for Zs on night 2.

Sushi is delicious, enjoy...just don't let your fish know!

 

[Zaffy]

Ouch Zaffy, I think you just jumped into the shark tank with that blatant contradiction of why you voted for Zs on night 2.

Sushi is delicious, enjoy...just don't let your fish know!

reread that, where exactly is this contradiction?