mafia 63- Who is Who

[Fishfriend1]

wow hard to get caught up with all the posting. If I read everything right, we have jl claiming to be the police,and annie also claiming the same role. Obviously one of them is lying. But who knows for sure which? Jl makes a good argument to not lynch either until the mayor can investigate. As has been posted before, if we lynch the wrong one, then we lose the police.

This makes a lot of sense.

At the same time I see a lot of argument to not lynch ff just because he is a newb. I have stated before to ff directly that he has posted a lot and not posted anything helpful or useful.

By his own posts he states his strategy was to spread confusion so no one would know which side he was on. Isn't that kind of scummy in itself? Isn't that like spreading confusion? Isn't that something mafia would try to do?

I vote to lynch ff

Thats because i havent posted DAY2 only notes yet. Here they come

DAY 2

Well now im gonna be voted off so I will need to make sure my team wins. *Sigh* All I did was be myself. I guess that teaches me to never tell the truth again. I would be soo cool if I was the mayor because then I could say “I told u so ha ha ha” *sigh* ……(already posted, got no comments)

This claim of policeman by John and anie is suspicions. One of them must be lying. I think the johns the lier because he wanted me dead so soon so he must think im a threat despite all his “well ff1 cant be the mayor hes just o noob” if im a noob then why are you trying to kill me? I light of this im gonna vote to lynch him.

Jpap is looking like he may be an ally or at least neutral or maybe he is hiding something…

Im not the mayor... OR AM I? You can never be sure. The best way for the don to win would be to distract everybody and slowly have them vote innocents off. If the Leaders are out there you may want to look into me, I could be anyone.

Razzle thinks he can outsmart ME well hes got another guess coming lol. As for him being the don not so sure, but there is always the chance.
Ive got to have everyone confused lol. I mean I confused myself ha ha ha…

Kashta is an *** hole. I really want to just kick her ***. O well. Anyway I was about to give up and vote for myself but the song I was listening to had an inspiring line “Never give up, never give in” and another one “willing now to pay the price, just name the game, we are heros of a new world, we never die.” Very inspiring.

I left quite an angry rant about a comment when I asked Kashta a simple question and she was to stupid to even lie about it to get me to screw up. What a dumb ***.

 

[Fishfriend1]

wow hard to get caught up with all the posting. If I read everything right, we have jl claiming to be the police,and annie also claiming the same role. Obviously one of them is lying. But who knows for sure which? Jl makes a good argument to not lynch either until the mayor can investigate. As has been posted before, if we lynch the wrong one, then we lose the police.

This makes a lot of sense.

At the same time I see a lot of argument to not lynch ff just because he is a newb. I have stated before to ff directly that he has posted a lot and not posted anything helpful or useful.

By his own posts he states his strategy was to spread confusion so no one would know which side he was on. Isn't that kind of scummy in itself? Isn't that like spreading confusion? Isn't that something mafia would try to do?

I vote to lynch ff

The first one :headshake2: is stupid bacause even if the mayor investagates the right one we will not know who he is.
The second one is my way of trying to confuse the mafia into not voteing for me. If u think its scumy then my plan is working, cause your very confused.:evil_lol:

 

[IceH2O]

Fish

This is a friendly game. If you're not mature enough to keep it civil and need to resort to name calling you can just quit. If I see 1 more post against someone that I find offensive I will ban you from the game.

May I ask how old you are? I'm guessing under 12.

 

[Fishfriend1]

oh sorry i forgot to edit my thought and notes oops. Wont happen again. Sorry Kashta, Sorry anyone who i insulted just forgot to edit.

 

[Fishfriend1]

can anyone delete the first DAY2 notes plz? Ill put the edited ones up in a few minutes.

 

[Fishfriend1]

(talking to myself)
This sucks.
What?
Ive insulted everyone and they all left.
Sad
I know.
Your probably gonna be voted off.
Duh.
Now youve insulted me too.
Sorry.
>.<
...

 

[AnniesNotOK]

(talking to myself)
This sucks.
What?
Ive insulted everyone and they all left.
Sad
I know.
Your probably gonna be voted off.
Duh.
Now youve insulted me too.
Sorry.
>.<
...

I have begun to revisit my thoery that you are an innocent, confused, and slightly touched noobtard.

I now am leaning towards the theory you may be a disjointed mafium.

Perhaps with no team to guide you along, you assumed it was your job to create confusion and fill the thread with useless fluff to make it more difficult for the rest of us to find clues.

How old are you FF?

 

[Fishfriend1]

why does everyone want to know? Anyway im 16 years old and not the worlds greatest strategist. Not that im not good a strategy but well yea... That post was me being stupid and making a lousy joke.

 

[Fishfriend1]

I have begun to revisit my thoery that you are an innocent, confused, and slightly touched noobtard.

I now am leaning towards the theory you may be a disjointed mafium.

Perhaps with no team to guide you along, you assumed it was your job to create confusion and fill the thread with useless fluff to make it more difficult for the rest of us to find clues.

How old are you FF?

Why are so many people trying to have me vote off? If im really such a newb then i shouldn't be a threat right? If u think that trying to have me voted off will help then you must be mafia. Im glade im voting for you.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Lab's conspiracy is bothering me because it really banks on the fact that both JL and Annie are putting forth a coordinated plan which has to take into account the fact that 1) both are scum 2) both were investigated by the Don and 3) that the real policeman is sitting back and letting this all take place.

Finally, some feedback! Thanks jpap, I've been trying to poke holes in my theory all night, but everything had an explanation for why it worked.

As to #1 and #2: yes, it hinges on that they are both mafia, and not only mafia, but I'm sure Annie is the don simply from JL's behavior. If someone could explain JL's behavior any other way, PLEASE do so! Why would someone RCing policeman even hesitate to lynch someone counterclaiming it? If you know your role, like I assume JL does, why wouldn't you take out the lying party? The only feasible explanation was that JL has a lot to lose from taking out Annie...Annie has a lot to gain from taking out JL. If Annie were regular mafia scum, not the don, the situation would not make sense. So I agree with you there. This means only one investigation would have been required to be successful. There have been two (one pre-nightfall, and one after night 1).

As to #3: When I was formulating the theory, turning it from every angle, I thought the same thing at first. But then I realized that I wouldn't RC if I were the policeman in the middle of this mess. Why? Because I would not want to throw myself into the mess and possibly get my policeman self lynched. I guess someone else would take a different approach, but the real policeman, knowing there is a real possibility one of the two that has falsely RCed will get lynched, would be doing the town a favor to let these two with some ulterior motive get themselves lynched. That's kind of a mess, so simplified, if you know your role, which is so important to the town, is being claimed by two liars, why would you throw your name in the ring with them? I think it would be foolish and detrimental for the real policeman to step up at this time.

I think your counter-conspiracy theory is interesting and I'm truly flattered that you think I could come up with something like that. If I didn't know my role then I could see where that could be entertained as a possibility. But it doesn't explain JL's behavior and why he refuses to vote for Annie when he's 100% sure Annie is lying scum.

Can someone please explain JL being 100% certain Annie is a scummy liar yet he 100% refuses to lynch him to me??? Like I said, the only plausible explanation is JL working with Annie to clear Annie's name.