Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

Final Votes Day 2

Lab (6) - Ice (566) Wiz (779) Kashta (804) JB (807) DD (809) DD (817) Rich (867)
JB (5) - Lab (567) Annie (740) Rich (801) Mad (848) Noods (849) Dag (856)
Dag (1) - JL (680) DD (811)
Ice (1) - Mad (730)
Annie (1) - JPap (780)
JL (1) - Noods (789)

No votes: Tank

Now we know that Annie was mafia and that Lab was in fact communitcating innocent. We also know that it was only because of Tank's non-vote that it was a coin toss, Rich's late vote should have lynched Lab.

I vote to lynch rich

The late switch proves one thing, he was not trying to save Lab, so there is no way he is CI.


 
Also could be exactly what I told you. Having nothing to do with saving anyone. Just finding that I did not like my vote and decide to change it. That wont work in your world though. There must be a conspiracy.

Only regret I have about my switch is that you all are wasting time on me and letting the bad guys get away. Of course for you, I am a convenient place to play, with out having to expose yourself.

WTF Rich? You're a veteran player who keeps contradicting himself by the statements you make.

By the reason you gave for your vote to lynch FF, you didn't care which team he was on. He annoyed you and you said you just wanted him gone. You had NO regard for either team if that was true.

By the reason you gave for your late switch from JB to Lab, you contradicted the player list rundown you just had posted earlier that day. You said your reason was you didn't like the way she whined about being innocent. Again... if this was true, you intended to seal the fate on her death with NO regard for which side she was on.

If we believe your statements, then your claims for both these decisions indicate a player who is not pro-mafia or pro-town... but more anti-game than anything else.

If we disregard your statements and look only at your actions, we would naturally interpret those as scummy and vote you off the next nightfall. You're not a noob here. You knew your late vote switch would draw everyone's suspicion toward you before you made the change.

You're either just being a grouch about this game or you're actively working against the town without admitting it.... you can't be doing both at the same time.

How by any stretch of imagination now could you believe we're going to accept a statement from you that you regret we're wasting time on you and letting the bad guys get away?
 
Just checking/reading real quick while I have a moment at work and this kinda stuck out.......

WTF Rich? You're a veteran player who keeps contradicting himself by the statements you make.

By the reason you gave for your vote to lynch FF, you didn't care which team he was on. He annoyed you and you said you just wanted him gone. You had NO regard for either team if that was true.

By the reason you gave for your late switch from JB to Lab, you contradicted the player list rundown you just had posted earlier that day. You said your reason was you didn't like the way she whined about being innocent. Again... if this was true, you intended to seal the fate on her death with NO regard for which side she was on.

If we believe your statements, then your claims for both these decisions indicate a player who is not pro-mafia or pro-town... but more anti-game than anything else.

If we disregard your statements and look only at your actions, we would naturally interpret those as scummy and vote you off the next nightfall. You're not a noob here. You knew your late vote switch would draw everyone's suspicion toward you before you made the change.

You're either just being a grouch about this game or you're actively working against the town without admitting it.... you can't be doing both at the same time.

How by any stretch of imagination now could you believe we're going to accept a statement from you that you regret we're wasting time on you and letting the bad guys get away?


hhhhhmmmm, think about that for a minute........:eek:
 
I already have, Noodles.
 
WTF Rich? You're a veteran player who keeps contradicting himself by the statements you make.

By the reason you gave for your vote to lynch FF, you didn't care which team he was on. He annoyed you and you said you just wanted him gone. You had NO regard for either team if that was true.

By the reason you gave for your late switch from JB to Lab, you contradicted the player list rundown you just had posted earlier that day. You said your reason was you didn't like the way she whined about being innocent. Again... if this was true, you intended to seal the fate on her death with NO regard for which side she was on.

If we believe your statements, then your claims for both these decisions indicate a player who is not pro-mafia or pro-town... but more anti-game than anything else.

If we disregard your statements and look only at your actions, we would naturally interpret those as scummy and vote you off the next nightfall. You're not a noob here. You knew your late vote switch would draw everyone's suspicion toward you before you made the change.

You're either just being a grouch about this game or you're actively working against the town without admitting it.... you can't be doing both at the same time.

How by any stretch of imagination now could you believe we're going to accept a statement from you that you regret we're wasting time on you and letting the bad guys get away?

Good points, very well written and thought out. I did say several times i believe that JB acted more like a townie than LR by the way he handled his possible lynch. Was that not clear?
 
Rich, who do you suspect?

Since I doubt anyone would have investigated LR since she was in trouble both days. It makes it harder to figure since the main pushers for her lynch could have been on either side I imagine they were.

Since you are not allowed to think like you want around here I have been busy today explaining a simple concept. Gosh forbid you do not do what you are supposed to.
 
AquariaCentral.com