Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[IceH2O]

Because she didn't want her vote on anyone up for the day 1 lynch. What's our record for lynching innocent vs. lynching scum on day 1? At the time of her move I was not a lynch contender, thus it was a safe vote. I guess she could have moved onto one of her scum buddies, but she didn't.

But what better place to hide then in a 3 way tie versus moving and letting it be a 2 way tie? It was Day 1 and how many would have really argued that Noods vote on me was any more important then yours?

 

[noodles62]

this post make no sense...

consider the facts

1) the chance of picking an innocent are greater than a scum (or for the scum invest a PR)

2) why would a PR especially push for a lynch unless there was a lot of evidence out there for them being scum? at that point it wouldnt be hard for the town to notice it either. they would likely catch flack for pushing w/o any backing.

LG: I believe the mod said at one point that the psychic chose last night and from no

well, true now I think more about it - the invest results could have back back as a bust...........guess I was wishful thinking for some good results......

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

I'm going to disagree with this train of thought. I don't think it means as much as you guys think.
If I had asked everyone who they would have hit last night how would you respond?
If I was mafia I would have hit someone like ILM to help FF with investigations. Does that mean I know ILM is innocent and I'm automatically scum? No, just means I'm smarter then the current mafia players.

Still not convinced Lab is innocent but I don't think the statement means as much as its being made out to be.

then the difference would be in how it was delivered:

Lab was speculating about dawg being a pr and going for it if she were scum.

then there is also the difference is why is was delivered:

she was using it as a defence, not simply as a "what if" thing

 

[noodles62]

well, true now I think more about it - the invest results could have back back as a bust...........guess I was wishful thinking for some good results......

oops! should say "could have COME back"...........

 

[noodles62]

g/o well, I gotta shut this baby down for now - the fan is protesting loudly.....hope to have it repaired next week..............g/o

 

[IceH2O]

If you asked me who I would have hit last night I would have said Annie because I thought he was scum. If you wanted me to out who I thought was innocent in order to help the scum figure it out...I wouldn't have speculated or answered. It's not pro town IMO.

then the difference would be in how it was delivered:

Lab was speculating about dawg being a pr and going for it if she were scum.

then there is also the difference is why is was delivered:

she was using it as a defence, not simply as a "what if" thing

I got it. The wording and delivery is suspect.

Lot of that going on with Lab the past 2 days huh....Now I'm thinking yesterdays post was a slipup after all.

 

[Lady G]

I'm going to disagree with this train of thought. I don't think it means as much as you guys think.
If I had asked everyone who they would have hit last night how would you respond?
If I was mafia I would have hit someone like ILM to help FF with investigations. Does that mean I know ILM is innocent and I'm automatically scum? No, just means I'm smarter then the current mafia players.

Still not convinced Lab is innocent but I don't think the statement means as much as its being made out to be.

BUT, no one asked...she just put it out there herself, THEN of course it was asked as to why him, to which her response was because she was thinking him a PR. BIG difference IMO. IF someone had actually asked maybe I would see it differently. Although personally if I was asked I would just of said I didn't know who I would of picked.

this post make no sense...

consider the facts

1) the chance of picking an innocent are greater than a scum (or for the scum invest a PR)

2) why would a PR especially push for a lynch unless there was a lot of evidence out there for them being scum? at that point it wouldnt be hard for the town to notice it either. they would likely catch flack for pushing w/o any backing.

LG: I believe the mod said at one point that the psychic chose last night and from no

was that suppose to finish with "now the spirits pick" or something on those lines? LMAO

 

[Lab_Rat]

I thought it was quoted enough times that I didn't need to post it again. Well here it is in case you missed it Lab...



Why are you speculating about innocents? How would you know I'm innocent and therefore a good hit for the scum?

I'm not speculating about innocents, I'm speculating about who I think is scum. If I were scum I wouldn't have to speculate about innocents in the thread, because afik, scum can communicate with each other off site and everyone who is not communicating on day 1 is innocent.

See, my problem here is...you say you THINK he is scum OR PR, yes you add you lean him way more scum, but if you think there is a chance he is a PR why, why, why mention it if you are not evil?

If I were evil I would never have brought it up in the thread, I would have brought it up in the scum den chat.

But what better place to hide then in a 3 way tie versus moving and letting it be a 2 way tie? It was Day 1 and how many would have really argued that Noods vote on me was any more important then yours?

Idk why she got nervous and switched her vote. Suddenly she didn't find you as scummy so she moved, and she's claiming it was a pro-town move. Iirc, she claimed her move was much more pro-town than staying on someone she no longer thought was scummy.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

ooops yeah something along the lines of "now on the spirits pick" lol hit submit too soon

 

[Lab_Rat]

then the difference would be in how it was delivered:

Lab was speculating about dawg being a pr and going for it if she were scum.

then there is also the difference is why is was delivered:

she was using it as a defence, not simply as a "what if" thing

Huh? Noods said she could see me putting a hit on Kash. I said that Kash would not be my choice of a hit if I were scum. I don't know what the heck you're saying Mael. It's not a defense, it was simply a response to the hypothesis Noods put out there.