Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[johnlarson66]

Dawg, explian this -

If you asked me who I would have hit last night I would have said Annie because I thought he was scum. If you wanted me to out who I thought was innocent in order to help the scum figure it out...I wouldn't have speculated or answered. It's not pro town IMO.

You would have hit anne because you thought he was scum? The scum have the hits, of course they would hit an innocent. A scum would keep a scummy looking innocent around.

So are you voting annie to be lynched?

I also think there is nothing wrong with stating who you have leaning evil or leaning innocent. I have not known you to have a problem with that before either.

How would telling who you thought was innocent help the scum? How is it not pro-town?

 

[Lab_Rat]

You guys can't be putting names out there and saying they should be investigated, a list of names yes but not a single name. All that does is give the scum a hit target and a wasted investigation. I'm pretture they look at our suspect list of who they think they can trust and make their choices from that.

Now Lab maybe you can stop posting defenses and give us a suspect list and why....

My bad. I've been too busy defending myself from constant attacks to focus like I should on what's been posted the past day. I need to re-read from the beginning. I also need to walk my dog. So I will post my thoughts once I walk my dog and get a chance to re-read the thread. Good enough for you?

 

[IceH2O]

My thought is she moved off of someone who was at risk to be lynched onto someone who was not. If she truly didn't think he was scum then yeah, but why the last minute move? The timing is what stuck out most to me.

You need to go back and read prenight fall from 6:30 on....Most of us thought 7 EST was night. At that time Noods was on me, it wasn't till we all realized it wasn't till 8 that she moved.

 

[dirtydawg10]

My thought is she moved off of someone who was at risk to be lynched onto someone who was not. If she truly didn't think he was scum then yeah, but why the last minute move? The timing is what stuck out most to me.

So by your post I take it you don't want to answer my question?? I thought it was a reasonable question.

 

[Lady G]

Looks like I have made some new friends. CCM and Wiz seem to have me high on their lists.

Wiz has claimed I did not answer Kash's questions, but I think I answered them earlier in the day, then an hour before nightfall she posts 14 questions for me. I answered what I could.

Wiz also jumped on board with my response to LG about my actions. I think LG's response was that I did something to FF. Really, I do not think I gave FF a lot of pressure nor did I really ride him much. His bad for the both of us comment made no sense and FF should be past that by now. I also thought the arguement placed by Ice that FF would do a bad job at picking investigations was highly suspect. I felt Ice was protecting the FF, who could have been the prime evil.

I don't mind people having me leaning evil. I never have. I do mind people trying to make a case out of nothing. CCM is trying to say I have backed off, what is he even talking about, the guy is a part time poster as it is and mostly post dribble. Wiz seems to be on me hot and heavy. I can't recall, but I think both of these guys had me as top suspects on day one.

Wiz has a question for me to answer -



Is that your big question? Really?

I would not have hit Kash. Period. Even if she was hot on me. Most people don't trust her either, so who really listens to her? I also would not have hit her because she is a great suspect. Plus with this new twist where the dead innocents get to talk and help, I would have not wanted her in that group. I would have hit a low poster or player who I felt would not contribute much in the afterlife. I do not think I side stepped or avoided Kash's questions.

WOW, you are here!

I responded to Noods accusation that I was the one who put the hit on Kash. If I could take it back I would, but I can't. It's out there, I think Dawg is scum. Maybe the dead spirits would be kind enough to investigate him...

My thought is she moved off of someone who was at risk to be lynched onto someone who was not. If she truly didn't think he was scum then yeah, but why the last minute move? The timing is what stuck out most to me.

Which brings another "I don't get it" IF she were scum, staying on a three way would of been the perfect place to be. Last minute, it's kinda hard to move your vote if your not on, she came on, she changed her mind, she changed her vote, from what I saw.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

ok Lab, you just keep ignoring the fact that you used it as a defesnce...

 

[johnlarson66]

How about the repeated sidestepping of questions. I've asked numerous times what he thought of Labs pre nightfall post, no answer.

I'd also like to know from JL what he thinks of JRRs posts and hit and run posts?

Ice, I have not answered your questions about Lab, this is true. I can say that I did not read into it the same way you read into it. I think the switch by noods was suspect and I was suprised by the late run on Lab. I am not sure why you were asking me and another player at the same time (maybe JRR), but not asking all the players. It seemed to me like you were trying to drag me into something. I choose not to get dragged in.

As far as JRR hit and run posts, I have not really put much weight into them. Just as rich and annie, just to name a few.

 

[Lady G]

I responded to Noods accusation that I was the one who put the hit on Kash. If I could take it back I would, but I can't. It's out there, I think Dawg is scum. Maybe the dead spirits would be kind enough to investigate him...

Wow, now you are saying who the spirits should investigate. Lets just put a red X on ppl for the evil to pick. Lab, I think you need some sleep you are digging yourself deeper and deeper.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg, explian this -



You would have hit anne because you thought he was scum? The scum have the hits, of course they would hit an innocent. A scum would keep a scummy looking innocent around.

So are you voting annie to be lynched?

I also think there is nothing wrong with stating who you have leaning evil or leaning innocent. I have not known you to have a problem with that before either.

How would telling who you thought was innocent help the scum? How is it not pro-town?

I was making a point about why an innocent would speculate who they would hit if they were scum. IMO they wouldn't. Naming ONE person you would intend to hit and several people you LEAN innocent are two totally different things.

No I am not voting Annie and I have explained already why I'm not.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

the way i see it the only reason noods would have pulled off ice and make it a two way tie was for them to both be scum and then it would be between two innocents...there's no reason she would 1) draw attention 2) not stay fit in with all the votes in the tie. Maybe Im just being narrow minded here but it makes no sense for lab to push the opposite