Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

Sorry grammer king, I guess keeped it not a word - lets try kept. I kept my vote on FF. That is not muddled, my non-counting confused friend, it is typo while watching TV. Next you are going to say gooder is not a word.

You are wrong, gooder comes right before goodest in my dictionary.

 

[johnlarson66]

Back to being the politician I see.

Read the post. You yourself stated that you didn't see any reason to move your vote.

Are you reading or skimming?

Out of all the events of D1, I really find it hard to believe that you didn't see anything scummier than FF.

I thought FF was the best vote and I thought Ice's claim that FF would be bad for the town to be part of the investigation was scummy.

I saw no reason to move my vote. I would have been okay with either Ice or FF being lynched.

So what did you see?

 

[johnlarson66]

I was just throwing a thought out there. I suck when I don't have a communicating team cuz I put my thoughts out there way too frequently. You are right, I need sleep. Fortunately I will get to sleep in tomorrow (if you can call 6am sleeping in) since I will be teaching immunizations all day so I should have a couple free hours throughout the day to really read up on the thread.

Ice, I will post my revised list of suspects tomorrow, after I've had a good bit of sleep and more time to think.

Lab, this post smells like evil to me. Lines like "I suck when I don't have a communicating team cuz I put my thoughts out there way too frequently." sound just like FF.

 

[the wizard]

I thought FF was the best vote and I thought Ice's claim that FF would be bad for the town to be part of the investigation was scummy.

I saw no reason to move my vote. I would have been okay with either Ice or FF being lynched.

So what did you see?

I saw FF being FF. I saw you keeping it going . I saw you getting people to look to FF and Ice.

I saw you state you didn't care which one was lynched.

Which brings up another point i need to ask.

I dont have the post handy but you said you were glad FF was gone for the good of the town.

I have a hard time understanding how an innocent being lynched is good for the town.

How many more innocents are you willing to lynch for our good?

 

[johnlarson66]

I saw FF being FF. I saw you keeping it going . I saw you getting people to look to FF and Ice.

I saw you state you didn't care which one was lynched.

Which brings up another point i need to ask.

I dont have the post handy but you said you were glad FF was gone for the good of the town.

I have a hard time understanding how an innocent being lynched is good for the town.

How many more innocents are you willing to lynch for our good?

So beside me, what scumminess did you see.

As far as how many more innocents am I willing to lynch? As many as it takes to rid the town of evil. There is a saying, you have to break a few eggs to bake a cake.

Do you really think the town won't lynch a few innocents? That is how the town learns.

I think you had some sort of master list, who were those?

Again, besides me (and not including the noods/lab late night action) what scumminess do you see?

 

[the wizard]

So beside me, what scumminess did you see.

As far as how many more innocents am I willing to lynch? As many as it takes to rid the town of evil. There is a saying, you have to break a few eggs to bake a cake.

Do you really think the town won't lynch a few innocents? That is how the town learns.

I think you had some sort of master list, who were those?

Again, besides me (and not including the noods/lab late night action) what scumminess do you see?

I am FF's daddy not yours. (your own thoughts).

Do your own homework. I posted my suspect list after I got home from work. read the thread.

 

[johnlarson66]

I was looking at the vote tallies, here CCM moves off of FF and puts a lone vote on me -

OK I have a few quick thoughts (may have been logged on ac earlier, but I've been running around all day).

As I said early on, I still think JL is pretty scummy, and FF is not looking as scummy. To me rereading his early posts with FF it still looks to me like he is just working FF up to make him ramble and look bad. I'll admit it worked. I don't think FF is an innocent, but that is more a a general feeling from his posting than from any real quotes I can get from his posts.

I'm not sure what to think of ILM not posting. I get the impression he is going to vote at the last second to lynch someone. If that's what he does, that'll look very scummy to me. Like he would be told who to vote for (just a thought on the way things look so far, and my theory as to why he's not saying much).

I'm not sure what to make of ice yet, but i get a pretty strong desire to get soap when he posts. He seems to like to point fingers, and that can't be a good thing right?

These are just a few of my thoughts for now...

if I don't get a chance to do this later:

I recant my vote for FF and change it to JL

He saves FF, but states that he does not think FF is innocent.

CCM, do you think I am the prime evil, is that why you would choose one person over the other if you thought both of us were evil?

 

[johnlarson66]

I am FF's daddy not yours. (your own thoughts).

Do your own homework. I posted my suspect list after I got home from work. read the thread.

So you are not willing to answer the same questions you ask me?

You tell me to do my own homework, but yet you beg for a vote count?

Really, tell us what day one scumminess you saw.

 

[johnlarson66]

Final votes:

(4) FF - JL(19) JRR(87) CCM(145) Annie(155) Rich311k(216) ILM(332)
(0) CCM - Madcrawdad(109) the Wiz(164)
(1) Maelsrom - DD(140)
(3) Ice - Lab(180) Kashta(188) Bio(194) Maelstrom(287) Noodles(347) FF(363)
(1) Noodles - Ice(238)
(3) Biohazard - the wizard(239) Lady G(265) Kashta(361) Madcrawdad(383)
(4) Labrat - Annie(335) Noodles(484) Ice(511) Madcrawdad (529)
(1) Annie - Dawg(342)
(1) ILM - Bio(377)
(1) JL - CCM(449)

Ice, if me and JJR are on the mafia team, we deserve to lose. We were the first two votes on FF. We are even the first two votes.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Let me ask you this,disregarding my rhetorical question to him, do you not think he sidestepped some pointed questions from Kashta yesterday?

And if he did wouldn't you consider that scummy?

If he disregarded answering valid questions, then yes...

With that said, using post 460 as example, the tone of the questioning was condescending, some questions seemed rhetorical, and a few others may have not been readily answerable. It seemed like more of an opportunity for Kash to call JL scum, as opposed to actually gathering any information to help her make a decision.

But even in spite of that, I do remember JL answering to that post.

Can you point out just the most important question of Kashta's that went unanswered (in your opinion)?