Mafia #75... Assassins in the Palace - The Play

[Lady G]

Here's your post that has me confused LG...



I'll break it down as I read it...red in quotes is you and the rest is my interpretation.

"Hmmm, ok Dawg" that's me...."you say this as if you KNOW who is a guard?" yes I did say that as if I knew User was a guard...because JB just got through telling us that User was a guard. "IMO, there is only ONE person who would know that and that would be the assassin, because know one else knows anything except who the King is." wrong!! we all knew at that point JB had already told us. Now if I'm reading this wrong please show me what I'm missing.

The way you posted it IMO, looks like you already knew before hand. Sorry, still not changing my mind about you Dawg...I think you post was scummy and I think you trying to force ppl to believe I didn't know and said I didn't know what user was was scummy. I think you are putting up way to much of a fight to stay alive. Shouldn't you as a "guard" not want the Assassin to know more then one "guard" tonight. Wouldn't it be better to go ahead and take you out so they wont get another name too? Isn't that kinda your logic?

 

[Lady G]

I'm not backtracking I'm trying to find out what is really going on here. Is this between me and LG one big misunderstanding or is she really full of crap.

Hmmm, lets see...YOU said I said something I didn't, YOU kept trying to push that, YOU now are trying to bring up something else. Who is full of crap...me thinks you are dear.

 

[dirtydawg10]

The way you posted it IMO, looks like you already knew before hand. Sorry, still not changing my mind about you Dawg...I think you post was scummy and I think you trying to force ppl to believe I didn't know and said I didn't know what user was was scummy. I think you are putting up way to much of a fight to stay alive. Shouldn't you as a "guard" not want the Assassin to know more then one "guard" tonight. Wouldn't it be better to go ahead and take you out so they wont get another name too? Isn't that kinda your logic?

I'm still not following you so I'll just have to agree to disagree. As far as voting me out I have no issue with that. The problem I see is if I go and you all learn what I am I suspect it will not look good for you LG. The problem I have with that is I don't think the assassin would be pushing as hard as you and I are right now. I think the assassin is more likely to be FF or Tay who can just jump on a lynch vote and ride the wave. I don't see the assassin making too many waves this early in the game. JMO.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Hmmm, lets see...YOU said I said something I didn't, YOU kept trying to push that, YOU now are trying to bring up something else. Who is full of crap...me thinks you are dear.

You want to vote me out because you think that I thought that I knew what User was before JB told us even though I said it after JB told us. That sounds like crap to me.:thm:

 

[Lady G]

I'm still not following you so I'll just have to agree to disagree. As far as voting me out I have no issue with that. The problem I see is if I go and you all learn what I am I suspect it will not look good for you LG. The problem I have with that is I don't think the assassin would be pushing as hard as you and I are right now. I think the assassin is more likely to be FF or Tay who can just jump on a lynch vote and ride the wave. I don't see the assassin making too many waves this early in the game. JMO.

I can live with that. I will take the heat IF you come back a guard. I do however appreciate your concern for how I will look.

 

[Lady G]

You want to vote me out because you think that I thought that I knew what User was before JB told us even though I said it after JB told us. That sounds like crap to me.:thm:

Dawg, you have pushed way to hard to just be a guard IMO. Remember back to your post to Tay where you asked her...would you rather "out" another guard...you don't seem to really stand behind that to much when the vote is on you do ya

 

[Fishfriend1]

I'm not backtracking I'm trying to find out what is really going on here. Is this between me and LG one big misunderstanding or is she really full of crap.

Um, your the one who brought the whole thing up...

I'm still not following you so I'll just have to agree to disagree. As far as voting me out I have no issue with that. The problem I see is if I go and you all learn what I am I suspect it will not look good for you LG. The problem I have with that is I don't think the assassin would be pushing as hard as you and I are right now. I think the assassin is more likely to be FF or Tay who can just jump on a lynch vote and ride the wave. I don't see the assassin making too many waves this early in the game. JMO.

Just because Tay and i would be IDEAL assassins due to our mafia prowess and ability to totally hop onto any trains made doesn't make us the assassin.

Also, if you really think that LG or myself is evil, say so, and if so then you should be happy that you are gonna be lynched, cause it will make LG and myself look bad.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg, you have pushed way to hard to just be a guard IMO. Remember back to your post to Tay where you asked her...would you rather "out" another guard...you don't seem to really stand behind that to much when the vote is on you do ya

I have 2 votes on me and Razz has 2 votes. I haven't voted yet so what on earth are you talking about?

I would love to get voted out of this game right now. It's driving me nuts. I'm beginning to know how Ice was feeling about getting voted out last game.

 

[Taysius]

I'm still not following you so I'll just have to agree to disagree. As far as voting me out I have no issue with that. The problem I see is if I go and you all learn what I am I suspect it will not look good for you LG. The problem I have with that is I don't think the assassin would be pushing as hard as you and I are right now. I think the assassin is more likely to be FF or Tay who can just jump on a lynch vote and ride the wave. I don't see the assassin making too many waves this early in the game. JMO.

I believe I'm the one that started the waves on you, Dawg. It's just that someone else started the voting part. Also note that I retracted my vote to see what else you've got to say. We've got time and there is no need to get all lynch happy tonight.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Has Razz played before? I was thinking it was their first game...just don't remember the name.

Yeah, he's played. I played the gunslinger game with him and one or two others. He likes to not post until he's under fire.

After 4 votes User was a done deal. He was guaranteed not to be the King at that point. If I was the assassin I would have wanted to keep User around and take out someone else so I would know who 2 people were. Now the assassin knows only one of us.

This makes sense.

Can you explain that to me Lab? What doesn't make sense?

You explained it better above, makes sense now.

I'm not here to out guards so my answer is no. I want to lynch the assassin. I don't get why you still think 4 votes on someone renders them useless. There is more to protecting the King than just body blocking.

I have to agree with Dawg, it wouldn't make sense to be that close to a majority of votes on the king. A couple of votes, yes, but not when one more vote gets them the lynch.

Also, UN was dead weight since he wasn't even bothering to read the rules or what people are posting in the game. Totally unhelpful if you don't read what others post.

The assassin does not know who the guards are or who the King is. Just that all of us are against them. If the assassin has a living player who they know is not the King they don't necessarily want to kill them. The assassin would rather have 7 players alive who they know are not the King. Then they know who the King is. The assassins role is to kill the King...not to kill the guards.

Again, makes sense.

You know who i am right? I say something, and do the opposite without a care in the world. i am reliably unreliable ;D

This is not something I would play up FF.

Yes by my logic as well once the town puts a person within 1 vote of the lynch, the assassin knows that person is not king. Keeping around known guards is in the assassin's interrest if we move on and out another person.

If another vote came in on Dawg before you retracted I would have finsihed him off eventhough I'm not seeing the same thing you guys are. I'm not clearing him jusy not seeing the same case you guys are.

I agree with your logic Chill.

You sure seem to know what the assassin would want don't ya :thumbsup:

Not to defend Dawg (since he may well be the assassin), but I think he's the only one of us who has actually played this format before.

To put other thoughts out there, what is the consensus on Raz?

Razz typically doesn't post. In this format, I think it's important we post so the assassin is exposed. It would be way too easy for them to lay low and avoid detection by not posting. It's why my vote is on Razz for now.

I'm still not following you so I'll just have to agree to disagree. As far as voting me out I have no issue with that. The problem I see is if I go and you all learn what I am I suspect it will not look good for you LG. The problem I have with that is I don't think the assassin would be pushing as hard as you and I are right now. I think the assassin is more likely to be FF or Tay who can just jump on a lynch vote and ride the wave. I don't see the assassin making too many waves this early in the game. JMO.

Me either, but Dawg, it scares me to agree with you so much. You totally snowed me in the RR game...