MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[Malbri]

I didnt vote because I honestly had no idea, its my first game so im trying to get into the flow of things, yet still try to contribute what I can without making osme huge mistake that is going to make everyone think im mafia

 

[Sploke]

3) ? undecided- i have inklings of bad mojo coming from sploke and cory lover, although that last one just may be habit

Edit...my list has changed...

1.Jo
2.Malbri
3.Z
4.Sploke

1. Judgemax
2. Sploke
3. DD
4. bkw but really weak and basically just my gut instinct.

No offence to any of you - you just flickered my mafia meter.

I change my vote to lynch Sploke

Nope not fully. Here they are :

2. Sploke...first post made me queasy...voting for Malbri made me very interested. Defending JM

sploke, has given me no reason to think anything...

Dangit, this posting sequense is still nagging at me. 3 people named me as suspicious, and one even voted for me. The mafia know I'm innocent. If JM was mafia, I feel like she would have jumped on and tried to get something started with that. Maybe I'm more inconsequential to the game than I thought, but I dunno that is still casting a doubt in my mind about her. This is frustrating.

 

[Sploke]

Well see that's what bothers me. Ice switched, Coler retracted, then switched, and Ogre retracted then didn't vote. And there were two or three others that didn't vote at all but I saw them watching the thread. I'm so totally confused at this point. I think a lot of folks are since there are very few votes so far. On the other hand johnlarson is bugging me because of how quickly he jumped back on joander, but then again that was how he voted last game as well.

I'm of the mind that coler switched to try and draw out some mafia. If he had been the tipping vote (I'm not sure, after coler retracted his vote, would it have been even/one up for jo?) then it would make sense that mafia would try to switch to swing it back to clown, knowing he was innocent. But, the posting times are so close its impossible to know if Ice was aware that coler had switched when ice himself switched. confused yet?

 

[Coler]

Day one analysis, mostly of judgemax :

I vote to lynch jo, because of the last statement here..he just screwed up and claimed mafia

post 59...first vote of the game (except for me voting for me)

These next two were after voting for Joander. There is a very fair chance that Joander made a slip up but not a true mafia slip up...new to the game :

wanted to add to is this your sad attempt to cover up, the direction from the don?...

post 67

ha-ha, did coler loan you the soap box, lmao!

post 73

Then after some vague hypothetical suggestions that judgemax could be the Don. Does the following post ring true :

LMAO..I would make a great don, lol, however, its not going to happen in this game.not sure if i could pull it off, lmao, i almost got myself killed as an innocent, couldn't imagine having to be mafia..

post 85

I list judge as a suspect then she says I and Jo are mafia (note, that interaction between me and jo did indeed look very pally, mafia style. This is not however what it was) :

OK, you can all watch me, however, i will be leaving to take the brats to the park, ..Coler, are you throwing suspicion my way, cause I found your friend jo?..lol, you should get your soap box back, hes not using it very well

post 110

Nothing then until post 149...only a suspicion of jo...why the vote ?

I see no need to get serious here folks, at least not yet, I have jokingly called a few people out, in truth, I am suspicious of just jo, and thats about it, we all know, that coler, and KOTD, OGRE AND JL , ICE, they all scare me, they are all great, and influential players, lol..I doubt any of them are going to be giving anything away (esp so early) ..my votes are always subject to change, and I will not repeatedly scream I am innocent through out the game, its a waste of my time and yours, =i will say it here, and now, I am innocent, and for those that choose to believe ,great, lets get them, and for those that don't well, Thats your problem..Cause I don't know what to tell ya..

Where did the suggestion that clown and joander are top suspects come from ?

well, if you guys want other suspects at this point, I guess that malbri would be my second guess, she has constantly stuck up for everyone else..Most especially jo, and I feel strongly that jo made a newbie mistake.

I am also looking at Clown lover, ..not only is it hard to have two CL's, lol, its awfully early to act so serious IMHO..I can't help but think, one that comes on that strong, and hasn't played before, ..maybe needing ti hide something, hes either a very smart person, or very dangerous,

post 178

Well 197 post later and its better then last game....not to much role playing, some good looks, and Jo pulling a cory-love on day one...lol fun times.

watch list
1. joander, mainly for this statment:



For all the post about how you don't know how to play the game and you're confused how can you be certain this is not what you do. To me this is where u messed up.

2. clown-lover, the post about how members from last game hav a higher chance of being mafia make me think he doesn't know wht the word random means, or it's misdirection.

3 colar.....colar ur just colar and spike everyones radar, even when we're not playin the game lol.

post 203

Ok,. I guess it's list time.... there are a few people who I am set onwatching closely.

1)joander- your posts are either really, really attributed to newness, or you are mafia and didn;t know what to do

2)clown-lover - super weak, but I don't have good "let's trust him vibes" from you

3) ? undecided- i have inklings of bad mojo coming from sploke and cory lover, although that last one just may be habit

Just my thoughts for now. I will vote tomorrow before i go see HP5.

Until then: good night and good luck!

~brandy

post 299

Then the hissy fit :

ok, well whatever, you guys will see, I am not going to proclaim my innocence a hundred times, . I am having a good time, and Right now, i have the time to do it, i won't tomorrow, and whats it matter?, i give up, you guys wanna lynch me day one, ok, do it, i have done nothing wrong, and have tried to not copy so much,like NJ pointed out, forgive me for trying to learn, ! I guess, when the smoke clears, and you see my name, youll know, your down a townie..., i have two kids to bath, so, unless they go to bed early , i won't be on till later, is that alright, or will that make me look mafia to?..

post 229 07:38, 15th of July 2007

20 mins later :

this is really it, ..i gave a list already, read back, ...see if i get in a good mood, and try and play a game with yall anymore...

post 314

Is this a guarded warning from a colleague ?

Im srry judge i don't see anything HN said that could be taken offense. IMO using posting habits from old games is a good tatic, the post are there for everyone to read, so if Hn derived at a conclusion that you're mafia from your post habits i see nothing wrong. Please don't leave just caused you're named....honestly it makes me watch you closer because u reacted so poorly

post 235 (my italics)

Apparently JM still has no strong opinions - ref back to first vote cast in the game. That's a strong opinion.

kinda, lolI was just throwing suspicions, I said before i really have no full on He is mafia hunches yet, although,



and yes here to, i think jo, acted very much like Cl from last game, and slipped up, and was expecting a much different reaction than what he got, ..

post 253

OK, I have read until my eyes are blurry,I still see no other person to vote for at this point, except jo, whether hes innocent or not, I feel like he told on himself, ..thats me feeling, i am gonna stick it out, ..

whether he's innocent or not post 299

After I say I think sploke is dodgy because I voted for him and nobody followed (i.e. why didn't a load of mafia jump on him). Defence of sploke ?

Not to burst any bubbles, but Its highly unlikely, that a "a load" of Mafia, are going to be jumping on anyone, There are only 4. I think watching who votes when is going to be almost fruitless this game since there are so few.

I am also still concerned with what "appears" means In RB's post, he has not answered that yet, It would be helpful to know, If there really is more Mafia, I would like to know how many I am dealing with, I maybe looking to much into things, I can't help but wonder why it says "appears" LOL..

yeah but not even one vote following, after an innocent nails their colours to the mast, somewhat ? post 352

This by the way is randomly quite wierd, remember JM and DD posting against Malbri earlier, and why vote Malbri because "Jo has the most votes" :

and since Jo has the most votes, I vote to lynch Malbri...
I have been at work all day, and finally caught up to this post...

So...something to think about JM

 

[judgemax]

Right now I'm split between a vote for JM or Ice. JM's postings are just making me nervous, it seems every 5 minutes she's got an excuse as to why she won't be around...thats fine, we all have lives (well some of us, I don't...) but I dunno something just strikes me as off. Ice's vote change last night caught me as strange as well. but I just don't know what to think of it. I've reviewed the flurry of posts in the last hour or so before night last night, and feel more unsure than ever about anything, so I'm not voting now, but unless something drastic changes, my vote tonight will be for one of those two. Whoever the mafia is this time around, they're doing a good job of keeping us confused. The events last night helped a little but not much. We now know that coler is most likely innocent, but still no sure leads on possible mafia. Blast.

By the way if anyone thinks I'm crazy with either of those two, please give me some other options. Like I said, just hunches, I would love some reasoning or solid justification.

Sploke, just so you know, I got called on not being in the last game at certain times, I am just Informing people, so No one questions why I am not posting, if you see my name here, its usually because I leave my browser open, ..thats all..hope that clears it up.

 

[Coler]

So

I vote to lynch Judgemax

who presumably strongly believes in a) my innocence and b) joanders guilt ?

 

[Coler]

'who' above = JM

 

[Coler]

and my list of suspects :

Judgemax
Dangerdoll
Sploke
bkw (weak suspicion)

My other candidates :

Ogre
Mee-Mee
Ice (pretty much only for the late change to clown-lover; gotta admit it was unfortunate at best ice)

 

[jpappy789]

Agreed, at the moment.



Not sure about the mafia thing, but the more jo posts, the more I'm beginning to lean toward another innocent. Its possible that the mafia figured if they could swing the vote to clown, we would go back after jo afterward and waste two nights lynching innocents. That maybe be giving them too much credit, but its plausible.

If that was the case, then jpappy comes off my list as well, since my whole reasoning was, I thought jo was mafia, and jpappy was telling him to basically cool it or he'd get lynched. If jo is innocent, that theory falls apart.

Ice and Jensons are definitely suspect for that last minute voting for clown. I still don't understand that one, but whatever. KOTD is also tentatively on my list. He was quiet and pretty subdued all last game and ended up being the Don, but I'm not sure if he's just a less-vocal player than some in general. Its hard to get a read from the quiet ones.


Right now on my "presumed innocent" list is HN, ZSand, coler and mal, and I think I've given reasons for all those already at some point. Comments?

What? When did I tell joander to cool it? I said that he was acting like cl in game 4 and that's why everybody was jumping on him. I was just as suspiciuis as everbody else. If you seriously want to lynch me because of some connection between jo and I then go ahead, but time will tell the real story...

 

[Coler]

Dangit, this posting sequense is still nagging at me. 3 people named me as suspicious, and one even voted for me. The mafia know I'm innocent. If JM was mafia, I feel like she would have jumped on and tried to get something started with that. Maybe I'm more inconsequential to the game than I thought, but I dunno that is still casting a doubt in my mind about her. This is frustrating.

Sorry...you're still on my list.

a) 'and no one even voted for me' - I did

b) If JM is mafia there is one clear and good reason why she would not have jumped on me voting for you...take a guess ?