MAFIA #5 The Play.....

rbishop said:
Social Rules
The Vigilante...a total wild card...he can kill once per game by sending me a PM at the start of the game night. The Vigilante can be an Innocent or a Mafia, and strike against either.
Click to expand...

The mafia are allowed talk amongst each other.

This is a rules question; if the vigilante is mafia is this know amongst the mafia. The quote above suggests the vigilante can be innocent or a mafia. That says to me that if he's mafia that is known to the mafia.

But I may be wrong...Perhaps rbishop could clarify this EDIT IF it is an ambiguity in the rules. All we need to know is whether the vigilante, if mafia, is part of the mafia mob, or appears innocent to all persons even if investigated, by either side, and if mafia that this is unknown to the mafia.

I say if it is an ambiguity, because perhaps we are not meant to know the answer.
 
Coler said:
Ogre...you are telling us that KOTD is innocent and the vigilante I take it...that might not have been a good idea...now the mafia know who he is, and he has basically got until tonight to use his hit...before he is taken out.

That is pretty crummy detective play :D

Wasn't there enough stuff out there in ZS's game to show him up as mafia, if that's what we now must clearly believe ?
Click to expand...

I'm saying that Coler is the vig... I got nothing else. I'm not assuming anything at this point. rb could let JMax come back as zombie mafia for all I know now... shudder.

Z is very good at this.
 
OgreMkV said:
I'm saying that Coler is the vig... I got nothing else. I'm not assuming anything at this point. rb could let JMax come back as zombie mafia for all I know now... shudder.

Z is very good at this.
Click to expand...

I think this might have been meant for your buddies :D
 
Dangerdoll said:
gosh things have certainly taken quite a turn and I was about to believe you 200% Z...... until this post.... this kinda freaked me out, made my heart drop kind of thing. What with the font size change for BKW?
Click to expand...

I keep my notes in a word document, it always screws up the font when I copy over, and it doesn't show in the preview. The top line is like that too.
 
Ogre is definitely mafia

I'm getting close to 100% that Ice is

Ogre's post pretty much shows me KOTD as well...had to name a fake vigilante and it had to be someone who would play along
 
Coler said:
Don't know if I buy this.

Who was trying to lynch you...today it was JL...can you save us a bit of work and tell us the other efforts ?
Click to expand...

jl voted for me yes, but there were more subtle workings.

OgreMkV said:
Coler, I like your list and I think EVERYONE should do the same at this point. I think that will help us see who is what.

BTW: Lexie is feeling better, but still not 100% so I'll be in and out for a day or so still. In case anyone was wondering, she had a stomach virus that caused (because of inactivity) another case of mastitis. She probably wouldn't want me telling you this, but she's in bed with Xander right now. Just so there's no question of my abnormal posting.

I'll work on a list and get that up before night fall (hopefully).

mee-mee and Jensons remain strong suspects for me at this time. JohnLarson (have fun on vacation) is still voting weird though. Zsand? Is there going to be a push for him?

Malbri missed another vote (according to my notes), so they might be gone tomorrow.
Click to expand...

Bolded for clarity.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom