I love LEDs so Im partial but i will state a case for LEDs.I really appreciate your contributions to the subject, I think I would be more inclined to t8, I just don't like leds very much, I think tanks look very artificial with them, but that's just my liking and opinion, I know that many people are very taste with leds.
I agree with you that certain LEds make that tank look "artificial" as you put it. But many LEDs nowadays are adjustable. You can create the colors that you want by adjusting the light. MIne does that. I love it.
It also grows plants well.
But i doubt you'll cahnge you mind.