Yes, I tried reading the Silmarillion, too, Fungi. I think it does give good background information, but doesn't hold my attention long enough to make a good read. Like you said there are some underdeveloped characters and a lot of side notes. I suppose that's why it's not quite as popular as the other books. I would like to learn Elvish one of these days, though.On that note, have you read the Silmarillion plant? I tried... just to give myself some background to the books but I found it way too difficult, it spends about three pages introducing a character, only to never mention them again for the rest of the entire book/novel/collection/whatever it is.
And thanks for the suggestions, Shoreliner. I agree that Robert Duvall and Tommy Lee Jones are fine actors. I don't mind books w/some misery and suffering, but I perfer those that don't leave you feeling gloomy.