Mafia 101 - Blarney Castle: Return of the Leprechauns - Game Thread

[Lady G]

Because Toes is obvious scum. And even though Kashta and Wizard are probably more dangerous if scum the numbers aren't there to lynch them.

I assume you have played this game before correct? So you would know things are not always as they seem and things can change in the blink of an eye right? It is my experience that most the time when someone has pretty much the entire town on them, they end up being innocent. Now of course there are times that is not true and this very well could be one of those times...that statement that Chill was the only one who knew he was evil is very curious, and my vote may very well end up back on them...but right now, Kash and Dawg depending on his answers (I will say, what he has answered so far seems up and up) have my attention.

 

[Lady G]

I just want to add one other thing that did make me pull my vote on O3T (for now)....in the nightfall, Labby did not say Chill was the NC Lep and most games that is revealed if it is the case. Of course I have no idea how Labby would call it.

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

I assume you have played this game before correct? So you would know things are not always as they seem and things can change in the blink of an eye right? It is my experience that most the time when someone has pretty much the entire town on them, they end up being innocent. Now of course there are times that is not true and this very well could be one of those times...that statement that Chill was the only one who knew he was evil is very curious, and my vote may very well end up back on them...but right now, Kash and Dawg depending on his answers (I will say, what he has answered so far seems up and up) have my attention.

I just want to add one other thing that did make me pull my vote on O3T (for now)....in the nightfall, Labby did not say Chill was the NC Lep and most games that is revealed if it is the case. Of course I have no idea how Labby would call it.

Both are good points and if enough players deem Kashta votable I'd consider moving. But it is hard to overlook Toes comment,even if his statement of making a mistake is plausible, I'd hate to let one slip through the cracks.

 

[allaboutfish]

right now i see no reason to move. mostly bc the majority are already on 3toes. i do think he's scum though, along with hi iq

 

[Lady G]

Both are good points and if enough players deem Kashta votable I'd consider moving. But it is hard to overlook Toes comment,even if his statement of making a mistake is plausible, I'd hate to let one slip through the cracks.

Understandable

I had planned one waiting to see if Kash answered and what she said...but after thinking more about it, I can't help but think Kash is evil.

I vote to lynch Kash Her posts have me very quipped at this point, I'm seeing her "Dawg is to valuable" post as a trying to suck up to a innocent, and she was just wrong about my vote to Chill as a normal day one vote for me, I know this may not seem like much but I can't help but feel "Evil Kash" when reading her posts

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

Besides, I have this feeling that Kashta,Toes and maybe the Wizard are teammates and why after he screwed up they came after him for going after AAF. I think AAF is probably innocent and why they didn't move there to get him lynched. It wouldn't look good to move from one innocent to another even if it told them more about Toes. Which is another point that makes me think they are teammates. I don't think they wondered about Toes but since he screwed up they could use that as an excuse. Wizard even voted Toes Day 1"randomly" *cough* distance vote *cough* plus by befriending AAF he won't vote against them but with them.

 

[Lady G]

Both are good points and if enough players deem Kashta votable I'd consider moving. But it is hard to overlook Toes comment,even if his statement of making a mistake is plausible, I'd hate to let one slip through the cracks.

right now i see no reason to move. mostly bc the majority are already on 3toes. i do think he's scum though, along with hi iq

I certainly want everyone to vote who the feel is most likely scum and I'm not trying to force your hand or bully you into any vote...but are either of you thinking for yourself or just following the crowd? I do agree the post of O3T is questionable...but you both have stated how everyone else is voting them so you don't want to move. As I said I do want you to vote who you feel is scum, I just want to be sure you are voting from your own thoughts and not just because it's "popular" at the moment.

 

[Lady G]

Besides, I have this feeling that Kashta,Toes and maybe the Wizard are teammates and why after he screwed up they came after him for going after AAF. I think AAF is probably innocent and why they didn't move there to get him lynched. It wouldn't look good to move from one innocent to another even if it told them more about Toes. Which is another point that makes me think they are teammates. I don't think they wondered about Toes but since he screwed up they could use that as an excuse. Wizard even voted Toes Day 1"randomly" *cough* distance vote *cough* plus by befriending AAF he won't vote against them but with them.

Thank you, a thought of your own...and one I can see plausible...not sure on Wiz right now, will have to see more before I have any thoughts on him

 

[allaboutfish]

I certainly want everyone to vote who the feel is most likely scum and I'm not trying to force your hand or bully you into any vote...but are either of you thinking for yourself or just following the crowd? I do agree the post of O3T is questionable...but you both have stated how everyone else is voting them so you don't want to move. As I said I do want you to vote who you feel is scum, I just want to be sure you are voting from your own thoughts and not just because it's "popular" at the moment.

im not even on old3toes. im on HI IQ

 

[the wizard]

I'm back at home and don't see much to add at this point. I am getting pretty interested in the interaction around Fozzybear though. Muppets and bad joke aside.

I asked Fozzy a few pretty direct questions that largely went unanswered. When I pointed out to Fozzy that he had not answered, he came back with this post:


This post sort of touches the questions, but never really comes out and answers them.

Then Kash says she wants to hear the answer to my original question.

Then Wiz says he wants the answer. Wiz states that Fozzy "danced around the issue" which could be in reference to the post of Fozzy's that I quoted.


So...
Fozzy: who do you find more scummy for their actions, Dawg or O3T. I understand that your style is to use metaphor and flowery language, but a direct answer here would be helpful. also, a brief explanation for your answer would be lovely.

Kash: when you called for Fozzy to answer my original question, had you missed the post that I quoted above or were you calling for clarification of that post?

Wiz: is the post I quoted what you referred to as Fozzy "dancing around" the question? What do you think of Fozzy so far overall?

OK, I did make it home and will be around for night fall.

Yes JB, the post you pulled is the one I refered to when I said he danced around the issue. My thoughts of him so far are that he fit in well with the D1 banter, but the game hasn't progressed enough to make a determination of his role.

I do have reservations about a player not answering a direct question and find that to be vote worthy behavior if it persists.