that is an interesting point. however i have no clue which one might be hippy scum, if either. neph seems a bit more sincere to me but Jpap seems very logical and mechanical in his posts. almost too machine like. im not saying that makes him guilty but it makes me wonder, his posts seem devoid of emotion or gut feeling. like almost lacking a human element. but i still feel like i need to mull it over in my head and see what else they say. not to mention continue to digest the pages of posts that happened after nightfall.
First you like my posts because they are logical, but now you bring up the fact that I'm "too machine like"...you can't have both.
If you've ever seen me post in mafia or on AC in general you would know that I'm not a "gut feel" type of person. I tend to call those people out, in fact (see below).
Its really more of a gut feel, but for some reason they just sound off to me.
Either ssuchem is doing incredibly well or hes being coached.
Blobs not helping at all and making no since.
These are my top 3 suspects at the time. Not really in an order.
Sent from my iPhone using
MonsterAquariaNetwork app
AAF, your lack of digging as well as naming Neph based on just a "gut feel," at this stage of the game, is not helpful at all.
And Neph's recent vote on Ice... happened while I was postin.g
While Ice is an aggressive player and may be ok with Neph voting for him (if they are hypothetically on a team), I just don't see their interactions as distancing.
i vote to lynch neph mostly a gut feeling on the way hes posting. This is subject to change.
Sent from my iPhone using
MonsterAquariaNetwork app
Can we get ANY posts at all that point to Neph being vote worthy?
A few things...
I really wish that we never had to worry about this vote-doubling business... It almost feels like cheating when trying to figure out who's who from that... Anyway, I'm going to make a list on scumminess.
Scale from 1-10, with 10 being the scummiest.
AAF 4 Really hard to get a read. Hasn't posted much, would really like to see more. If I had to lean one way, it would be innocent, but that's honestly just a gut feeling.
Jpappy 6 Also hard to get a read, but not for lack of posting. I think JPap is crucial to whichever side he is on, which makes me wary to vote for him. He seems to be acting pro-town, and I haven't seen anything crazy yet. He's another where I would lean towards innocent.
Blobdabob 4 I put myself in his shoes, and I think that he is innocent. I remember my 2nd game (1st not on a team), and it was so different, and really hard to know what to say.
Ice 7 I think Ice is creeping me out the most. I can't quite put my finger on it, although one of the posts that scared me was when he said what he would have done as BF. It looked like he was trying to tell BF what to do after BF's blunder with Rich N1. Not sure yet.
Chill 4 I wish he would post some, I guess it's hectic, but I haven't seen anything scummy, so I will wait to see more, I guess.
ssuchem ?? No idea. (S)He's following JPap around, maybe just from being new, maybe not, another one I will wait and see.
Nephereal 7 The more I read from Neph, the more I begin to think Neph is scum, with Ice. Ice and Neph have been pretty cuddly IMO, and I think that Neph's vote on Ice D2 was for some distancing.
I would really like to see others' lists.
How can you say I'm leaning innocent when I'm the third highest rated person and on the 50/50 side closer to scum?
You have the more vocal players as scum, which concerns me since those are the only people who seem to be working to flush out the hippies. I see no reason to lean AAF or Chill, especially, towards innocent when neither have done anything to dig up scum.
If JB got the double vote he would know Neph was scum. At the same time he being a PR,which we now know, wouldn't want to go right after Neph especially since the main threat Rich is gone. Going after Neph could tip off BF that he was an innocent and get himself hit. If JB got the double I could see him using it to make sure Lab went home as she is a big threat. Especially since he placed his vote after I did making sure it wouldn't be wasted and putting her tied with blob with an hr left. Then Lab moved to blob and blob to lab.
If JB knew Neph was scum, why wouldn't the hunter use one of their hits on a confirmed hippie? They have two shots, so one would still be left if they found bigfoot later (unfortunately JB is dead so by the looks of it the PR team has no more invests anyways).
I also don't understand how JB voting Neph would tip off bigfoot seeing as the bigfoot doesn't know who anyone else is...this would make more sense if Neph was bigfoot and JB didn't want to make a sudden move there. That could tip off bigfoot AND the rest of the hippies.
This isn't to say that Neph is innocent, I'm just not following this theory that JB got the double vote/invest. There's really no way of knowing since 1) He's dead and 2) the remaining players can apparently only deny getting the vote.
Sorry i just dont believe in basing much off of day 1. You can look at past games.
Sent from my iPhone using
MonsterAquariaNetwork app
You've said that multiple times. Problem for you is...it's not D1 anymore. Your lack of effort has been noticeable throughout the entire game.
I don't know why people keep getting this idea. All along I have suspected you, pir, and pap (I may have commented at AAF also). I have said what has made me vote where I voted and have specifically voted for you for 2 nights. Pap came front and center in my eyes when he made a comment about lab whom I had pegged as innocent. He made me doubt her innocence then you had your thought about the double vote and that's when I went in that direction. Once I found out otherwise I completely recanted and went right back to where I was... voting for you and keeping an eye on pir.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S3 using the MAN app!
Neph, am I really on your list because I called out Lab?
While I regret doing so since that may have played a part in her lynching, I'm uneasy that you had her "pegged as innocent." Before nightfall you debated switching to break up the tie and said that you weren't convinced Lab was scum. Right after she flipped innocent you specifically said you had a
feeling she was innocent. Now you had her
pegged? That's quite a step up from what you claimed in your own posts.
I really shouldnt have played this one. Im not in the mafia mood at all.
Sent from my iPhone using
MonsterAquariaNetwork app
Convenient excuse.
