I'm not going to quote the entire run-down over AAF's comment, but the fact that he was effectively lynched for that one comment, which I took when I read it as a joke, is scary. From what I saw, Neph commented on Jpaps comment, and then Coler questioned the entire thing. I personally think it was initially just an honest little compliment, but when Coler questioned it Neph defended it.
Dawg and Zaffy, during this entire thing, completely refrain from looking at it. This comes to me as odd, since it was about the only game-related subject at the time. Zaffy is the dead doc, so probably trying to lay low, but Dawg is an unknown.
ForeverNewb
(referencing myself). Colers earlier post where he listed the people he was looking at seemed useful, but honestly didn't add anything new to the game except that he was interested in people who were posting fluff to look helpful. I got a bit of a pot meet kettle feeling when he made that comment.I would like to take this time to comment that it WAS day 1, with almost nothing to go on. Day 1 is always a crapshoot, so I find it interesting that people kept saying that voting for BS reasons was dumb/unusual/scummy. From my experience, unless something big happens on Day 1, joke votes are all that it amounts to, with Day 2 being the day that people get serious, building from they lay of the votes on day 1. Also, why did no one question Dawgs vote on Zaffy for 'his avatar giving me a headache'? That was as bad as mine, but he was never questioned.
And the nightfall events... I'll start with the vote fall out:
Votes:
Allaboutfish – Fishfriend1 (027)Joke Vote, Coler (64)Because of post 61, Zaffy (72)To 'remove idiocy'(and post 61) JPappy (83) Because of post 61
Zaffy – Dirtydawg10 (037)Joke Vote,
Coler - Rich311k (054)Joke Vote, Nepherael (71)OMGUSy, Allaboutfish (73)BS Vote,
Fishfriend1 - Metric (068)No Answers,
So, from what I see here, Coler, Zaffy, and Jpappy all voted for AAF almost entirely because of the manner in which he chose his vote, which was not that bad considering I voted him because I saw pretty betta at the fish store and was jealous of his betta. Or Dawgs because it 'gave him a headache'. Or Rich's because Coler 'hadn't played in a while'. While I do see why his choice of vote and the way he chose was scummy, I still find it strange that he was heavily questioned while none of the other lousy and joking votes.
As for the nightfall write up, while it was sad we lost AAF and a tad bit suspicious that the three kill votes on him were for the same reason, he did bring it upon himself a little. The fact that no one voted Neph but many people posted that they were suspicious of him also interests me, as people (like Jpappy) mentioned it in multiple posts leading up to nightfall but still voted elsewhere. The votes on Coler are all rather strange... a joke, an OMGUSY, and a BS. Can't really read anything from that. The vote on me by Metric was probably the most justified vote of Day 1, and that one was because I wasn't able to get on and answer questions.
Sorry to see you go Zaffy, but at least it was a funny way to go. Crushed by a Snorlax. At least you didn't get sung to death by Jigglypuff... And the drag lol! But I shouldn't be laughing, you'll be missed.
As of right now, I still think all of you could be scum. However, I think that Dawg, Neph, and the other people to vote AAF are all a bit more likely for scum. I'll probably end up voting one of the people I just listed for one of the reasons I just listed.
And here is the kicker:
"Delibird hands you a Pokeball. You let its inhabitant out and a Victreebel pops out. You try to ask Delibird more, but it's frivolous because the only words it can say are "deli" and "bird". Delibird flies away, but crashes into a window. It then hops around in a circle for a few minutes before flying sideways into the nearest tree. You decide to leave it alone." - Pir with neither deny nor confirm this, as per the pm.
Pir sent this to me at nightfall, and it makes me wonder... Victreebel is a plant-type pokemon, one that looks like a pitcher plant. It was more famously owned by James, of team rocket. That means to me that this hint is telling me who James is. The fact that the delibird was flying and moving so erraticly makes me think it was drunk. That in turn makes me think that James was discussing alcohal in the thread. That means Dawg, Zaffy (dead), Coler, Rich, or Metri (all the people who mentioned alcohol). Most likely Coler or Dawg, as Colers first post was saying he was a bit drunk and Dawg and Zaffy both chatted about beer. Zaffy is dead and the doc, so that leaves Dawg and Coler. Besides this, Dawg posted primarily about alcohol up until after night 1 was over.
Anyone else have their own interpritation?
